For more than a quarter century, Amore Pizza by jack calandra has kept our customers coming back for our Delicious Pizza. Starting in two locations in Newark, then opening in Bloomfield and Montclair our mom and pop shop, adjacent to Nutley, is home to the most desirable Pizza in Essex county and beyond. Now exclusively in Nutley NJ.
Pizza prepared by Amore pizza by jack calandra is like no other in Nutley. That’s why it’s the people’s and critics’ choice year after year. For starters, it’s fresh – we mean really fresh. When you pull up to get your order, all you have to do is look, listen and smell.
Based on 80 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
371 Centre St, Nutley, NJ 07110
Phone: (973) 667-5000
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday |
10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: pizzanutleynj.com
Reviews
Mike S
The Giuseppe is phenomenal. The crust is crispy yet airy with a little garlic kick to it. I also loved the grandma slice. Worth the 50 min drive. Can’t wait to go back
… more
Rich G
The Giuseppe Pizza is great, it’s one of the best pies I’ve found in the area.
… more
Jasmine Gowans
It’s really good! I ordered 2 slices plain and 2 with pepperoni by Ubereats and it was delicious. The pepperonis made it a tad spicy which I like and they added a good amount of sauce. I like the sauce. Lots of pizza places underestimate the value of the sauce! Pizza & cheesy bread are not supposed to be the same! I just wish there was an option for half toppings on the app and I also wish I didn’t find out about this place a couple days before I was about to go on a diet.
… more
Diana Gamarra
The service is top tier, the pizza is top tier, the establishment is clean and organized !
… more
K S
I like the pizza here a lot, my household orders from here frequently. However, I find all of the barstool imagery kind of off-putting. Having it on the box was weird enough, but now there are gigantic photos of the owners with the reviewer all over the fence and building. I think the food here is good enough on its own to not need to rely on the barstool branding so heavily.
… more
Jessica
Received an ICE COLD pizza that had clearly been sitting out all day. When I contacted the restaurant, I reached the most incredibly rude woman who tried to convince me that the pizza was ice cold and essentially stale because the Uber eats driver had his air conditioning on in his car. Like are you kidding me? This disgusting pizza was definitely sitting out for HOURS. There is absolutely no way that this pizza was made within the last hour when I ordered it. So now not only do I have a pizza I can’t eat, instead of apologizing and trying to figure out how it could be fixed, I was spoken to like absolute garbage. Never again.
… more
Cassidy Serrano
Had the nutley tomato pie… incredible ! Thin crust, delicious sauce, can’t go wrong
… more
A C
Had a great experience a few weeks ago with the pizza. Ordered a Giuseppe and grandma, they tasted very similar not as good last time. Also ordered calamari, wings and a chicken parm sandwich. The calamari had to be thrown in the garbage immediately. It was sooo fishy and rubbery I can’t believe the even sent it out of the kitchen. The wings are breaded and very greasy, dominos is MUCH better. Chicken Parm was ok.
… more
Nancy Beth Kamhi
Dave portnoy of barstool sports gave them a 7.9 that’s is a high score. We enjoyed the pizza completely.
… more
Harold Medford
Had the regular cheese pizza with half sausage. Was good pizza. There are few different pizza options at this place and was not sure which might be the best one. Will come again to try the The Giuseppe which I guess might be their signature pie? Will see. Decent parking on site, did a pick up order. No issues. Staff was friendly and food tasted fresh even after a 10 min drive back home. Place is worth a visit.
… more
… View more
