Based on 196 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
102 W 15th St, Beardstown, IL 62618
Phone: (217) 323-5222
Website: http://bennys-pizza-beardstown.keeq.io/
Hours
| Sunday | 3:30–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 1:30–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 1:30–10 PM |
| Thursday | 1:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 1 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 3:30 PM–12 AM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tom Imel
We had a huge crowd that pretty much took up the entire building. There was a little confusion at first but then everything went well. Very good food. If I’m ever in the area we’ll go back.
… more
Steven Henderson
On Saturday, May 6 I placed an order for hot wings and some deep fried raviolis. My friends also ordered wings and some cheese sticks. The three of us enjoyed our meal and left to go home that evening. We all were up with stomach cramps, vomiting, and diarrhea. This is now Tuesday of the following week, and I am still suffering from stomach cramps and diarrhea, I hope they can resolve the issue with their staff and enforce sanitation practices and prevent cross-contamination
… more
Vraj Patel
Specifically told them about dietary restrictions and they brought out food that was against the restrictions. And then was told to eat it because it wouldn’t kill me. I don’t think that is the type of customer service that should be provided. Was told that the food (that didn’t met the dietary needs) wouldn’t kill me by the owner felt very disrespected. I have dietary restrictions due to my religion so this was very disturbing. Just wanted to alert others on our experience.
… more
lynn miles
On 4/09/2022 around 4 or 5pm I called to find out if they deliver and when they no longer delivered. A young lady did not know but she ask. I heard a man say “As long as we are open, we deliver “. I said great, I also ask about getting a bacon cheeseburger pizza in a stuffed crust, again the young lady ask again. The male voice stated, “we can put anything in a stuffed crust.” I said great, I would call back and order, could I call an early delivery order? I was told yes. I called back and ordered for delivery a lg stuffed bacon cheeseburger pizza, an order of Tiramisu and Bogo? Cheese sticks. Total $42.75, delivery at 10pm to my address. The card reader was not working so I had to write a check, adding $5 for tip. 10pm came and went, 1030, 1045 I called and spoke to the “owner”, he said “yes, but it was a family business.” I told him who I was and was wondering when we could expect our order? This man snapped at me saying “are you calling from Ohio?” I kinda chuckled and said no sir I live right here in Beardstown, again gave him my address, he in turn said “let me have you talk to the driver so he will be able to find you”. I thanked him. The driver had no clue! I have lived in this town for 2yrs, 911 gave us our address. After I had hung up I called right back because now it has been an hour. I ask the man who was the owner if I was getting a fresh order or am I getting cold food that’s been given the royal tour of Beardstown? This OWNER YELLED AT ME “LOOK LADY I HAVE ALREADY BEEN HERE 11& 1/2 hrs. Their hours say they are open til midnight on Saturday. My response to him was,”So, that’s not my fault, I just want hot food”. He said he would not be delivering to us as we do not live at 800 West 12th St., I gave him instructions on how to get here! I ask “ if he knew where Caseys was?” He said “yes” , I ask “the car wash across the street?””yes” I then said,”if you turn right at the car wash, you will see my house on the left side, my porch light is on, I will be standing in the door watching for you.” He yelled at me again that” that was not an address and they would not deliver to us!” So I simply said “ let me make this easy for you. How’s about we never order another friggin’ from you again!” His reply “Good”. Then he started back tracking saying they were doing the best that they could…”. By that time this man had been so rude to me I just hung up!!! My address is 800 West 12th St, Beardstown IL 62618, we live in a double wide mobile home on the corner of 12th St and Garm Ave. That is our home across the street.So folks my advice order at your own risk!! We will not! That man owes me a HUGE APOLOGY! Even at that we will not spend our money in a place that is so blatantly rude and made no attempt to show any kind of sorrow for the things he said to me. I cannot imagine why ANYONE would spend their money there.This is our house we are the Miles! We do live on the corner of 12th St and Garm Ave. Benny’s is very disappointing…
… more
Tim Bot
Me and my friends went here for a cooldown food was awful pizza still raw flies on the food and can’t even stand the customer service we ordered cheese ravioli for our friend that’s is vegetarian and we specifically asked for there to be nothing meat wise but of course the sauce had hamburger inside of it luckily we found out before he took a bite of it we also ordered a deep dish had and half pepperoni and cheese pizza but the man came out with a pepperoni and sausage pizza we told the man and he said he would make another one he comes out with the other pizza and it is awful it’s raw greasy and just disgusting he also said “oh to bad you ur going to die because I have you hamburger sauce” awful customer service will not be coming back any time soon
… more
Courtney Rayborn
We had family driving through from Louisiana, thought we would try out the “famous” Benny’s Pizza. Ate our meal, and just got everything boxed up to talk a few mins more and was informed by the owner that “he had people he could put at our table if we could go, just saying”. Pizza nay be decent, but being rude doesn’t keep business!
… more
Anita Read
We love the thin crust. Typically fast from order to table.
… more
Adriano Gonzalez
Verbally assaulted, raw dough, foul language, food was good except that IT WAS RAW!
… more
Crystal Hopper
Pizza was very good, reasonable prices
… more
Kevin Beer
I ordered 22 pizza’s for a customer. I needed them at 11:30am they came in early to get this order done and delivered on time. The pizza was great still very fresh and hot. Customer was satisfied and so was I they really understand customer service. I just want to thank Benny’s. Great pizza and local business support them…thanks again
… more
… View more