Family-run Italian kitchen for pizza, pasta dishes & subs, with limited indoor & outdoor seating. Based on 506 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
105 Yacht Club Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32084
Phone: (904) 342-8863
Website: http://vinnysnewyork.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nicole Wittkopp
First timer to St. Augustine and had to get pizza- the white pizza here was unbelievably delicious! I’ve never had white pizza before with ricotta on top but it slapped! The price was reasonable for the area and the service (I think the owner) was so nice and friendly!! Asked if I needed plates, utensils, extra. Really positive experience all around- wish I could go back!!
… more
shawn heater
Reminiscent of hole in the wall pizza joint in Jersey or New York. Good food and friendly people. The calzone had good taste and had plenty of cheese and ham.
… more
Mama Bear 420
I ordered a Italian sub, I got, ham, salami and pepperoni, tomato, lettuce,oil& vinegar and mayo. I didn’t order any mayo and there was no Provolone cheese! Very disappointed! The next sub was ham and cheese, mayo and oil & vinegar, tomato and lettuce. No cheese, and no oil and vinegar or lettuce. Very disappointed! I have to say, I will never order another sub there! Although…….
… more
Roger Meisinger
Just had a Deluxe pizza and garlic bread at Vinny’s. Both were great!! The pizza dough was thin and crispy around the edges and there were plenty of toppings!! I highly recommend you give them a try. Only a couple of indoor tables with some outside, but I would take their pizza home any time. Really enjoyed it.
… more
Marciano Torres
It was much better than expected. Got the 2 pain slices and a drink. As good as the average spots in Jersey. It’s got a very nostalgic atmosphere, like something I’ve had before, somewhere I’ve traveled through, but tucked in the nook of a marina in NE Florida.
… more
Renee Grant
We stopped in here before a cruise because of its close proximity to the marina. It was the best pizza my son has ever had. My mother had the baked ziti. She said the same thing about it. She had never had it with ricotta.
… more
Karri Mason
Arrived burnt. Sure we were given the option of them redoing it but we had already been waiting.
… more
Matt Carrere
Excellent place to eat. Employees were great. Took my order with a smile and we’re happy to answer any questions. Food was ready very quickly and was amazing. The toasted roast beef sub was topped with fresh tomatoes and lettuce and loaded full. Very conversational also, I would highly recommend amazing food and amazing people! Made sure we had toppings and silverware since since it was a to go order. Location has easy parking and the pizza is great!!!
… more
Jennifer Randolph
We got a pizza to go and it was very good! They even gave us plates and cheese and pepper flake packets!
… more
Elizabeth Silva
10 out of 10!! Visited before taking a sunset cruise for a quick bite… I’m so glad we did!! Their pizza is Ridiculously good!!!!! Better than George st! The people working there were so nice, even told my boyfriend to buy beer next door.. taking money away from their own business! … gonna be completely honest… I still think about the garlic knots.. OMG!! I will always stop by if im in town!!!
… more
… View more