Based on 321 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
886 W Bay Ave, Barnegat Township, NJ 08005
Phone: (609) 698-1511
Website: http://vinniesbarnegat.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Peter Rosado
An excellent place to call a neighborhood staple. I was welcomed the moment I walked in by the friendly staff. I ordered two common slices and a specialty. My daughter fell in love with the specialty slice but all three were worth the re order. A delicious option for anyone to call dinner!
… more
Kashaun Covin
Just. Wow. After working in the area for a bit, it’s only customary to have to find your favorite pizza spot in a new town. After trying the competition I was satisfied but very much so whelmed. Search after search, I finally stumbled upon Vinnie’s and walked in expecting to find just another pizza spot. You see, Vinnie’s is FAR from your average spot. Not only are the prices cheap, their slices are fresh and FANTASTIC. The only pizzeria I’ve been in that actually knows how to make a good cheesesteak slice and not make it taste like some strange Wawa meat. Within my first bite, I knew I was hooked. The staff is friendly, generous, and very timely and I’ve never had a complaint while always feeling welcome. To think I could stop here but after multiple visits I decided to really test the waters. How good was Vinnie’s pasta and could it actually match up to its superb pizza skills? I decided to check out their Tortellini Alfredo as good Alfredo comes a dime a dozen. It came with the usual side salad, bread, and a HUGE serving of Tortellini. I was literally drooling. The side salad was a great appetizer but I especially loved their choice of Ceasar dressing. The bread?? Soft, fluffy, warm, while still having a consistent texture. It was insanely good but to think that the entree, the Tortellini Alfredo, would be that good was an understatement. Not only was it at THE perfect temperature, the taste was phenomenal. Truly out of this world. The tortellini was soft and consistent. I’ve honestly never had better Alfredo out a pizza shop. I write all this to say I trust Vinnie’s to make ANYTHING good at this point. If they sold toilet paper, I’d go there over Walmart. Enough said.
… more
Chris Costa
New owner is argumentative and not accommodating. Has no idea what customer service is or how to treat people with respect. Food is Sub Par and made with cheap ingredients. There are better local small businesses to spend your money in. These lessons will be learned once they’re out of business.
… more
Julia Harris
This is our weekly pizza place and let me tell you the penne vodka pizza is to die for!!! The entire staff is always so personable and helpful and the food and service is always incredible. This past weekend, we ordered catering (4 or 5 trays) for a party-delivered hot, on time, and I’ve never seen my family and friends so happy! The food was delicious and fresh. Our family who live in TR and Forked River now drive to Barnegat just to get pizza from Vinnies!
… more
cynabunzzzy S
I can’t say enough nice things about Vinnie’s, especially the new ownership! The Manager Greg is great as well as their entire team! The food is amazing and they are super-community oriented! They sponsored lunch and dinner today for our ENTIRE Nursing Team at Barnegat Rehab! THANK YOU Vinnies, you are great neighbors and it’s a huge plus that you also have GREAT Food!
… more
Ginamarie Phillips
We stopped in for dinner last month. My husband had chicken franchese and I had linguine with oil and garlic. OMG!! I don’t know whose meal was better. We live in Jackson but the drive to this restaurant is so worth it! The quality of the food, the size of the portions..the staff..ALL are top notch. You will not be disappointed!!
… more
Felicia Baber
If I could give less than 1 star I would. Tried Vinnies because was close to home. Really in the mood for a nice hot slice of pizza. 1 hour and 23 minutes later, order was delivered. We had to call to ask about our order as we were told 45 minutes to 1 hour. Wings, pizza and a chicken caesar salad. We’re told it should arrive shortly. We are literally 3 minutes from the restaurant. The pizza was COLD. The wings were COLD. Asked the delivery person when he pulled up if it was hot..his response was “its fresh”. Immediately Called to express my dissapointment when we opened the pizza box and it was COLD. The girl answering the phone was sympathetic and asked me to hold so she could speak with someone. Greg got on the phone and called me a liar. Told me there is no way it was COLD. When I questioned how he would know that as he was not here to see the pizza or the wings and he continued to insist I was lying. Said the driver had been back for 10 minutes already and there was no way it was cold. The time from opening the box to the call to the restaurant was less than 2 minutes from the delivery Although one customer probably makes no difference to their business…I urge you to take into consideration that the $40 bill means nothing compared to a business that can actually call a customer a liar. I would gladly have returned the cold pizza for a hot pizza and wings myself with an acknowledgment and explanation rather than an accusation and no accountability. I have no comment on the quality of the food because. How can anyone say COLD “fresh” pizza is worth a comment. Awful that “Greg” called me a liar…..this one customer will make it a point to urge potential customers to go elsewhere!!!!!!
… more
Rachel Canaie
Food was amazing and the owner was nice and attentive when we sat down to eat! I live in northern NJ and always stop at Vinnie’s when I’m in town.
… more
Derek Konasiewicz
I used to order chicken parm cutlet subs, and they were awesome. I just ordered a sub and got a chicken patty cut in half on way too big Italian bread. I called in shocked about the change in quality. They sent a medium pie to replace the sandwich, and it was a puddle of watery looking cheese in the center of a pie crust…ALL PUDDLED IN THE MIDDLE.. it was suspect, so we tossed it. We won’t order delivery from this place again for a while.
… more
Tori Costa
Our staff over at BRNC frequently orders lunch and dinner from Vinnie’s, and has nothing but good things to say about them! Vinnie’s generously donated meals to our nurses for the 2023 Nurse’s Week, and put smiles on all of their faces. I highly recommend ordering from Vinnies if you live in the area or are passing through.
… more
… View more