Quaint eatery for soul food dishes such as oxtail & smothered pork chops, plus homemade sweet tea. Based on 326 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
534 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801
Phone: (914) 413-7533
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8:30 AM–7 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8:30 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 8:30 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 8:30 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 8:30 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jannette “Badia” Coleman
I read many bad and good reviews of SuggarPlums, but I needed to try for myself. It didn’t disappoint the fried chicken and Mac and cheese hit the spot. The atmosphere and staff were very nice.
… more
Jermaine Cooper
Okay. Arrived to this location at 637 pm on friday evening(closes at 7)
… more
Debbie Catering
I walked in to order the food I asked the young lady. How long is it gonna take? She said 20 minutes, and I waited 40 minutes to get my food. I didn’t mind. The young lady got up to fix my food. She did not wash her hands she did not put gloves on she did not have on anything covering her hair, I already paid so I got my Food, when I left the store and open the food there is a piece of hair in the food. I threw the food out. You guys got be careful when you serve in the public. Mind you, the owner was sitting there asking me if someone Took my order.
… more
Priestly Canty
The service and wait time just to receive your food is extremely slow. Not a good sign when it is the start of the business day, and the place is empty at the time. The music is a bit loud on the overhead speaker. The food is decent; I recommend the oxtails, and sweet potaoe. The collard greens are not freshly made, but out the can. Average!
… more
Isaac Jackson
It’s a small restaurant that cooks delicious Southern style food no doubt!… small entertainment area you can have small parties there… Originally raised in Georgia, I spent about $95.00 at Sugarplums because I wanted a lot of their items. Well worth it go there. Spend some money and support now!! Oh, and the fried Whiting will make you start crying!!
… more
Liddy Jacob
The owner has No clue, she’s walking around the restaurant and eating food with her hands. sells out of food quickly because they don’t cook a lot of anything and food isn’t good either The bathroom is not at all for a full size person can barely do a three sixty in a small place I Wouldn’t Go Back to this spot in the wall. Not a place I’d recommend either……
… more
Glover Hill
Just a copy of their menu. The food was good, but if you judge a place by their rest room, you would NEVER go back again! Very nasty and dirty restroom. Music, even though it was of a religious nature, was so loud, that I had to lean over the table to talk to my daughter. I would not recomend this place to anyone. Tighten up guys!!!!
… more
Janiece Thomas
I will start off by referring you to a better location. Sweet Potatoes Restaurant ( 393 North Ave) Is only a 2 minutes drive away. The food is better. The people there are nice and theres never any drama. Food does not get dropped, and there are no babies crying in cribs.
… more
Faith Moore
The food is delish hands down, but unfortunately the etiquette of the restaurant is not up to par which is why I only give one star. The website says the opening time is 1:00pm on Sundays, but everytime I go the doors are closed and lights off. This Sunday 11/6/2022 I went to enter the restaurant and the kind lady mouthed to me that they were not opening until 3pm. 2 hours after the time stated on their website. Myself and others, who were waiting outside of the restaurant, finally decided to drive away. As mentioned above the food is delicious, but due to lack of customer etiquette and consideration I will unfortunately not return. Best of luck.
… more
Zaire Thomas
Owner is very disrespectful and called my phone to complain about an issue between her and Uber. Kept saying she doesn’t understand my request about wanting extra cornbread and sadly I had to break it down. Customer service is lacking 100% and the unprofessionalism is just all over the place.
… more
… View more