Local fish & classic American dishes served in a vintage inn with yacht-style polished wood decor. Based on 19 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in
Address:
5775 W Mill Rd, Mattituck, NY 11952
Phone: (631) 298-8080
Website: http://www.oldmillinnmattituck.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Open 24 hours |
| Friday | Open 24 hours |
| Saturday | Open 24 hours |
| Sunday | Open 24 hours |
| Monday | Closed |
Reviews
S. Stassevitch
Hello google, they are open!
… more
Stephen Wong
very fresh seafood great service . excellent happy hr $1 Clams $1 Oysters . Local vibe . Allowing our dog on the outdoor deck was a plus.
… more
MorichesBayBum
Great atmosphere! The building is old and has historIcal charm. We ate bar-food and everything was better than expected. We’ll be back soon!
… more
Paige Dabek
Lovely setting, food was decent not great. But I’d go again (at least in the summer) because I love sitting outside in a nice setting.
… more
Bill Lang
The hostess is terrible. Don’t sit outside at night or the bugs will eat you alive. The food is basic. Ignore the zagat rating. The reviewer missed the mark.
… more
The Corcoran Group
Open Friday through Sunday for Lunch & Dinner. Delicious seasonal menu – get a plate of local Oysters, Peel-n-Eat Shrimp and the Monkfish.
… more
Christine K.
The Old Mill Inn is one of the best places to be, PERIOD. Love it, love it ,love it.
… more
Carol Celeste
Went there June 10 2017. Closed and building for sale
… more
snow rachel
Great food good service.
… more
John Hennessey
I don’t remember going here.
… more
… View more