Waterside tiki bar/eatery pairing seafood classics such as coconut shrimp with frozen drinks. Based on 6 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Phone: (305) 743-4191
Website: https://islandfishco.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 8 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bailey Ostrom
The food here is exceptional! I think this was the VERY best meal I’ve had during my time here in The Keys! Our server was EXTREMELY personable, kind, and friendly. My 6 ounce sirloin was cooked to perfection! The fries were really great too! This restaurant is also located right on the water in a beautiful area!
… more
Latisha “Hungry Hiker Hodgepodge” M
This was a fun place to go. We went on the dock and fed the fish. You could be near the water if away. They have a gift shift. The seafood egg roll appetizer thing is amazingly delicious. I wasn’t super hungry so ordered a shrimp quesadilla instead of a big fancy meal- it was actually huge and delicious too. Better than expected.
… more
Jake W
They are so popular they probably don’t need my review anyway. It has great vibe, great view and the food there is just superior. Had to wait for around 30 min to get seated but definitely worth the wait. The conch fritters is a must try. The next day we drove to Key West and tried the same thing at conch republic seafood, then we realize the huge difference. Pro tips: don’t trust restaurants at tourist sites.
… more
Nathan Corlew
This was our second time eating here. We ate here almost 10 years ago. Very little has changed. The atmosphere is the same and the food is still really good. The prices are a little steep for what you get. We had buffalo shrimp, wings, and raw oysters. It is a classic Florida Key place to dine.
… more
Tammy Morgan
Solid stop in Marathon. Friendly bartenders and good cocktails. Shrimp appetizer was great, oysters ok very mixed in size. Fried grouper was good. Fun atmosphere and worth a visit.
… more
Frank Vvk
We had a light dinner here on during our road trip in The Florida Keys in February 2023. The place was busy, but we still were able to get a nice table. The staff was very friendly, not pushy and the salad we had was ok!
… more
Heather T
We went twice on our visit but it’s definitely a different experience if you do not get a table by the water. It’s the best view I saw in Marathon FL
… more
Cindy Smith
Ok first and foremost we loved it here. It was walking distance from our hotel. You can dine indoors or outside and be right on the water. There was a pier that extended out into the water which a lot of guests ans family’s took photos. Feeding dispensers that allowed you to feed the pretty fish below the pier and around us. The food was great. We had the calamari, shrimp pasta and one of the best key lime pies I had in all of the keys. Lively establishment and awesome staff.
… more
Allen bullard
We had this place picked as a must before we arrived into Marathon, and was further recommended by our resort concierge.
… more
Greg N
Great view and service. We loved looking at the boats and fish while waiting for our good. I found the lobster a little chewy. But the more basic meals were fine.
… more
… View more