White Buffalo Pub and Pizza Co. Menu – Grand Lake, CO

Type : Restaurant

Location : Grand Lake, CO

White Buffalo Pizza Co. is Grand Lake’s family friendly pizza restaurant.
Our fresh salads and signature brick fired pizzas with roasted wild game meats, variety of sauces and toppings, serving calzone’s, and local’s favorite pepperoni Knots. Is sure to please. Our bar menu includes delicious hand crafted signature cocktails as well as a Seasonal Beer and Seasonal Cocktail drink list.
The Historic Log building once Grumpy’s Saloon, has a unique mountain atmosphere where you can find all your favorite sports and music video channels.
Upstairs is our arcade room/pool table, and large 2nd level outdoor cover perfect for birthdays, reunions after parties and more
Come belly up to the saddle bar! We look forward to seeing you soon!

Based on 234 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

White Buffalo Pub and Pizza Co. 80447

Address:
913 Grand Ave, Grand Lake, CO 80447

Phone: (970) 627-0123

Website: https://www.stonecreekcatering.com/

Hours

Saturday 12 PM–2 AM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 12–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 12–9 PM
Wednesday 12–9 PM
Thursday 12–9 PM
Friday 12 PM–2 AM

Menu

Salads
House
Mixed greens, black olive, red onion, carrot, green pepper, tomato & croutons
Caesar
Romaine lettuce, parmesan, croutons & caesar dressing
Spinach
Spinach, mixed greens, tomato, carrot, feta red onion, chopped walnuts & croutons
Ranch
Buffalo Ranch
Italian
Raspberry Vinaigrette
Blue Cheese
Caesar
Specialty Pizzas
The Stampede
This pie is bursting with zesty, sweet and tangy flavors. Pepperoni, ground buffalo, red onion, pepperoncini peppers, buffalo mozzarella, mandarin oranges, and bacon heaped over mozzarella with a sweet & sassy bbq sauce. As an added zip, we finish it off with a drizzle of our signature sweet & spicy sauce.
Park Ranger
We start with a traditional pine nut pesto and mozzarella, then top it with fresh tomato, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, and buffalo mozzarella.
White Buffalo
Our signature white pizza. Home style crust brushed with garlic infused olive oil, mozzarella, ground buffalo, buffalo mozzarella, and blue cheese crumbles. Then garnished with an herb ricotta cream and fresh basil.
The Homestead
Succulent, savory roasted chicken, red onion, bacon layered over mozzarella with a sweet & sassy bbq sauce. Finished with fresh chopped cilantro.
Whole Buffalo
For the carnivore, our house-made red sauce topped with mozzarella then loaded with ground buffalo, pepperoni, savory house seasoned elk & italian sausages, smoked bacon, and a light touch of parsley.
Gold Rush
The rush is on! It’s a little east meets west with our zesty buffalo ranch sauce, mozzarella, fresh tomato and red onion, roasted chicken, and crispy bacon.
Greek Goddess
The olive trifecta (black, green, kalamata) is in full swing, accentuated by fresh tomato, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, over our tangy house-made red sauce and mozzarella. Truly a pie fit for the gods.
Thai Pie
A fusion blend of asian cuisine and american pizza, featuring savory roasted chicken, red onion over our zesty peanut sauce and mozzarella, hearth-baked then topped with chopped peanuts, shredded carrots, fresh basil, and a sweet chili sauce.
Dessert And Drinks
Fresh Berry Pizza $6.95
Cobbler Pizza $6.95
New York Cheesecake $5.95
Reese’s Pb Pie $5.95
House Marg
Traditional margarita with a fresh house-made margarita mix. Ask your bartender to elevate your marg with our top shelf tequila
El Búfalo Blanco Paloma
Ruby red grapefruit juice, espolon and blood orange liquor with a 1/2 salted rim & white orange wheel
A Grand Bloody Mary
Our take on the classic bloody mary with a zesty kick
Lake Island Iced Tea
Similar to the long island iced tea, but with a slight refreshing twist
Brown Sugar Old Fashion
(Ryan’s signature drink) traditional old fashion with ryan’s homemade brown sugar syrup
The Kilted Buff
Hot coffee with buffalo trace & baileys topped with whipped cream & cinnamon
Voodoo Ranger
Hemperor Hpa
Elysian Space Dust
Hop Peak
Avalanche
Fat Tire
Kilt Lifter Scottish Ale
Bud Light
Budweiser
Miller Lite
Michelob Ultra
Pbr
Coors
Coors Light
Guinness
Boulder Shake
Bells Porter
Vanilla Porter
(Breckenridge)
Blue Moon
(Wheat)
Shock Top
(White)
Sierra Nevada Pale
Angry Orchard
(Cider)
Square Mile
(Cider)
Del Sol
Corona
Stella Artois
Paninis And In House Smoked Meats
In House Smoked Meats
Our smoked pork and chicken is carefully brined with bourbon and molasses for 12 hours before the smoke. Then in true-style of low and slow, smoked over a unique blend of apple, pecan, and hickory.
Kick’n Peach
Ham, peach preserves, jalapeno and pepper jack cheese		 $11.00
Cheese Trip
A triple load of american, swiss and cheddar cheese		 $7.00
The Meat Ball
Our twist on a classic. Italian sausage, in-house smoked pork, ham, pickles, buffalo, mozzarella and house-made red sauce		 $10.00
Caprese
Tomato, pesto aioli, fresh basil, mozzarella and balsamic glaze		 $12.00
Fiesta Chicken
In-house smoked chicken, red onion, black olive, tomato, lettuce, roasted red pepper, chipotle aioli and cheddar cheese		 $11.00
Cuban
Our chef’s weekly special…. onion, pepperoncini, swiss cheese, brown mustard		 $12.00
Apps-Soup-Salads
Soup Of The Day $4.00
Cheesy Bread $6.95
Pepperoni Knots $10.95
Others
Byopizza
(Gf available)
Specialty Cold Drinks
Non alcoholic or well alcohol, call, premium cyclone drinks! Vape shots! Dry ice!
Byo Pizza And Calzones
Sizes

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Max Wood
Grabbed a quick bite here before the evening activities. Great pizza ( unfortunately I did not take any photos) and the staff was great! They need extra help since one lady serviced the entire restaurant but she was amazing. Comfy atmosphere and the value is what you would expect from a popular mountain town. Probably a little easier to get a bite to eat here since the restaurant is located at the start of all the main street food businesses.

… more

Angela Stephens
My favorite pizza! I work/live seasonally in Grand Lake, and White Buffalo is definitely a highlight of Grand Lake living. While the pizza is on the pricier side (but so is everything in Grand Lake), the quality of the ingredients used, and the size of the pizzas make it well worth it!

… more

Jennifer Hurd
The food was great, we loved that they had disney plus available for kids. Unfortunately they were learning a new system, we were charged for an extra pizza and were given a hard time after asking to have it removed. After we got home we realized we were charged $90 for the incorrect ticket and also $60 for the correct ticket. Definitely make sure to verify you are not overpaying.

… more

keisha deguzman
A very laid back vibe. We got our pizza to go but decided to eat it right outside at one of their patio table/benches. We got a Hawaiian pizza. It was just simple and good! The crust is between pan and thin crust. The bathrooms were clean. The owner was super nice. And his dog was awesome!!! He is allowed to roam the streets of Gran Lake and is so chill! He came up and hung out with us for a bit

… more

Jared Palonis
I m sorry but Ive been trying to hold my review for a while, but it truly keeps bothering me. I ordered here a while back for a pick up order. I ordered 2 pizzas and 2 salads. $93. If you order pick up from here, make sure you check it before leaving, cuz I truly wish I did. Crust was burnt to a crisp on the edges, to the point you could barely bite into it. The salads were mediocre at best, and blue cheese dressing was separated and unusable. Will never eat here again, and wouldn’t recommend this place to anybody.

… more

Katie Kirk
We stopped in for lunch after an afternoon of tubbing and sledding with 5 hungry boys, the barman, Chris, was a pleasure to talk to, and when I mentioned we had nut allergies in the family, (they have a Thai pizza on menu with peanuts, which I bet is amazing but could potentially cause cross contamination) he brought the cook up to speak with me about ways to accomodate for the allergy. Which is above and beyond what most places will do.

… more

Hina Shaikh
Staff was nice but must be under staffed. The food took a while to come. Appetizer came after the pizza. Pizza tasted good.

… more

Titus Windle
Excellent pizza and in fact one of the best pizza joints in the country! Wouldn’t think to find such a majesty in a small rural town but it’s a goldeneye for sure! Amazing service and one of a kinda pizza. A guy in Arkansas can’t hope to find that good of pizza down here

… more

Bryant Culler
Love this place. Great pizza! They struggle with help as all Grand Lake establishments do so please be patient.

… more

Bo Sharp
Pizza is really good. Worth a try. Only downside it is a little pricey but I’ll be back.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch