Voted the best restaurant in Fayetteville, NY. A modern and approachable dining experience featuring local ingredients expertly prepared daily by the culinary team. Part grille and part tap house; we offer creative appetizers and small plates to share as well as larger entrée plates, and a vast beverage program featuring the region’s best beer and wine.
Based on 355 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
7300 E Genesee St, Fayetteville, NY 13066
Phone: (315) 637-9999
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: craftsmanwoodgrilletaphouse.comresy.com
Reviews
Attilio Lospinoso
We came here for an early dinner (4:30) on a Saturday. We had a reservation, and we were promptly seated, and we were allowed to choose if we wanted to sit inside or out. We opted for outside. Both the inside and outside of the restaurant are beautiful. Our waiter was very friendly, and he checked on us regularly. They have a good selection of beers from local breweries. We started out with a pretzel and fried cauliflower, and I highly recommend the cauliflower! It was so good! For the main course, I had a burger, and I would definitely recommend it! It was a great experience!
… more
Cory Iffert
The espresso martini is one of the best I’ve had! I got the fish and chips which I was surprised of the portion size. I’m happy they gave a lot because some places give you such small pieces of haddock. I also got Brussels sprouts on the side and omg they were delicious. We didn’t get the bacon flight but a lot of others did and I wished I didn’t each so much fish so I could order the bacon. This place is a true gem with quality food and amazing service by Danielle! I can’t wait to come back when I visit my family again
… more
pavlina ivanova
Today we had dinner at Craftsman Grill to celebrate a PhD graduate. The atmosphere was fantastic, ambiance and very nicely appointed dining room. Food was phenomenal! There were 5 of us, so it took a while to decide on orders. But our server Zack took great care of us and patiently waited for us to decide; he was very attentive and was checking on us in a very unintrusive matter! We had cocktails and a bottle of very good wine! Drunken mussels were to die for and Zack’s recommendation for wings did not disappoint! Duck ravioli were a hit, salmon was very good, too! Due to dietary restrictions I had the Figs and goat cheese pizza,, and it was very delicios as promised! Raspberry mousse with a glass of RemyMartin finished the meal ( only deficiency was it was served in inapropriate glasses).
… more
Misha Bassi
Great, beautiful ambiance, friendly staff, great service,portions were good,food & drinks were flavorful the only thing I don’t like was fish & chips,the batter/coating on fish was thick and very oily.I had to scoop out just fish to enjoy a few bites of fish, other than that we enjoyed our time there.
… more
Trina DeMattei
Food was tasty and the ambiance is great. I felt bad for my waitress honestly. I was the only table she had in the dining room as her main area was the patio. I waited about 15 minutes to order while tables near me were given drinks and had their orders taken. I waited about 40 minutes for fish and chips that came to me cold. After I ate the waitress, who was slammed, did not take my money for for another long stretch of time. She kept apologizing profusely.
… more
Zac
The service was the highlight – our server was pleasant and attentive. Our drinks were refreshed regularly during our experience and that includes as the evening got busier.
… more
Michael LaBarbera
First time at the Craftsman and it was a great meal. First off it’s a beautiful setting both inside and outside. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The menu is very diverse and dare I say almost too “fancy” for the less adventurous eaters in the world. I’d recommend taking a gander at the menu if you fit that description.
… more
George Garlock
I brought my friend for dinner, we sat outside. Nice night. Waitress was so bad & then so RUDE that I cannot even believe that even happened! I still can’t believe it! Despite all the neglect & inappropriate service, I still tipped 20%. So our bill was about $100 – (expected). I did not expect to have to go see the bartender to ask for our bill…it was obnoxious. The food was average. However! I apologized profusely to my guest & tried to leave. Upon our way out, the neglectful & inappropriate waitress stopped us from leaving. She claimed in front of many people that we failed to pay our bill. ALL this, after not properly refilling our drinks, doing a meal check before we could even cut or try our food & never returning! I’m shocked. Based upon our ridiculous experience, tonight, (it was severely ridiculous & worse than I have articulated) I am stunned that she is even still employed. Gosh, so many fine waiters & waitresses! I wish I did not tip her at all. I’m just not like that, so…but this was BAD. The worst I’ve ever seen in my life & I’m not kidding. Gross display. I even through out our food. Ten thumbs down.
… more
Iryna Prylutska
We came here on Saturday evening with no reservation but were seated promptly. We had bacon flight as a starter. I don’t remember the manager’s name… but thank You for your recommendation, it was the most flavourful bacon I’ve ever had!!! Exceptional food plating!
… more
Floyd Williamson
My fourth time there. The food is excellent but on the expensive side. The massive interior decor is really nice with superb indoor and outdoor bar that extends to the patio. Patio has a nice gas firepit. The only negative is that the interior noise levels make it difficult to hear conversations. Waitress joked about having to yell at customers to take their orders. Toddler with us covered their ears several times due to the noise level. There is no obvious noise abatement in the dining area. Parking is challenging during peak times. We were there from 7:00 pm until nearly 9:00 pm.
… more
… View more