Based on 254 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
5262 Stewart St, Milton, FL 32570
Phone: (850) 983-0303
Website: https://www.mckinelys.com/
Hours
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–2 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–2 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–2 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–2 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–2 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rich Hinckley
My wife and I had lunch here today, 5 star across the board! A+++ Not only is the food amazing, it is very large portions. Strongly recommend!
… more
Angelica A
For an affordable price I grab a sandwich, kettle chips, slaw, and a pickle. Staff is friendly and the cup cakes are on point. The environment is nice, a rich green and black theme I really enjoy, just feels different than every where else. Good place for a couple’s lunch date. Pictured is a turkey on croissant with a whipped cream cheese and cranberry spread.
… more
Patrick Lowndes
RUDE server! Stopped in for a sandwich with my wife. Very good Reuben. All was good till we were leaving. A young family came in, no tables were ready, so they were standing near a dirty table. The mom had a child about 1-1/2 years old or so. She was holding him while he was standing’s on the table. While I do realize this is not sanitary, the guy behind the counter was COMPLETELY rude and blurted out “get your kid off the table, that is not accepted anywhere. Board of health will fine me if that’s see that”. The young family seemed blindsided. He then, speaking loudly, said sarcastically “ that is unbelievable “!
… more
Tom Jackomis
Wow, 13.99 for a Reuben! The meat w as s dry and basically tasteless. ” Coleslaw” was cabbage. Best part of my meal was the pickle and chips. Jason’s Deli has a much better Reuben for less money than this place….also,
… more
Amy Kinnear
We stopped here because my fiance is obsessed with cuban sandwiches. They were so delicious! I am a coleslaw snob, and this is the best I’ve ever had. Some ancient family recipe. I hope to finagle it out of the owner eventually. Just go. You will love it. Also lots of tastey cakes and cupcakes.
… more
Mrs. Kries
I walked in to experience this place for the first time today with my teacher friend group after teaching summer school, and I walked out without even ordering. I will N E V E R return. I haven’t even tried their food, I cannot speak to that. It may be great, but the atmosphere and service made me leave as soon as possible. They were so rude that it felt almost like a prank at first so I laughed. It was not a joke, they were just that rude to their customers. I have never experienced anything like that in a restaurant. I’ve also never left a negative review before, until now.
… more
Brie Flanagan
Food = 3 stars. Service = 1
… more
Paige H
While their food may be good, their customer service and willingness to serve children is unacceptable.
… more
R Jenkins
Locals, you folks are spoiled. McKinely’s Sandwich Shop is wonderful. We ordered the Turkey and Cranberry signature Sandwich, Balsamic Chicken and Blue wrap, and Chicken and Bleu salad. The wrap had lots of chicken and a good balance of lettuce/veggies and dressing. Very good, I have it again. Salad was well balanced with spinach and romaine lettuce, lots of chicken and big chunks of Bleu. The turkey and cranberry was delicious. If you’re a fan of the best Thanksgiving ever, you’ll enjoy the hints of cranberry in every bite. On the croissant, it’s a favorite. Try it! The sandwiches come with slaw and a pickle… be sure you remember. Once you start on the sandwich it’s easy to miss because the sandwiches are so good. The slaw was fresh and light. You can almost taste the sweetness of the cabbage. Not sure how they make it, but it’s great. Dessert? Oh my. Cream brulee cheese cake, flourless chocolate torte with raspberry puree! Yum!!
… more
Austin Hatfield
Sandwiches were quite heavily portioned and included chips. They were very delicious and I will be returning quite soon for another. I had the Pamento-BLT. First one I’ve ever had and was very excited. It did not disappoint!
… more
… View more