Garrison Restaurant & Pizzeria (The old Papa Johns!) Menu – Garrison, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Garrison, NY

A locally owned and operated family business up and running for about 15 years. We are a warm and welcoming environment ready to serve any and everyone who walks through the door! We have a wide variety of dishes like pasta, pizza, Spanish food, tacos, sandwiches, etc. Come and visit us!

Take-out/delivery chain for pizzas, wings & breadsticks, offering a side of peppers with every pie. Based on 135 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Garrison Restaurant & Pizzeria (The old Papa Johns!) 10524

Address:
2534 US-9, Garrison, NY 10524

Phone: (845) 265-3344

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
 11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM
Sunday 12–8 PM

Menu

Starters
Fried Shrimp $9.95
Fried Calamari $10.95
Eggplant Rollatini $8.95
Fried Ravioli $6.95
Mozzarella Sticks $7.95
Zucchini Sticks $7.95
Jalapeño Poppers
With cheddar cheese, served with sour cream		 $6.95
Chicken Fingers $7.95
Onion Rings $4.95
Buffalo Wings
Served with blue cheese, celery, hot, mild, BBQ, teriyaki or garlic butter		 $8.95
Garlic Bread $3.50
Cheese Quesadilla
With salsa, sour cream, guacamole, refried beans		 $8.95
Potato Skins
Crispy/baked potato skins topped with cheddar pepper-jack cheese, bacon bits, s erved with sour cream		 $7.95
Pizza Bread
Pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese		 $4.95
Mussels Marinara $12.95
Spicy Chicken & Rice $5.95
Chicken Noodle $5.95
Pasta Fagioli $5.95
Minestrone $5.95
Vegetable $5.95
House Salad $4.95
Caesar Salad $6.95
Chef Salad
Served with ham, salami, provolone, turkey		 $7.95
Cold Antipasto Salad
Garden salad with salami, ham, provolone		 $8.95
Crumbled Blue Salad
Romaine lettuce with tomato, carrots, dried cranberries, blue cheese		 $7.95
Buffalo Salad
Fried chicken strips served with fresh tomatoes, celery sticks, blue cheese		 $7.95
Greek Salad
Mixed greens, feta cheese, fresh tomato, red onions, peppers, black olives, cucumber, drizzled with oil & vinegar and grape leaves		 $8.95
Garrison Salad
Served with bacon, tomato, mushrooms, mozzarella, hard boiled eggs, grilled chicken with Italian dressing		 $9.95
Caprese Salad
Lettuce, fresh mozzarella, fresh tomato, basil, roasted red peppers		 $7.95
Entrees
Spaghetti & Meatballs $9.95
Spaghetti & Sausage $9.95
Spaghetti W/ Garlic & Oil $7.95
Pasta Marinara $6.95
Penne A La Vodka $10.95
Cheese Ravioli Parmigiana $9.95
Cheese Manicotti Parmigiana $8.95
Lobster Ravioli
In pink cream sauce		 $10.95
Stuffed Shells Parmigiana $8.95
Meat Lasagna $10.95
Pasta & Pesto Sauce $9.95
Ravioli Marinara $8.95
Baked Ziti $8.95
Ziti With Broccoli $9.95
Ziti Siciliani
Meat sauce, ricotta, eggplant, cheese		 $10.95
Tortellini Alfredo $11.95
Tortellini W/ Meat Sauce $11.95
Fettuccine Romana
Onions, ham, peas, cream		 $11.95
Fettuccine Meat Sauce $10.95
Fettuccine Alfredo $9.95
Fettuccine Carbonara
Bacon, egg yolk, cheese, little cream		 $11.95
Pasta Fagioli Dinner $10.95
Linguine Primavera
Vegetables in garlic & oil		 $9.95
Linguine Calamari
Red or white		 $12.95
Linguine Clam Sauce
Red or white		 $10.95
Gnocchi With Meat Sauce $10.95
Gnocchi Marinara $9.95
Sausage & Peppers
Over pasta		 $10.95
Spicy Sausage
With garlic & oil		 $10.95
Chicken Parmigiana $14.95
Chicken Cacciatore
Peppers, onions, mushrooms, wine, red sauce		 $14.95
Chicken Alfredo $14.95
Chicken Sorrentino
Topped with eggplant, ham, mozzarella		 $15.95
Chicken Cutlet Saltimbocca
With fresh tomato & fresh mozzarella over pink sauce		 $15.95
Creamy Pesto Chicken $15.95
Chicken Francese
Egg battered chicken sautéed in a lemon butter, white wine sauce		 $15.95
Chicken & Broccoli A La Vodka $16.95
Chicken Marsala
Chicken breast sautéed with mushrooms, marsala wine		 $15.95
Chicken Borracho
(Drunken chicken) Peppers, onions, tomatoes, wine & beer		 $14.95
Chicken Piccata
With capers in lemon-butter white wine sauce		 $14.95
Garrison Special
Chicken, artichoke, garlic, sun-dried tomatoes, brandy cream sauce		 $16.95
Chicken Scarpariello
Hot cherry peppers, sausage, potato in white sauce		 $14.95
Eggplant Rollatini
Stuffed with ricotta, topped with mozzarella		 $14.95
Eggplant Parmigiana $14.50
Eggplant Marinara Or Fra Diavolo $12.95
Veal Parmigiana $16.95
Veal Marsala $16.95
Veal Piccata
With capers in lemon-butter white wine sauce		 $16.95
Stuffed Flounder Filet $16.95
Shrimp Parmigiana $16.95
Shrimp Francese
Egg battered shrimp in a lemon butter, white wine sauce		 $16.95
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Spicy sauce		 $16.95
Shrimp Scampi
Butter, wine, lemon		 $16.95
Shrimp Sinatra
Sautéed with tomatoes, basil, white wine sauce		 $16.95
Mixed Fish Platter
Marinara or fra diavolo, chopped clams, shrimp, calamari		 $18.95
Tilapia Francese $14.95
Mussels Marinara
Marinara or fra diavolo		 $16.95
Seasoned Grilled Chicken Breast $12.95
Seasoned Chuleta
Pork Chops		 $12.95
Seasoned Grilled Steak $16.95
Seasoned Grilled Tilapia $12.95
Carne Asada
Grilled Beef		 $12.95
Arroz Con Camarones
Shrimp rice with peppers, onions, peas & yellow rice		 $14.95
Arroz Moro With Chicken & Salad
Fried yellow rice with lentils, grilled chicken and salad		 $14.95
Meatball (3) $4.95
Sausage $4.95
Broccoli
Garlic, oil		 $5.95
Spinach $4.95
Rice & Beans $6.95
Fries $3.50
Cheese Fries $4.50
Bacon Cheese Fries $6.50
Side Pasta $3.95
Side Patacones $3.95
Sandwiches
Hamburger
Grilled to order with lettuce, tomato		 $6.95
Cheeseburger $7.95
Cajun Burger
With roasted red peppers, provolone, raw onions		 $8.95
Nacho Burger
Cheddar cheese, jalapeños, raw onions		 $9.50
Texas Burger
American cheese, bacon, fried egg		 $9.95
BBQ Cheddar Burger
Bacon, cheddar		 $8.95
Bacon Cheeseburger $8.95
Mushroom Swiss Burger $8.95
Pizza Burger
Tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese		 $7.95
Hungry Man Burger
Double cheeseburger		 $10.95
Ham & Eggs $6.95
Peppers & Eggs $6.95
Sausage & Peppers $7.50
Sausage Parmigiana $7.95
Meatball Parmigiana $7.95
Chicken Parmigiana $7.95
Chicken Club With Swiss Cheese
Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayo		 $8.95
Chicken Cutlet
With lettuce, tomato, mayo		 $7.25
Rialto Grilled Chicken
With roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic		 $8.95
Shrimp Parmigiana $8.95
Eggplant Parmigiana $7.95
Veal Parmigiana $8.95
Turkey Club With Cheese
With lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayo		 $7.95
BLT & Mayo $6.95
Philly Cheese Steak
With peppers, onions, mushrooms		 $8.25
Grilled Chicken Cheese
With peppers, onions, mushrooms		 $8.95
Ham & Swiss
With lettuce, tomato, mayo		 $4.95
Turkey & American Cheese
With lettuce, tomato, mayo		 $4.95
Italian Combo
Salami, provolone, ham, lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar		 $6.95
Tuna Salad
With lettuce, tomato, mayo		 $6.95
Tuscan Eggplant
With roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic		 $6.95
Chicken Italiano
Chicken cutlet, roasted peppers, provolone, oil & vinegar		 $6.95
Bacon, Chicken & Ranch $8.50
Chicken Cordon Blue
With ham, cheese, honey mustard		 $8.50
Grilled Chicken Caesar $8.50
Philly Cheese Steak
With onions, peppers, mushrooms, American or mozzarella cheese		 $8.50
Turkey Wrap
With provolone, bacon, ranch		 $8.50
Buffalo Chicken
With blue cheese		 $8.50
Grilled Chicken BLT
with mayo		 $8.50
Italian Combo $8.50
Roma Wrap
Grilled chicken, onions, mushrooms, cheese		 $8.50
Tuscan Eggplant
With roasted pepper, fresh mozzarella, balsamic vinegar		 $8.50
Pizza
Regular Slice $2.50
Sicilian Slice $3.00
All Gourmet Slice $3.50
Garlic Knots (6) $2.50
Pizza Pies $13.50
Chicken Pizza
Your choice of BBQ, Cutlet, Buffalo or Marsala		 $16.50
Bacon Chicken Ranch $17.95
Meat Lovers
Ham, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella		 $16.50
Fresh Tomato, Garlic And Herbs
no sauce		 $14.95
Vegetarian
Eggplant, onions, fresh tomatoes, broccoli, fresh garlic		 $17.95
Margarita
Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, plum tomatoes		 $17.95
White Pizza
With ricotta, pecorino Romano		 $14.95
Lasagna
Ricotta, pecorino Romano in a meat sauce with mozzarella		 $15.95
Hawaiian
Sliced ham, pineapple chunks		 $14.95
Baked Ziti
Our classic pizza loaded with baked ziti & ricotta		 $13.95
Salad
Carrots, cucumbers, black olives, red onions, Italian dressing		 $13.95
Supreme Pizza
Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, onions, peppers, black olives		 $17.95
Il Diavolo
Sausage, hot cherry peppers, garlic		 $17.95
Giardino Pizza
Artichoke heart, roasted peppers, black olives		 $17.95
Pepperoni Roll $6.50
Chicken Roll $6.95
BBQ Chicken Roll $6.95
Chicken Marsala Roll $6.95
Stromboli $6.95
Sausage, Peppers & Onions $6.95
Eggplant & Ricotta $6.95
Cheese Calzone $5.95
Meat Calzone $6.95
Chicken Calzone $6.95
Specials
Special #1
(2) Small Cheese Pizzas. Toppings Extra. No Substitutions. Please present coupon at time of order. Not to be combined with other offers or coupons. Pick Up or Dine In Only		 $20.00
Special #2
(1) Large Pizza, (1) Order of Small Wings, (1) 2 Liter Soda. Toppings Extra. No Substitutions. Please present coupon at time of order. Not to be combined with other offers or coupons. Pick Up or Dine In Only		 $21.95
Special #3
(1) Meatball Parm Wedge, (1) Chicken Parm Wedge, (1) Eggplant Parm Wedge, (1) 2 Liter Soda. No Substitutions. Please present coupon at time of order. Not to be combined with other offers or coupons. Pick Up or Dine In Only		 $22.95
Special #4
(1) Large Pizza, (1) Order of Mozzarella Sicks, (1) 2 Liter Soda. Toppings Extra. No Substitutions. Please present coupon at time of order. Not to be combined with other offers or coupons. Pick Up or Dine In Only		 $19.95
Special #5 A
10% Off All Catering Orders. Please present coupon at time of order. Not to be combined with other offers or coupons. Pick Up or Dine In Only
Special #5 B
$5 Off Any $50 Purchase. Please present coupon at time of order. Not to be combined with other offers or coupons. Pick Up or Dine In Only
Desserts
Cannoli $3.00
Tiramisu $3.75
Cheesecake $3.50
Fried Dough $3.00
Gelato $2.95
Beverages
Sodas
Juices
Iced Tea
Milkshakes
Hot Coffee
Hot Tea
Hot Chocolate
Imported
Domestic
Cabernet
Merlot
Sauvignon
White Zinfandel
Paisano
Papi Wine
Catering Menu
House Salad $25.00
House Salad With Grilled Chicken $40.00
Caesar Salad $35.00
Caesar Salad With Grilled Chicken $55.00
Classic Chef Salad $40.00
Fresh Mozzarella Salad $45.00
Cold Antipasto Salad $45.00
Mozzarella Sticks $65.00
Zucchini Sticks $60.00
Chicken Fingers $65.00
Buffalo Wings $49.00
Sausage, Peppers & Onions $49.00
Meatballs Marinara $49.00
Linguini
White or Red Clam Sauce		 $49.00
Ravioli A La Vodka $45.00
Ravioli Parmigiana $45.00
Manicotti Parmigiana $40.00
Stuffed Shells Parmigiana $40.00
Penne A La Vodka $45.00
Meat Lasagna $49.00
Baked Ziti $40.00
Pasta
Meatballs or Sausage		 $40.00
Pasta With Broccoli
In Garlic & Oil		 $40.00
Pasta Primavera $45.00
Fruit Salad $50.00
Cold Cut Platter
Ham, Salami, Provolone, Turkey		 $55.00
Roasted Red Potatoes $40.00
Vegetable Mix, Garlic & Oil $45.00
Broccoli, Garlic & Oil $45.00
Chicken Parmigiana $80.00
Chicken A La Vodka $45.00
Chicken Francese $49.00
Chicken Marsala $49.00
Chicken Piccata $49.00
Chicken Fra Diavolo $49.00
Chicken Sorrentino $49.00
Chicken Cacciatore $49.00
Eggplant Rollatini $45.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $40.00
Veal Parmigiana $70.00
Veal Marsala $70.00
Veal Francese $70.00
Veal Piccata $70.00
Shrimp Parmigiana $75.00
Shrimp Francese $80.00
Shrimp Fra Diavolo $80.00
Shrimp A La Vodka $80.00
Shrimp Scampi Over Linguini $80.00
Tilapia Francese Over Ziti $95.00
White Rice $25.00
Moro Rice $40.00
Shrimp Rice $60.00
Seasoned Grilled Chicken $50.00
Seasoned Pork Chops $50.00
Beans (Menestra) $40.00
Italian Or American $14.95
Assorted Wrap Platter $60.00
Cold Sandwich Platter $55.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Mellisa Sanders
Great burgers! Delivery is fast and friendly! They actually have pints of ice cream that are scooped to order! I love the coconut!

… more

AMF
Search pizza and pick the place with the best rating right? Due to the good reviews we looked forward to visiting. We 100% want to support a family owned business. Frozen fries served with a cold shredded chicken parm. The pizza below lacked a crust, flavor, and sauce. We did not finish the food. Stomach hurt later. I hope it was a bad night for the restaurant, but I can’t risk a second chance.

… more

S
I ordered pick up from garrison restaurant. The man who helped me was very kind and provided quick service. The prices here are great too. I got the tortellini Alfredo and I would highly recommend it.

… more

Annie B.
Staff was super nice and accommodating. Food was yummy too! I had potato skins and a meatball parm wedge. Everything was fresh and hot!

… more

J C
I buy here all the time I love that margarita pizza and there’s good people here that make you feel like family

… more

Simon Butt
Great Pizza, unexpectedly great salads, super staff

… more

Yssertouko (Tuko)
I really love their special menu. Specially the tilapia lol

… more

kim
Very surprised, don’t know why I was surprised, but they had really good pizza. Maybe, I was surprised because I’ve lived in WV and they say they have pizza down there, but it’s more like some cheese and sauce on a cardboard slab. Before y’all West Virginians attack me, this WAS 43 years ago, so who knows, maybe by now, you’ve upped your pizza game down there. Anyway, yes, I went off on a tangent, but the pizza is great, especially, when you order a whole pie, instead of a reheated slice. They have a lot of other things on the menu there, which I haven’t tried yet, but I will keep you updated. So far…YUM!

… more

Jaimie M
I love this place! The food is always delicious and the staff is always pleasant. Everything I’ve ever ordered has always exceeded my expectations. We’ve only had one mix up and they made sure to fix it right away. Their delivery service is good-on time and friendly. I typically order from there once a week and we’re always happy we did!

… more

Emilio Santiago
Good food fast delivery great service would definitely recommend to everyone

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch