Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering calzones, sides & desserts. Based on 497 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
Address:
2525 Elida Rd, Lima, OH 45805
Phone: (419) 331-1900
Website: http://godfathers.com/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Matthew Arnold
I hadn’t had this pizza since I was a child and it was just as I remembered, delicious!
… more
Rick
We ordered a classic combo large 14 inch and a pitcher of Pepsi. Was $38. The pitcher of pop was $8 and didn’t fill the three small glasses with ice twice. The pizza was average at best. The sausage and onions were the only thing with favor. This place is way over priced and really not good. This place is expensive for good pizza let alone bland pizza. We all know what pop cost so this is ridiculous gouging . Wish I could give less than one star
… more
Dan Hennon
Always great pizza but this time it was a little off. I gave the restaurant a call an Scott the manager was polite an courteous an was able to make it right! HANDS DOWN BEST PIZZA IN THE AREA!
… more
Dortisha Hamilton
Never got my pizza. Staff was very rude and unapologetic. After about 2 hours I asked for a refund of money. I didn’t even get an apology just excuses. Never again!!!
… more
Kayla Newland
Food was good, but was disappointed that they only do the buffet at lunch which was the original reason we went, had to wait a while on our dessert pizza which we ended up taking to go and the place was pretty messy. I understand places are short staffed, but there were plenty of workers just standing around that could’ve cleaned it helped the rest of their coworkers. Godfathers use to be a huge hit back in the day, but sadly it looks like they’re letting it run down..the carpet, decor, tables, chairs, ect look the same from when I was a kid..
… more
Michael Lake
I love godfathers pizza, I wish they wouldn’t have ever left Toledo, but they did many years ago. So now in order to get Godfathers Pizza we have to drive to Lima, Ohio to get one, so guess where we went this weekend? Lima, Ohio. Best pizza ever, a sure definite must try….
… more
Cory J. Shiverdecker
Polite staff, fast service, excellent pizza. A little disappointed there isn’t a buffet, but with COVID it makes sense. Highly recommend this venue if you’re looking for some pizza.
… more
Nick Miller
Great pizza. My only complaint is how astronomically expensive it is to eat here unless you do the buffet! Small cheese pizza and a Pepsi is OVER $18.00!!!!! If quality was the only criteria, they’re 4 stars! Since value is also part of the equation, and this place is grossly OVERPRICED, I can only give 2 stars! This is midwest pizza at Manhattan New York pricing! Unfortunately, I can no longer justify these High prices!
… more
Will Hoo
Excellent pizza buffet! Scott has been here for around 30 years, and his staff is the best. They know what they’re doing, and they care about it.
… more
ClanMack 4JChrist
It was ok, the staff looked overworked and too tired to be motivated to make the customer feel welcomed and appreciated. I drove 45 miles one way thinking a 26$ pizza is certainly worth my wild. Naa first time and last time. Pizzas weren’t bad, just not quite made right? And definitely not the greatest like I imagined. I like the bacon chopped up and integrated into the whole pizza, not 1 per slice and when it’s gone I’m left with extra pizza without it.I do like the way the box flattens and folds up when I put it in the garbage. The owner of the franchise is kind. Thank you for the free monkey bread though half of it kind of went to waste I honestly appreciate it.
… more
… View more