Italian-American comfort eats presented in an informal space with wine, beer & outdoor seating. Based on 258 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
11534 Clifton Blvd, Cleveland, OH 44102
Phone: (216) 281-9191
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 1–8 PM |
| Thursday | 1–8 PM |
| Friday | 1–8 PM |
| Saturday | 1–8 PM |
| Sunday | 1–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 1–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sylas Leonardi
Stopped by on our way into Cleveland and everything was absolutely amazing. The guys working there were super sweet and hooked us up on food. Their croutons are homemade and the pizza was to die for. We got baked potato and cheeseburger pizza. Will definitely be back
… more
Sydney McLin
I love Papa Nick’s they’ve been around forever! First time we tried it we went in getting a Cleveland style (deep dish)pie which is so delicious and was so decadent! These days I stick to a regular pizza! With extra sauce and cheese! Their sauce is like no other and it’s just bright, robust and tastes fresh! I’m waiting on my next pizza now if only they could stay open later! ♥️ a Cleveland & Lakewood favorite!
… more
Heather Upton
Papa Nick’s was just what we needed! We ordered spaghetti, pizza, wings, and a calzone, all which were very good. The wings are not breaded, and even the “hot” is not super hot. They are huge wings, and were a little on the dry side on the edges, which I really like. The pizza and calzone dough was springy and full of flavor, almost buttery and a little sweet. The spaghetti was nice and they were huge portions. The drinks are done in a cooler inside…you just keep your empties and they add them all up once you are done. We also got to sit outside – they have several places to sit.
… more
David Simms
Tremendous service! A very personal touch when you come in.
… more
Lilly Papierowicz
It’s a nice little place I can walk to and grab a slice for a few bucks. I just regret not tipping the first time I went there because I didn’t notice the spot for it on the receipt I signed. Great pizza!
… more
Tiana Ramsay
Great Pizza! I had some church ppl at my house helping me move and I wanted to feed them something quick – We ordered a pizza and it was actually very good!! Def will order again
… more
tayyy hobbs
The gentleman whippin in the kitchen has been making pan in pizza’s for 42 years! This pizza here has crispy crust on the bottom and plus on top! The pepperoni was just to the point of sears crisp packed full of flavor and sauce that complimented the cheese to creamy perfection! It was an absolute mouth watering experience! They offer Pino Grigio that pairs exceptionally well with any combination of meals they offer!
… more
saxon veverka
The pizza is AMAZING best taco pizza I ever had, even the plain cheese pizza was phenomenal. 5/5 reccomend whether it be takeout or dine in this is a hole I’m the wall place that I never heard of until I was driving past and gave it a try. Easily in the top 5 pizza places in greater cleveland. Staff is very kind and friendly the resteraunt has a nice homey appeal to it, parking was fairly large for a small resteraunt. And prices were great compares to your main brands with much much more quality behind it.
… more
Richard Lockett
Ordered 2 pepperoni and sausage pizza and two dozens of wings, Spent $72 bucks. The wings were ok, the pizza was really dry there was barely any sauce on the pizza. All though the flavor on the pizza was really good the pies need more sauce!! Drove from Euclid to Lakewood due to the fact I was seeing amazing pictures on Facebook with toppings fallen of pizza I’m highly disappointed ordered pepperoni and sausage there was a lot of pepperoni but barely any sausage. I feel like I was taken. Arcade pizza on Broadway in Cleveland cheaper pizza and much better. Very disappointed in Pappa Nicks after spending $72 hard own dollars. First off Phil Thanks for making this wright. All I have to say is the two All meat pizzas I received from your establishment on 12/16/22 were fenominal or should I say perfect, it was a completely difference experience and the staff was so apologetic. I will be back and be sure to let family and friends know your pies ROCK. The Pizza was fenominal and the best all meat Pizza I ever had in Cleveland Area. Thanks Again.
… more
Johanna Conrad
Our first time here, and we’ll definitely return! Super friendly and attentive service, even though ONE person is cooking, serving, bussing, and delivering! Pizzas were fantastic. We sat outside because it was a beautiful day. Highly recommend.
… more
… View more