Based on 233 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
Address:
411 S Main St, Elmira, NY 14904
Phone: (607) 734-7100
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Louis Magno
Ordered medium chicken wing pizza and a order of cauliflower. The cauliflower was soaked in grease and soggy. The pizza… had 8 maybe 10 chunks of what looks like boneless wings thrown on with barely any cheese. 3 inches of barely cooked crust. This was a last resort as Vinny’s is closed. Should have known better. The quality here has really gone down.
… more
beth bedics
Is now pasquale’s pizzeria and is delicious. Wonderful people. Just getting going but they have amazing food.
… more
Goplaces Dothings
Great antipasto salad! Really like the pickled veggies they use. Thw salad came in a big serving, wnough for multiple people to enjoy. Good service too, brought us the food when it came out.
… more
Chef Liz
Everyone is friendly and they do a great job! Great atmosphere and overall pleasant experience. I give OIP a 5 star.
… more
Ronald GoodBurger
Normally they are fine but this bbq chicken pizza I ordered came with burnt chicken all over it. When I called back, they couldn’t even offer a refund let alone a discount. You lost my business forever ♂️
… more
Ann Cheatham
I’m so very disappointed! My spaghetti was so watery hardly any sauce. I should take a picture of the water in the spaghetti. ! And it’s COLD! MY Husband’s pizza was not done. I understand they were going to close soon after we placed the order and I did call to *complain”. But I couldn’t eat the spaghetti. Thankfully I had a salad. And the bread was hard and cold. I’m extremely disappointed ☹️..I couldn’t figure out to show how much water was in the spaghetti.. I’m extremely disappointed for paying 30. Plus dollars for horrible food. And when I asked her for extra sauce, she was happy to say she put a lot of sauce!! SERIOUSLY!! I CAN’T FIGURE OUT HOW TO POST THE PICTURE! I WANTED SPAGHETTI NOT SOUP!? I posted a picture..I didn’t eat any of it..the picture is just showing how watery it is!
… more
Lorraine Gaskins
My daughter recommended the Grilled Chicken Salad. For my first time eaten at OIP it was by far the best salad I’ve had in this area. I strongly recommend this salad & can not wait to explore more options as well. Thank you for the speedy delivery & amazing food.
… more
Dwarfnauts
Waited about fifteen minutes for my order, only to find out that they burnt it completely. I do not recommend this place at all.
… more
Tyler Sciarratta
Seriously just save your money and time. There has only been like 2 times out of 15 orders that they got my food correct. And if you try to order closer to closing, which I know sucks I was planning on tipping inside good fir the inconvenience, they straight up tell you they aren’t taking your order. I’ve never seen such a poorly run place in my life. Usually super understanding cause I work in food, but straight up refusal to take a later order when your still open has been the last straw.
… more
M Watkins
Both times I’ve ordered they have messed my sandwiches up and had to resend another back to the house. The second time I also ordered chicken parm w three meatballs and extra cheese. They forgot my bread and didn’t put the extra cheese that in sure I got charged for.. but whatever I won’t order again. The chicken seemed undercooked but some how still dry and tough.. two stars for them correcting the sandwiches but need to stick to just cooking my own food
… more
… View more