Based on 80 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
Address:
3966 E 42nd St, Newburgh Heights, OH 44105
Phone: (216) 400-7224
Website: https://www.mikespizzanewburghheights.com/?utm_source=gbp
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
The Goddess Vaughn
Great local restaurant. Very clean and brightly lit.
… more
Tiffany Jackson
I just ordered a pizza and wings through Door Dash and this was big disappointment. My pizza bread was stale and barely had any pizza sauce on it. My wings had half sauce and plain. However I paid for sauce on all my wings. I have not eaten at this restaurant yyears ago the food was good. Now the food is bad and the customer service is sad. I called the restaurant and tried to come up with a solution and a worker name Alysha if that her real name tried to tell me to go through Door Dash for any compensation or even to for the food to be made over. Door Dash did their job. Mike’s Pizza are the ones that dropped the ball and sent garbage food. I paid 37.00 dollars for nothing. This pizza place is not the place to eat at.
… more
NewfieDuck
Great pizza and subs…….pasta dishes are pretty good too. Good portions with decent pricing.
… more
William Sheehan, III
A great pie and friendly staff. The sauce tastes slightly sweet without being overwhelming and the toppings we got on our pizza were very fresh. Chewy and crunch crust in all the right places. And the prices are great. Great for grabbing a quick bite at lunch.
… more
Tracy Valich
They were so nice. And I had to put salt on my pizza. I like that the veggies are fresh but should make bite size. I’m the other hand my kids are picky with pizza and they loved it. We will be ordering from them again.
… more
Michael Cook
Delicious sauce. Great fresh toppings. Crust crunchy on outside, soft on inside like it should be. Lots of cheese and they cook it long enough to caramelize the cheese properly. A perfect Cleveland style pizza in my opinion. Ever since Ohio City Pizza closed I’ve been searching for an adequate replacement and finally Mike’s achieves that goal! Highly recommend!
… more
Stacey McClanahan
Our office and Plant employees have been ordering from Mike’s as long as I’ve been working here (2013). They are always nice, the food is fresh, and they have it to us by lunch (which is super important because some employees only get 30 mins.) WE LOVE YOU GUYS!!!
… more
angela horvath
This was our 2nd time ordering pizza from them and it was so delicious, fresh, and the sauce…perfection!! Very friendly people, down to Earth too!! You’ve definitely made some customers for life!!!
… more
John McElfresh
Just had their 1/2 rack rib dinner today. 6 big meaty ribs with fries and slaw. These are oven cooked so no smoke but well seasoned and tender. Falling off the bone. Will definitely get again.
… more
jonathan Grinko
Mike’s has always served me well! Great food and great service! What else could you ask for?!
… more
… View more