Low-key eatery serving a menu of NYC-style pizzas, plus pasta, subs, appetizers & wings. Based on 721 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
322 W Kenosha St, Broken Arrow, OK 74012
Phone: (918) 251-6666
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Teagan Lewis
Fantastic pizza! The individual slices are quite large, so even if you’re a fairly big eater you shouldn’t need more than two. They’re reasonably priced (a lot cheaper for a meal than most places these days), and the quality is incredible! I was very impressed. The staff here is so friendly, too. By far the best pizza place I’ve been to in Oklahoma.
… more
Adam Haley
We decided to try this place after an amazing review from a local food group. Well we were more than happy that we did. The good Lord introduced us to Greg, and he decided to join us for supper. Turns out, this establishment has a pay it forward program, just for an occasion such as this. So we got the pleasure of treating this man to dinner whilst someone else got the pleasure of buying. The staff went above and beyond in ensuring our dinner was freshly cooked and served with care and maybe a touch of love.
… more
Steve Pisonero
Amazing folks and the best NY style pizza in Tulsa!!!! And don’t forget the hot oil!!
… more
KMW creations
i am IMPRESSED. as someone from chicago it is very rare i find pizza i actually like in oklahoma. authentic NY pizza, and the best cannolis i’ve ever had! very nice staff and clean inside. 11/10 stars, i will definitely return
… more
MomOf3
I wish there was an option to give more than 5 stars. This place is absolutely amazing! 1st time we have ever ordered from here and we are from the east coast and love our NY style pizza! This is heaven and reminded me so much of home absolutely loved our pepperoni and sausage pizza it was so tasty! The garlic bread is good, the meat ball subs are a must as well! We also loved the lasagna! The pizza rolls are big and so tasty! No other pizza joint in town will ever come close to comparing to Vinny’s! Everything here was so so good my friends!! If you haven’t checked this place out then you are most certainly missing out! This place is a Gem & im now a forever fan.
… more
Alisha Aguero
We tried their pizza, pasta and desserts last night and they were all excellent! Amazing service! Definitely a family owned and operated business so please go and show your love! Don’t leave without trying their cake or cannollis!
… more
Sebastian Resendiz
I’ve tasted their pepperoni pizza and cheesecake. It’s some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. I recommend everyone try this location as opposed to a big fast food chain. It’s family owned and the employees are always super nice and friendly. I go at least once a week and I’m never disappointed.
… more
Sharon K. Deal
Delicious! I was looking for NY style pizza and found it. I tried the supreme without peppers. The crust was thin and crispy.just the way I like it. I also had a pizza roll. When you cut into it you see layers of cheese and pepperoni in this crispy rolled shell. The marinara is perfect. I tried the hot oil it got a little kick, good flavor, something I want to take home and try in other dishes. Tiramisu is for dessert and looks dreamy. I will come here again and drove from Bartlesville.
… more
Adrianne M
I’m originally from NYC and occasionally have cravings for NY style pizza.
… more
Rustybeard
I don’t know how I’ve been sleeping on this place. I must have driven by it a hundred times and not seen it. Anyway it caught my eye the other day so I decided to stop and man am I glad I did. I wasn’t super hungry but got a couple basic slices. It was perfect. So delicious and just the right amount for what I was wanting. Price was just right too. Less than $10 for lunch is always a win. I will definitely be back. I have to try the hot oil. I’ve never had it but it has great reviews. Definitely check this place out, it’s even worth the drive from anywhere to get some.
… more
… View more