Relaxed place featuring a lengthy menu of traditional Italian dishes, plus weekend live music. Based on 591 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
304 NY-25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
Phone: (631) 473-2400
Website: http://www.amicirestaurant.org/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 12–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ryan M
Amici was awesome. Went here with my wife for dinner. Atmosphere was nice and rustic, great cozy place to eat. Service was extremely quick and we did not even have to ask for a thing. Food was beyond fresh and delicious, best penne alla vodka I’ve ever had. The chicken was amazing and the fried calamari was great. Everything was cooked perfectly and everyone was very nice. Will definitely be going back.
… more
Chef Wannabee (El Chef)
My wife and I came here on a Thursday night to enjoy a relaxing evening on their beautiful outdoor patio. The serving were good portions, and the flavor was excellent.
… more
Ricardo Macpherson-Ortiz
Amazing food and live entertainment too. Closes like 9:30pm. Attentive waiters. Desserts.
… more
Cassandra Leggio (Cassandra)
Definitely, the place to be for a fun evening that’s filled with lots of laughs, positive vibes, and flavorful spirits! There’s live entertainment too, which fills the space with amazing sound to accompany the great food and delightful convos you’ll have amongst dinner. The service is excellent as well- orders and apps were timed perfectly. The restaurant is clean and at least I know the female’s bathroom is well stocked and maintained- after all isn’t that where we continue to chat ladies! I will most certainly be making another reservation!
… more
Deborah Curcio
The staff were so pleasant!! I ordered penne with shrimp and broccoli in garlic and oil. The presentation was only surpassed by the flavor! The broccoli was so green, so fresh, so plentiful and cooked to perfection. The shrimp were delicious!!! By far the best I have had anywhere in years!!! I will be back!!!
… more
Ralph Courter
We sat outside on a Saturday afternoon. Was empty when we got there. But was filling up when we left around 6:30. Band was getting ready to play. 4 of us had a relaxing meal with good food and friendly service.
… more
Carrie Treadwell
I am saddened by the changes in the menu. I have faithfully ordered from this restaurant for over 10 years and have always loved it. They had an amazing salad with marinated tomatoes and mushrooms that was to die for. That item is gone. They also had an amazing pasta dish Lorenzo capelli, it had seafood and pasta that was amazing. Also gone. The basics bacon wrapped shrimp, meatball parm hero and all heroes are also gone. Ordered an appetizer and pasta dish this evening and it came with one single 1/2 inch slice of bread. For a dinner that cost $50, I think it can be expected to have a little more bread. The menu has become quite limiting to what it was. It saddens me to think I can no longer order from them because even the quality of tonight’s dinner was lacking.
… more
Frank DiLernia
Food is excellent although when we went to dinner with my family and took a bit long because we were enjoying the moment, the stares and annoance of management was very evident and very rude! Some of the staff robotic in their treatment of guests. Will think twice about going there for inside dining take is my preference!
… more
Daniel McGrath
Very good food
… more
E M
I like to leave reviews when is good and when is bad and this place was a big disappointment. Good thing I don’t leave in the area and was only staying in a hotel around for one night. I ordered take out Chicken Frances with spaghetti. When I arrived to the hotel I realized they didn’t put no napkins and no utensils. Food was also terrible, I can make a better chicken Frances and I’m not even Italian. Btw the order was $29.00 but their menu says 22.00. I find that very very expensive for the quality of the food. I was better off buying pizza or any other fast food. Don’t waste ur money here, it was a very big disappointment.
… more
… View more