Old-school German mainstay with rib-sticking traditional dishes such as sauerbraten & vintage decor. Based on 328 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
640 Main St, Northport, NY 11768
Phone: (631) 757-7959
Website: http://pumpernickelsofnorthport.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 1–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kevin Smith
The food and menu are excellent, the waitress is expert and German-speaking. The food is not just German (mainly German) but continental. The interior is great, the upstairs bathrooms and phone cabinet are classic and there is an ample parking lot. This was out of the way for me but my detail thought I would enjoy this. On a rainy Saturday afternoon in an empty German restaurant my soul was refilled. The waitress was joy personified. Dance. Mahlzeit!
… more
Kevin Smith
This German restaurant was a bit out of the way but just what I needed on a rainy Saturday afternoon. The combo lunch included soup, dessert and coffee with an entrée and is a phenomenal deal. The wiener schnitzel was divine, the rice beautifully cooked. The interiors were a restrained Bavarian and the service was impeccable. This is not Figlmüller’s but I was blissfully unaware. So Northport isn’t Vienna. Who cares? Mahlzeit!
… more
Kevin Smith
In an empty German restaurant on a rainy Saturday afternoon, the expert service of the German speaking waitress in her dirndl recharged my soul. The food was delicious, the decor was Bavarian (natürlich), the television and music were straight Mel Brooks, and the food was worth a return trip. My detail suggested this restaurant as a treat after not dining on German food for nearly three years. It is NOT Figlmüller’s but I am definitely going to reserve it for our delegates this coming weekend. It made a humdrum trip exciting. Danke für seine Gemütlichkeit. Mahlzeit!
… more
Benjamin Brokop
I’m not going to lie, the food tasted good and was delicious, but the place is extremely expensive compared to other German Restaurants here on LI and the city.
… more
Debbie
A true landmark!!!
… more
Ray Micucci
Haven’t been there in 20 years after moving to NC. Was in NY and couldn’t resist having dinner there with family. Everyone raved about the food & service. It was exceptional! Still the same owner who was gracious to come to our table and acknowledge our presence & bought us a round of after dinner drinks. Again, exceptional!
… more
Shawn Reimerdes
The food doesn’t even feel very German, only a 1/4 of the menu. I had the sauerbraten and it was the worst I’ve ever had. The mashed potatoes were instant potatoes. The gravy was the worst. The sauerkraut and red cabbage was depressing.
… more
MARY TURNER
The owner, Artie, the cooks, waitresses and bartender Denise are fabulous. They all seem to have a passion for being a part of Pumpernickels’ hospitality history. Their work effort and quality of service as well as the delicious food shows they are committed to giving you a memorable dining experience.
… more
Brett Bar
Nice place food much improved over when i went last
… more
Vinny Famiglietti
If I could give a 0 star I would the waitress is not very friendly I got the goulash with the butter noodles. Both the noodles and the goulash had no flavor. I had one piece of the meat and maybe 2 forks fulls of the noodles. The noodles we way over cooled like they were falling apart and the meat in the goulash was very tough and chewy I sent it back and was told I couldn’t choose another dish or comp it because I ate more then half the dish which was a lie. Then when we asked for a manager there is apparently no manager on duty today and was told we need to pay and call back tomorrow. We do not live an where near the area. VERY unprofessional and the food is very not worth the price. I have had better German food from booths at festivals l. Will never go back again.
… more
… View more