Cash-only BYOB pizza joint firing up whole pies & red-sauce Italian dishes in an old-school setting. Based on 398 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
Address:
443 River Rd, Edgewater, NJ 07020
Phone: (201) 945-9096
Website: http://www.brooklynspizza.net/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ellen
One important note: THEY ONLY TAKE CASH. NO GOOGLE/APPLE PAY. Other than the payment inconvenience, the food and service is good. Ordered a large pizza half tomato & cheese and half white pizza. The edges were slightly burnt but the pizza was delicious. The crust was chewy, the bottom not soggy, there was enough ricotta and mozzarella cheese. The tomato & cheese pizza was good too. The tomato sauce tasted fresh. We also got their fried calamari which was good too.
… more
Jasna Acharya
The best pizza in New Jersey! Or maybe even New York. They use quality of ingredients ( like San Mariano tomatoes from Italy)…and the taste will have you wanting more.
… more
Steve Dempsey
Ordered a pepperoni pie here and it was great, really good pizza. Walked in and pie was ready in 15 minutes. Orfered a small pie but even so it seemed like a large pie.
… more
James Park
Came around 2PM, did not have to wait at all to be seated that helps when you’re starving. Ordered fried cheese ravioli and it never ceases to amaze me how delicious it tastes. The ravioli came out in about 5-10 min. Heard good things about the cheese and tomato with pepperoni and the rumors did not disappoint! Crispy thin crusts topped with fresh mozzarella
… more
Irene
This is still one of our most frequented pizza spots for takeout. The crust has a nice chew, and it took me years to figure out that I like the personal size pizza for lunch even better than the larger dinner pizza size due to the smaller circumference. Favorite toppings are still sausage, mushrooms, and peppers.
… more
Claire J
My favorite pizza place in whole New York & NJ area.
… more
Harout A
One of my favorite pizza spots in Cliffside park. The Margherita pizza is my favorite! Super thin crust with flavorful pizza sauce and generous amount of toppings. Love that they’re baked in a brick oven, gives a nice woody flavor to the crust and pizza as a whole. Love their calamari and they also have amazing salads. Also amazing service feels like home.
… more
King ShermanII
I love this place with some nostalgia as my family would go here on many occasions in the past, however recently I went there and it was just as good as I remember. The Pizza has that charcoal crust flavor that is just amazing. The Price for the Pizza is reasonable. the Appetizers are great, especially their fried mozzarella which is 1 of 2 places in this area that makes it that way. I had their typical tomato and mozzarella pizza(Margarita pizza) and it was outstanding in terms of quality.
… more
Finch
Cash only. BYOB wine/beer. Authentic coal (or is it brick?) oven. Casual ambiance. Fresh ingredients, thin crust, good tasting pizza. Did I mention BYOB? A large pie, two toppings, calamari will set you back bout $35. They do deliver but use paper bags instead of boxes and the pizza arrives soggy, best eaten on site.
… more
george johnson
Excellent pizza. First time i’v tried this place. Got the personal pizza with sausage. Was not disappointed. Very good crust and only 8$ ! Can’t be beat.
… more
… View more