Based on 214 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
14 Maple St, North Lewisburg, OH 43060
Phone: (937) 747-2606
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Megan Pack
My husband and I enjoy going and trying different pizza places around Ohio, we happened to be near the area and decided to stop by. The staff is very friendly, the service is great and the food is good. The pizza isn’t the best I ever had but its definitely no where near the worst, the sauce has an ever so slightly sweet flavor to it (my husband being a sweet sauce lover had a harder time tasting the sweetness). I got the french bread pizza and my husband got a regular pizza. I tried both and the crust and bread were both good, nothing too fancy but better then some pizza places we’ve tried. They dont skimp on the toppings which is always a plus, my husbands bacon pizza had plenty of bacon sprinkled over top. They do have a good selection of drinks too from Pepsi products (bottle or cans) and even some iced tea and a few other drinks I can’t remember. The building is a little older but they appear to be making updates (brand new lighting when we went in) and the tables were probably the cleanest I have seen in a restaurant in awhile. There are some arcade games, good for entertaining the kids, and their menu had other non pizza items as well. The pizza was a little on the expensive side for what it was but worth it to support a local business. You pay when you walk in and order then sit down so if you aren’t one to normally carry cash you might want to make sure you have some change with you for a tip.
… more
laryssa Travis
Very cute little pizza shop! Pizza is the best I have ever had. You should try the BLT!
… more
Amber Pullins
Pizza is great, but the customer service sucks. When you see a woman with 4 large pizzas and 2, 2 litter bottles of pop you should at least offer to open the door for her. Especially when you are just sitting on a stool in the corner with nothing to do.
… more
guyof07
I loved the pizza. I just wish you could eat inside.
… more
Chris Wells
Got a BLT Pizza it was good. I haven’t had the regular pizzas since 2003.
… more
Bottled Avenger
Great local pizzeria. It is always a great time if you get a cardinals pizza. They also support the local triad cardinals football team. Go Cardinals!
… more
Melanie MacRae
It’s so nice having a great pizza place close to home! They offer a huge variety of foods besides pizza (from burgers to burritos) and the delivered pizzas arrived when they said they would and they were piping hot and delicious. Highly recommend!
… more
Wade Jordan
I ordered 2 13” pizzas and was told 15 to 20 minutes. When I showed up 20 minutes later they stated it would be 15 to 20 minutes longer. I waited 20 more minutes and came back in and they said it was in the oven. I told them about this and they acted like they could care less and never said sorry we were slammed. Also the lettuce on the taco pizza was wilted and they changed their taco sauce which sucks. I usually don’t leave these type of bad reviews but their arrogance was beyond belief.
… more
Matt Wells
Don is a transplant survivor. So when our daughter got a liver transplant, Cardinals pizza bought us a water drinking system for Danielle. And helped out with things when Danielle was at Cincinnati Children’s for just over 12 weeks. That was over 7 years ago. And we thank for what they do.
… more
Garrett Phillips
Fantastic pizza and subs. Delicious and consistent! Great staff!
… more
… View more