Unfussy joint featuring pizzas from a wood-burning oven, plus pasta, hoagies, salads & wings. Based on 330 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
Address:
2880 Rice Mine Rd NE, Tuscaloosa, AL 35406
Phone: (205) 391-6969
Website: https://www.broadwaypizzeria.net/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jillian Kelly
Best pizza in Tuscaloosa! Also fantastic customer service. It’s clear management is proud and passionate. Tonight I tried the chicken alfredo and it was great. Very cheesy.
… more
Jessica
A little slice of New York right here in Tuscaloosa! Pizza is great and staff is very friendly! Our dog loves it as much as we do! 🙂
… more
Timothy Taylor
Not my first visit, but it’s been a while since previous ones. Wife and I were a little at a loss for supper tonight, decided on pizza at Broadway. The sauce was fresh, not strongly flavored, an almost perfect background for the cheese and other toppings. It’s a little out of the way for us, but we’ll be back when we want to give ourselves that little extra treat.
… more
Greg Gwyn
The pizza is good but we love the cheese bread more than the pizza so now we just order the cheese bread. In response to the owner: We gave a 3 because we have ordered your pizza almost weekly but it was never consistent. Lots of black stuff on the bottom crust, skimpy toppings and sauce. We’d order the exact same pizza every time and each time it was different with these inconsistencies. The latest time the crust was much thicker than normal. So now we’ve just resolved to getting the cheese bread. Sometimes it has a lot of black stuff on the bottom too but we scrape it off and it is all good. Like I said the pizza is good but the inconsistencies prevented it from reaching 5 stars. Again, we ordered it a lot, so it wasn’t like it was once, it was each and every time. So, I feel the review is fair for the amount of times we ordered. I would still recommend Broadway but we review a lot and depend on them for our purchases and when I give a 5 it is not after one experience it is from a continued delivering of excellent taste through and through. For 5 stars, I can go to a restaurant and know that when I order that same dish it is going to taste just as amazing as the first time. That’s 5-star food no matter if it is fine dining or family pizza night. 5 stars is consistently amazing no matter what! Thanks for being an owner who is truly interested in your customer’s experience.
… more
Matt Crisafulli
Ok, but not good. Overpriced, food tastes ok; pizza was light on the toppings. Nothing good or bad.
… more
Grandma Di
We’re regular customers there. We love their Philly Cheese steak subs. Their Manhattan pizza is awesome. I usually don’t like the crust, but their freshly made crust is great. The employees are so pleasant and make you feel welcome. We love this place!!!
… more
Joshua B
Great food. Dining in is definitely 5 stars. While the atmosphere and seating aren’t the best the food is really good. Tastes better than the 82 location but that is likely to do with the oven seasoning. Delivery wasn’t so great but what can you expect from it steaming in a cardboard box? I recommend straight cheese pizza or a calzone. The toppings are good but just the base cheese, marinara and dough are amazing.
… more
Jessi
We absolutely love Broadway’s pizzas! they’re great for a crowd, delicious sand unique while still having options for pickier customers. our personal favorite is the spicy buffalo chicken pizza! can’t wait to go back and try different menu options!
… more
Amanda Heger
Broadway Pizzeria is incredible! I am from NJ originally (picky about my pizza!) but my best friend lives in Alabama. When I got engaged I decided I wanted to ask her to be my matron of honor in my wedding by sending her a pizza! I asked her husband where they order their pizza from and he quickly said Broadway is the best. I called Broadway and they were EXTREMELY helpful and delivered a pizza to my best friend with a special note saying “I know this is cheesy but will you be my Matron of Honor” and they made a question mark on the pizza out of pepperoni. They were thrilled to help me accomplish this and my best friend was even more thrilled to get a pizza delivery!! Thank you for everything, Broadway pizza!!
… more
A M
I was on hold for 9 minutes and 14 seconds before they were willing to take my order for a carry out pizza. Being frustrated after 5 minutes on hold I had more than enough time to order from Little Italy pizzeria instead. The food at Broadway is very good if you can get them to take your order.
… more
… View more