Based on 180 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
587 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769
Phone: (631) 589-9640
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 3:30–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Josephus B
My wife and I visited yesterday afternoon for their pasta special. We live nearby, but we haven’t been here in years. Friends have told us to give it another try, and we loved our meals and the service. Kyle was our server, and he welcomed us both just as he did his many “regulars”. I had the rigatoni di Spago and she had the Penne Rigate Alla Bellini. The servings are more than enough for 2-3 meals, and their homemade lentil soup was also excellent. This place is a hidden gem, and we will become frequent customers. Thank you, Kyle and your team!
… more
Patriot The Penguin (Bottlesgonewild)
Kyle.was.our server
… more
Benjamin Jolly
Pizza was very good, made quickly. Well topped, good attention to details like keeping bubbles under control and topping the pie to the edge of the crust. So good I stood in my hotel’s kitchen and ate a couple slices, wasn’t going to waste time sitting down!
… more
Glenn
Friday night is go out to dinner night…and a treat indeed to find such a gem. Home cooking with no waiting! Cozy and warm, friendly and delicious. Generous portions with a full menu and reasonable prices. We’ll be back!
… more
D
Christie is very sweet and attentive. We really enjoy the great shrimp marinara and love the spinach cannelloni! Pasta Night specials on Monday and Tuesday make dinner out an easy choice. It includes a glass of wine, salad, bread, and cheesecake to go (along with half of my dinner because who could eat it all?)!
… more
Robert Jones
The food here is outstanding! As for Italian food, this is the closest you’re going to get to real homemade food. I’ve never been disappointed. The pasta nights on Monday & Tues are a great deal. Service is always on point no matter which server u get. Kyle is top notch. Skip the other places & try this one, you’ll be happy you did.
… more
Amanda Morris
I hate to leave a mediocre review because the food was amazing. It is the best veal parm I have had in ages. And I loved and miss the Centereach location. But the tables are so cramped and the service was not up to par. They were nice but our meal took two hours. It was impossible to flag down a server and everything took forever to come out. I just can’t recommend dine-in until they staff it better. But for takeout I would do it because the food is phenomenal.
… more
eldon tyrell
Nice Italian pizzeria/restaurant in Oakdale on Montauk Hwy. Some typical Italian dishes served in the restaurant. Did not try the pizzeria. Very good wait staff, food was good even by a real Italian foodie’s standards.
… more
Milagros Morris
Mama’s in centereach was our favorite spot, so we drove further to try Oakdale Mama’s. We sat at 6 pm and left at 8:15 pm. They only had 1 server, so I understood the wait issue. But it was a very cramp space and the food is not quite the same.
… more
Simaan Gaffary
I came to this place with my wife for dinner, and for 3 days after, we didn’t have to buy dinner because their portion sizes are so damn BIG. Prices were low and it was good too.
… more
… View more