Based on 267 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
281 Springs Fireplace Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937
Phone: (631) 329-1800
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kaitlin Cavell
Maybe this place is good for pizza but the pasta is AWFUL!!! Ordered their carbonara which wasn’t a true carbonara, it was loaded with tasteless bland white sauce. Their cheesy garlic bread was a joke. It’s a hoagie roll sliced in half with barley any cheese in the middle and I didn’t even taste the garlic. $28 down the drain.
… more
Jay Abra
Ordered a pie, chicken parm and some garlics nots. Also got a chicken wrap which the person who answered the phone gave the wrong information as to what was in it so my son was very disappointed when he got it. The food was pretty good. Garlic knots are huge the chicken Parmesan serving was okay
… more
Cameron Klemm
Great pizza
… more
Anyelo Beltre
The pizza is pretty mid I always get sick from it, it had a bunch of grease on it, but their other options are good.
… more
Derek Snyder
Been a loyal customer for many years. Called tonight to order a pizza and wings and it came to $66. Found out they added a $7 delivery fee and $8 in gratuity without telling me. I will be picking the pizza up tonight and then never calling again.
… more
William Vorpahl
Reliable for good Italian take out for me. I’ve been going there for years.
… more
William Hart
Busy little pizzeria that serves Springs. One of the better pizzas in the area. Worth heading off the highway into Springs to pick up a pie.
… more
Cz Rey
I am not from the area. I ordered two pizzas and a salad for delivery. The gentleman on the phone told me it would take about an hour to deliver. No big deal. 2 hours passed and still no pizza. I called and they informed me they had a big order before hand. We received our pizza after 2 hours. I was unaware that the pizzeria was only 5 minutes away from where I was staying, I would have picked it up myself. I was also unaware that they charged 8 dollars for a delivery fee. Ontop of that the driver took it upon himself to charge 10 additional dollars to my card as his tip without my consent. The meal that should have cost $62 turned into $82. An hour late. Very big scam. Make sure you ask for a total before giving a credit card over the phone. I called the day after when I noticed how much my card was charged and the gentleman on the phone said “it’s the computer it automatically puts a tip.” However I didn’t consent to a 10$ tip nor was I given any recipet to sign or keep.
… more
Morgan O’Connell
They microwaved my pepperoni pinwheel and all the pizza looked as if it was cooked yesterday. The chicken parm and pinwheels were all I Saran Wrap at 12:30 in the afternoon
… more
Chris
I’ve been ordering from pepperonis for a number of years and they were great (key word *were*), I believe they have switched ownerships and at this point they are serving cold garbage in a box or a plate and they’re now ridiculously overpriced for the quality of food… I hope one day they go back to the quality they used to be but being a local and eating for this establishment for a long time I can’t justify eating here anymore
… more
… View more