We specialize in NY style Deli sandwiches. Our go to’s are the simple bacon, egg, and cheese on a NY style Kaiser roll for breakfast, and for lunch our pride lies in the breaded chicken cutlet(which we freshly bread daily and make to order), of which we have a well variety of signature sandwiches. As for the morning crowd, the strongest running contender is the Tusker (a classic Bacon, egg and cheese topped with a hash-brown, and drizzled with hot sauce). A simple concoction, but made to perfection ?.. as for a hearty lunch sandwich, the younger crowd loves our self titled Froggy. Seemingly, a bit decadent, but sometimes you have give the people what they want.
Based on 69 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1620 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509
Phone: (845) 490-4013
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
6 AM–4 PM |
| Wednesday |
6 AM–4 PM |
| Thursday |
6 AM–4 PM |
| Friday |
6 AM–4 PM |
| Saturday |
6 AM–4 PM |
| Sunday |
7 AM–4 PM |
| Monday |
6 AM–4 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jonathan Gonzalez
This deli is fantastic. I’ve been stopping in on my lunch break for the last few months and I always get a great sandwich whether it’s off their breakfast menu or their signature lunch sandwiches. The staff and management are amicable and really pleasant even if you’re arriving a few minutes before they close. I usually get a lunch sandwich as a wrap but they’re also available as wedges or kaiser rolls
… more
Kristin M
Went to Froggy’s for the first time since moving here after a long day at the dog park and we will definitely be back! My veggie wrap was outstanding! I could eat one everyday. The blazing buffalo sandwich was also a hit. Don’t pass by this hidden gem.
… more
Tara
Had a basic garden salad with chicken, it was delicious. Fresh, quality ingredients. Would definitely come back.
… more
Filipe Costa
Best deli by far in the area. I highly recommended! Food is awesome and the service is even better
… more
Anonymous Chameleon
You had the Kingsley wrap, and now refuse to carry salsa anymore?! That’s why I go to you guys. Now I have nothing to order!!!! It’s not hard to order salsa….
… more
Kevin Brown
The best sandwich place in Brewster NY!!! My family loves this Froggy’s location, the sandwiches are always made fresh, staff is always so friendly and they make the best sandwiches!!! keep up the amazing work!!! 10/10 must try!!!!!
… more
David Stollings
Very good, very heavy, very worth it.
… more
Gary Z
Great food, awesome service, more businesses need to operate like this.
… more
Donna Atkinson
Sent my husband to get a bacon egg and cheese omelette today 6/26/22. The girl seemed lazy or didn’t no how to make an omelette. What we both ended up with was a fried egg, cheese with bacon on the side. My husband also got a avocado and they just scooped it out into his bowl and didn’t cut it. Funny, because yesterday we went to the Froggys in New Fairfield and got what we wanted which was the bacon egg and cheese
… more
Anthony Zito
It seems that the prices have dramatically increased at this location. I understand that inflation has affected us all, but the increases seem to be extreme. Two Tuskers were $15. That’s an egg sandwich! Two Turkey / Swiss, LTM on a roll, $25! It is unfortunate that the owners have decided to take advantage of their patrons by raising their prices so much! Unfortunately, I’ll have to find another deli for breakfast and lunch!
… more
… View more
