Based on 371 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
110 S Pike Rd, Sarver, PA 16055
Phone: (724) 353-1111
Website: http://smokintoadsbbq.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–1 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jason Piwowar
Mac bowl was excellent! Cilantro Slaw was a refreshing treat!
… more
m Money
The bun for my sandwich had more moisture in it than my pulled pork in my sandwich. I don’t how you can screw up Mac & cheese but this place managed. I was there for 45 minutes and my cup was refilled twice by the waitress that had three tables and seemed to be overwhelmed. The lady that greats you at the front was just down right rude. She is incapable of smiling and has perfected the craft of side eyeing you every time she walked past. DO NOT GO !!!
… more
Noah Waldenville (KnexRules)
Excellent food, excellent prices, great service. No complaints here. One star off of atmosphere because of the sticky floors (due to the removed hard flooring I believe)
… more
Jenny Contenta
The place was giant and very different inside. The prices were good but the food was horrible. I got smokes dry turkey and the potato soup was old and stinky. My husband likes his brisket but agreed the rest of the food was not edible. Such a shame we wanted to love this place bc we love the surrounding towns and we drove over 20 miles to try this place out.
… more
Edward Streiff
This place is much bigger than it looks from the road. The food was fantastic and they have a lot to choice from. The overall feel of the place was very country and very pleasing to my family. The wait staff was younger but they were very pleasant and helpful.
… more
ghundah
Still searching for good BBQ in the SW PA area. Its all about the sauce. This sauce tasted like chemicals from the East Palestine site. Anyone that thinks this is great has obviously never been out of this area.
… more
Bob Musser
Floors were all sticky maybe due to removing tile but still. Slow to get waited on. Not a very large selection unless you consider their combinations. My wife had the brisket Mac n cheese tasted a little funny. Mac was tasty but noodles were overcooked. I ended having the fried chicken. Which was tasty, but who really goes to a BBQ place and orders fried chicken
… more
Coryn Neff
The food was really good. Ordered a smoking toad, they didn’t ask what bbq I wanted. I didn’t like the sauce. But later found out they have many different sauces. I was told my sauce was raspberry bbq. It tasted like a tangy tomatoes sauce with no other flavor. We’ll go back for another the fries were soggy with greese. He ordered a chicken burrito. He said it was ok, bit didn’t like the corn chips. Said they were oily.
… more
karen florian
Great BBQ, sides, desserts Friendly service I was stretching my arm after a bike ride and the waitress came and asked if I needed anything. Generous portions The slaws,were crisp with just enough dressing . Green beans fresh and cooked perfectly. Definitely going back!
… more
RUhungry 4more
The Food is always great, however, there are times when you walk in and there is nobody at the front counter. I’ve had to search the restaurant to find someone to assist me before. I do recognize that covid may be a contributing factor, so I don’t judge them too harshly. I’ve used smokin’ toads for catering, and they’re great! They delivered on time and provided all of the warming trays to serve my guests. Overall, I love this place and would recommend it to anyone looking for a nice casual dining experience.
… more
… View more