Based on 35 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
34 W Philadelphia St, York, PA 17401
Phone: (717) 887-3670
Social Profile: 
![]()
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–2 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–2 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–2 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–2 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–2 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Desmond Lomax
This cheesesteak was huge and delicious. The wife and I shared a large it was easy enough for 2. The perfect mix between soft roll and freshly sliced ribeyes. They used Cooper cheese which is my favorite. Going to go back over and over.
… more
Charles Bernstein
Authentic Philly hoagies done the right way. The only place to get a hoagie in the area. Perfection! Seeded rolls from Conshohocken, meats sliced perfectly, fresh veggies, great cheese, all the fixings. This place is the *real* deal by a LONG shot, no one comes close in York or any of the surrounding areas!
… more
Franz Sanvictores
Dope sub spot. It’s always nice to walk to the central market on a Saturday and enjoy local food. Had the roast beef and the ham turkey bacon one. Lefty’s way. Both the 6 inch and it was plenty. Delicious bread and top quality meats. Will be back.
… more
Brent Ott
My visit was prompted by a recommendation from my brother-in-law who lives 60 miles away and had read so many positive reviews. He knows I go out of my way to find them and this place is in my backyard in York, PA. On my first visit, I was greeted by who I believe was the owner who shared he slices the ribeye fresh every morning. Boxes of rolls from Conshohocken Bakery told me I was in for a treat and it did not disappoint. I ordered the Classic which has perfectly melted American & Copper Sharp cheese throughout and was stuffed full of meat. A nice helping of fried onions finished it off right. You know it’s good when you think about it days later so I went back over the busy weekend to confirm it was as good as I thought it was and the answer is a simple yes. It got my 7 year olds approval and is worth going out of your way for. I can’t wait for my next one!
… more
Connor Shade
Like biting into a block of cold cut.
… more
J Schmo (Joe)
The best hoagie in the area hands down. Hard rolls, delicious meats and fresh veggies and they don’t skimp on the ingredients. If you’ve never had a great Philly style hoagie then this is your new go-to place. Absolutely delicious.
… more
ELVISRN1
I ate one of their italian subs yesterday , The sub was put together well and was huge, Did not scrimp on the meat at all, This place is a gold mine for york pennsylvania. Love to see another location in the North end of town Easy to get to. This is without a doubt a 7 day a week.
… more
Susan Cloran
Hefty Lefty’s helped us out with a catering tray for our Robotics competition. Most people were from the Philly area, and wanted to see if there was a Hefty Lefty’s location around them they liked them so much! Really great hoagie, and customer service.
… more
Antonio Weedon
THE BEST SUBS EVER. ! I travel from Maryland just to get one. The ribeye cheessteak tastes like they are right out of Philly!. I had other subs as well and was never disappointed! The construction of the subs to the freshness of the ingredients are prefect!
… more
David barnhill
I ordered 2 cheesesteaks and one balboa grinder, Wow is all I can say. Excellent tasting sandwiches, well made. My wife said this is what a philly cheesesteak supposed to taste like
… more
… View more