Handcrafted everthing! Artisan sandwiches, Handmade gelato, Homemade goat milk soaps, Amazing wines and Drinks, Charcuterie, Farm Fresh and Aged Cheese, Boutique Shopping and a polished family feel that will make you feel good to stay.
The Door County Creamery family owners started and ran a 150 goat dairy farm and creamery located in Sister Bay, in beautiful Door County, Wisconsin. After over 10 years of running their own farm the family has now partnered with another family goat farm where it now sources its fresh milk. Door County’s owner is a world traveled chef and serves amazing food with their team at the Creamery in Sister Bay.
Charming cafe offering artisanal cheeses & sandwiches, plus lunchtime goat farm tours with tastings. Based on 885 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
10653 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234
Phone: (920) 854-3388
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday |
8:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday |
8:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
8:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
8:30 AM–10 PM |
| Monday |
8:30 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday |
8:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday |
8:30 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lori
Hot Honey…seriously one of the very best gourmet sandwiches I’ve ever eaten!! Thai salad absolutely scrumptious as well! House made Arnold Palmer very flavorful. Roasted Almond Fig gelato ~ delicious! Creative, high quality choices all around. A++
… more
Darrin Rogers
Very cute shop with fantastic food. The brie turkey sandwich was the best turkey sandwich I’ve had in my life (my picture does not do it justice) I had to come back later and had the mozzarella – also very good. They have a small but very good selection of gelato, in case you haven’t had it: good gelato >> ice cream. We got two larges and that was enough for a family of five to share. It seems expensive but in my opinion it’s totally worth it for how delicious the food was. We will be coming back. Skip the roof goats and come here.
… more
Rage Thomas
Fun little shop. Awesome that it is open late. We went for the ice cream/gelato ( never specificed) late at night.
… more
Bill S.
I’ve had ice cream here before but never eaten. I had the meatball sandwich and it was awesome. Toasted bun/bread, fresh jalapeno, lettuce, cheese and a great Pesto, Aioli, Arugula sauce. Meatballs had a light amount of marinara so it wasn’t overpowering. Not at all what you’d expect with a meatball sandwich but it was awesome! So good.
… more
Sheetal Shedbalkar
We grabbed take-out lunch here and got a burrata salad, green veggie wrap and a lamb gyro. The burrata salad and lamb gyro were great, the green wrap was so-so. We also got gelato here, which was amazing! You can try a sample before ordering. Service was quick. They also sell lots of different types of cheeses and condiments. This is a great place to stop if you’re in Door County.
… more
Casey M
My happy place! I’ve been going to Door County Creamery for years. I loved it when they opened and it just keeps getting better. The mozzarella sandwich is perfect balanced and delicious. The gelato is creamy and flavorful. They’ve got a great little shop, too.
… more
Brittney G
Love this place, all the seating is outdoors but it’s in the heart of Sister Bay! I recommend the mozzarella sandwich and their Arnold Palmer. Browse while you wait for your food (or they’ll text you), the shop is really cute!
… more
The Accidental Hero
My favorite lunch spot in Door County, by far. They do everything well: fresh ingredients, interesting menu, great vibe, friendly staff, terrific music. The outdoor tables are under a canopy of leaves and have fresh flowers. They care about their customers, and that’s why they get my business each summer.
… more
Noah Smith
Ended up getting the gyro. It’s was hands down one of the best I ever Eaten. Outdoor seating very nice as well.
… more
MICHAEL LIENAU
Delicious goats milk gelato! So many great flavors to choose from, and different ones each day. $4, $5, or $6 per cup or you can get a cone. Also a few sorbet flavors. Great sandwiches and other food and beverages too. And a cute gift shop. Friendly staff, often busy because it is a popular place.
… more
… View more
