Based on 221 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
588 Valley Rd, Wayne, NJ 07470
Phone: (973) 305-0405
Website: https://neilspizzainwayne.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mets RSL
Ordered online and left very specific directions for food. Everything was made perfectly to what I asked for. The pie was crispy and had very light cheese like I asked. The wings were also crispy and fresh. Could. Not of asked for better food at an affordable price. Neils is the spot!
… more
Lenore
Ordered a pizza for first time. I’m from Ardmore pa and the pizza is mediocre around the mainline. This was damn good…tasty crust, sauce and cheese and super nice staff …will def be ordering again!
… more
Get Real
I’ve ordered the Grandma pie here over 20 times already. Ive been wanting to try something else but that pie is sooo good. Fresh mozzarella, sauce is amazing, and the dough is cooked to perfection. If you live anywhere near here, it’s a must try.
… more
Jimmy Vo
Delicious Sicilian pizza with basil on top! We got a square 16” x 16” Sicilian pizza and it was delicious! My family really liked the taste of the pizza. The restaurant was clean and organized. There are plenty of choices as shown in the menu, but we just got vegetarian pizza for Good Friday weekend.
… more
christian larmony
I love this place. They always have a variety of signature flavored pizza to choose from, all top
… more
blaky carrasco
The great staff is absolutely out of this world, the price is very affordable and the pizza one of the best around. I give them 53 stars for the whole package, come and see for yourself not gonna be disappointed
… more
patsy chang
So I heard a co worker raving about this place and decided to order from here. After looking at their menu we decided on the bruschetta pizza. After excitedly waiting for almost an hour we got our deliver and what a disappointment! Every time I ordered bruschetta there was actually CHEESE YOU KNOW FRESH MOZZARELLA CHEESE ON IT. It wasn’t just tomato sauce, tomatoes, basil and bread. Where’s the dang mozzarella cheese? First time ordering and last. Other pizza places in the area are so much better. Save your money, we know we just wasted ours on whatever this is. I wish I could give 0 stars.
… more
Bryan Essing
If I could rate ZERO, I would. The pizza is horrific. The Sicilian slices are good if they’re center slices. Crust is way too big.
… more
Ricardo Gonzalez
Neil’s is a little treasure hidden in a shopping center in Wayne. I guess due to this location not many people knows it but they are good! Pizza is awesome and the variety is awesome. Only reason I give three stars for the atmosphere is for the gathering of kids after school who are just hangin out and also the tables are too small for big guys like me who barely can seat cause the benches are fit so its too tight. Eating there was a but uncomfortable but the food and attention are great.
… more
Ingrid Lee-Hall
I’ve been going to this place since 2005 and have NEVER had a bad experience until tonight. I ordered a plain pizza pie. When I arrived to pick it up the employee asked me my order number. He checked and after whispering with another employee he decided to give me a pie that was sitting on top of the oven. I asked him if it was hot. He told me to check for myself. I opened the box and checked. I said it was fine. I then asked my daughter to sprinkle some garlic. There were no other customers around waiting to order. That’s when the employee told me I can’t do that there. I need to bring it to a table and sprinkle it. I’ve been doing the same thing that takes a few seconds at the counter for years and it’s never been a problem. Suddenly without a valid explanation, I was impolitely told I couldn’t do it. No matter how good your food is, customer service is VERY IMPORTANT!!
… more
… View more