Based on 628 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
905 W Main St, Mount Joy, PA 17552
Phone: (717) 653-6181
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
James Gable
First time to Amato’s and I thought my pizza was delicious. We got a traditional cheese & marinara with green peppers & also tried a buffalo chicken bacon ranch pizza. I ate 3 slices of each. The crust is to die for, amazing crunch & the hint of burnt makes it perfect. Was recommended by a close friend who told me that the Italian sandwiches & dinners are excellent too, but I’m such a pizza lover, I’m not sure I will get to far into the menu, the different pizzas are enough for me to plan on returning
… more
Tim Hoover
Such a cool place. We had such a good time and the food was amazing. The wood fired pizza was very good. So much flavor and fresh ingredients. You won’t regret going to this place .
… more
MAG MAG
Everything was delicious we had such a nice meal and great experience… we will definitely be back with more people. Wish we had a restaurant like this around where we live
… more
Jacob Mathers
Amato’s was excellent! Our expectations were definitely exceeded- from the food as well as the service and atmosphere. Everyone in my party enjoyed their meals and the menu had a large number of unique options at reasonable prices. We’ll be back sometime soon!
… more
Caleb Gawne
My family and I used to love Amato’s, but we were treated with frustrating disrespect during our most recent visit. We were not only charged for burnt food, but were also told that we were liars about the quality of our food in front of other customers. The customer service was saddening, and we will not be returning.
… more
Peg Cramer
Three of us ordered 2 gourmet pizza pies. The star is a Stella pizza- it was amazing, so many topings that melded well together. The arugula pizza is the other picture and again, plenty of toppings. Our waitress was very pleasant and the food and drinks arrived quickly. I highly recommend Amato’s in mount Joy!
… more
Diane Mowery
The food is great, my Chicken Fajita Wrap was delicious. My husband really enjoyed his Cheesesteak. Ready to go back and try some other delicious item. Wonderful servers. Thank you. The meatballs were a sub, but I usually order hot subs with no roll. They were delicious.
… more
sarah messersmith
Got a caprese salad all tomato. Basically got a few tiny pieces of mozzarella. Never again will we order from here. So ripped off. Go elsewhere.
… more
Marlene Black
Typical pub in small town with 2 bars….one cute and well lighted…other..located in older part of the building. Not so much from the outside but it seems the locals frequent here.
… more
Derek Bryant
I tried their new Pucce sandwiches and they are spectacular. It’s fresh handmade bread for the sandwich cooked in the brick oven. Prices are slightly higher than your usual pizza joint (paid $12 for a sandwich instead of $9 at other places). But the quality and flavors of the food are totally worth it.
… more
… View more