Based on 222 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5216 Bethel Center Mall, Columbus, OH 43220
Phone: (614) 459-1111
Website: http://papagiorgiosohio.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
TIFFANY HAWKINS
I never thought I would find a grease stain sexy ! Their pizza is delicious, service friendly, and best of all around two minutes away from where I live. Nothing negative to say and will be getting pizza from here frequently. Oh and not sure if their blue cheese and garlic sauces are made in house but they are delicious!!
… more
Joey Jipping
I ordered a pepperoni and specifically asked them not to place any toppings within the outer 3 inches of the pizza, as this would provide the proper amount of distancing from the crust edge to make sure that I had zero toppings for those final bites of each savory slice. Actually, only the 1st 4 words of the previous sentence are true. Please consider,*gulp* adding more toppings so that they cover the entire pizza.
… more
Natalie Calderone
Best pizza I’ve ever had in Columbus…in Ohio…maybe ever! I was urgently hungry and Googled “pizza Bethel Road” and, lo and behold, Papa Giorgio’s Pizza popped up with a picture of a magnificent and very traditional looking margarita pizza.
… more
J Sanz
I was looking to try a new pizza place nearby. I remember distinctly the Papa Giorgio’s flyer I got at my last place and decided to try it. My boyfriend and I absolutely loved it! First time having it and it won’t be the last. We got the spicy vodka sauce and meatballs on our pizza. Everything from the cheese to the sauce and toppings were delicious, highly recommend!
… more
Rick Duckworth
I was kinda skeptical to get pasta given the lack of reviews but got the spicy vodka fusilil. It’s pretty stinking good. You’ll definitely want to add a meat. Vodka sauce shouldn’t be made without a meat. I got the sausage. This will go on the rotation.
… more
john m
Great NY style pizza! This spot years ago had a great new style pizza then a new place took over that had bad thin crust. Now its another New York style place that AMAZING. The pizza has tons of flavor, clearly great quality ingredients. I love the Ezzo Old World pep they use and the cheese is perfect & stringy. This is my new favorite pizza place in the area. Finally something great!!
… more
Zac W
Ordered a Supreme without olives and was pleased. East coast style thin crust pie with a bit of flop to it but comes together nicely. Great sauce and good service. Solid game day choice.
… more
Luke Hoover
Excellent pizza. The sauce is great, classic east coast style. Plus they gave us free breadsticks.
… more
a k
This is hands down some of the best pizza I’ve had in columbus. Its as good if not better than the pizza I’ve had in NYC. The crust is just right, the sauce is great, the toppings are generous and there’s just the right amount of cheese. Everything works together to create an amazing pizza.
… more
Phuong Marangoni
Best NY style pizza in the area. Their jumbo slices make for a very exciting eating experience!
… more
… View more