Based on 292 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
Address:
637 Main St, Lander, WY 82520
Phone: (307) 332-3900
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Neil Crook
I grew up having and going to Tony’s Pizza. There has been some changes since I’ve been there. First, the most major change is there store front. Now you enter from the side and the dine in options are significantly smaller. They have close off the front of the store and the on roof dining options. My guess is they are going to rent out the front of the building but I don’t know. Second, I feel the pizza is just alright. I remember it being one of my favorite pizza’s growing up. Maybe it’s now just my perception as I have grown older. Third, I didn’t see prices for the specialty pizzas on the menu. That would have been nice. If there was an option to give half stars I would give this place 3.5 stars. Tony’s is still good but didn’t live up to my expectations or my memories.
… more
Jeannie
This is such a cute hidden gem in Lander! My boyfriend and I were coming from out of town and wanted some pizza before we got to our hotel. We called while we were 2 hours away and requested it be ready by 9 (they close at 10) and they were very sweet over the phone! After we got into town, we picked it up no problem, very easy and great customer service. Their pizza is amazing and the sausage is delicious!
… more
Ashley Morrill
The first time we went years ago it was fine, but I understand there were some ownership changes since then which have led to a revamp of everything from the menu, to the recipes, to the renovating of the building itself. It is so so good now. Our favorite restaurant in Lander! The pizza is phenomenal, the stromboli is perfect, and the wings are the among the best I’ve ever had.
… more
Stacy McDaniel
Very disappointing unfortunately!, Tony’s use to be the best pizza place around. To night i was served cheeseless cheesey bread with the cup of ranch turned upside down and spilt. (You guys went way cheep on the ranch these days too i see , taste like nasty wishbone bottled ranch)And the way they put my receipt directly on top of my pizza thanks guys did me a favor i guess it’s so soaked in grease i can’t really make out the $27.00 price stamp i wasted on this horrid excuse of a dinner.
… more
Krystle Brooks
There pizza was like a big frozen Totinos pizza. The chicken in the Alfredo was obviously boiled and not seasoned. The Alfredo sauce itself was actually delicious. But the people working there were very rude to me and didn’t even ask for my name for the order, so no one knew my order. It wasn’t very easy to find either if you’re not living in Lander.
… more
William Dechert
Absolutely wonderful place! I’ve thrown a few group events here and the staff have always been understanding of specialized needs and tabling and they were always just all-around exceptional. The food is also really good, but my review is based much more on the employee/staff excellence.
… more
Keila Diaz
The definition of a hole in the wall. Found this place driving through on my way to Dallas. Their cowboy Stromboli was fire The staff was kind and thoughtful with our orders. Loved this place. If it wasn’t so far from me I’d be there every day.
… more
Wim Vanraes
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! The place itself is clean, and shows tons of individuality. This eye for detail and taste is also reflected in their menu, with well thought out pies that will give you a hard time deciding which to order.
… more
Alyssa Wilmoth (Lysa)
Pizza was AMAZING! We ordered the Carnivore specialty pizza and it was absolutely delicious. Wait may have been a little long as they did have a few people ahead of us, but for as fresh of a pizza we got and the service we received it was well worth the wait. Will definately be back when we are in town. I’m not going to like having to go back to pizza hut and domino’s where we live.
… more
Nan Halpern
Heard it was good so we decided to give it a try. Ordered the pizza to go. Came back 30 minutes later to pick up and the pizza order had not even been started. They wanted us to wait 30 more minutes sitting in the car waiting. The manager would not come out. No apology. Would not refund money. Pizza finally can out. Pizza Hut would be equivalent for less $$. Would NEVER return.
… more
… View more