New York Slice Company is a New York Style Pizza joint in Sarasota, Florida. Family owned and operated, N.Y. Slice Co. offers gourmet, hand-tossed, New York style pizzas, Strombolis, and Calzones. We keep a hot slice cabinet stocked with 3 different pizza flavors for pizza-by-the-slice. Our full menu offers a wide selection of pasta dinners, salads, appetizers, and desserts. Our thin sliced roast beef is HALA certified which goes in our Philly Rolls and Italian Dip sandwich and can be used as a custom topping or filling.
Based on 191 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
501 N Beneva Rd #250, Sarasota, FL 34232
Phone: (941) 366-8125
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael F
This place is the real deal when it comes to pizza. I mean, I almost didn’t want to leave a five-star review because then everyone will know about it and it might get too busy for me to get my daily fix.
… more
CT West
Well, we would love to try the pizza. We received rave reviews for our neighbors. So we decided to give a taste. My wife called in our order for a large Hawaiian, and she was told 45 minutes for pickup. Spoke to a younger gentleman who failed to announce his name. Upon attempting to pick up, she was told there was no such order in place. Real big disappointment. Apparently, you have to go there to be successful at getting a pizza.
… more
Neil McStravick
Went to the Wendy’s in their parking lot and they had drive through only so I tried these guys out. For the price I was very pleased with what I received. Their 2 slice and a can of soda for $5 is probably the best deal in town. I’m from Boston so I like the up North style of pizza and this is it. Thin crispy crust with tasty chees and sauce. This isn’t fine dining, it’s a no frills seating area but it’s all you need for this. The service was excellent as well. This is now my new stop when I’m on the go. I highly recommend this place.
… more
Lottie L.
My first time ordering food and eating from this NY pizza joint. I ordered 2 pies and a supreme calzone, one cheese and one 3 topping. The crust was just right. I typically favor pizzas with toppings when ordering from chain pizza places but their cheese pizza was more flavorful than the pizza with 3 toppings. I wish the 3 toppings pizza would be just as flavorful. The calzone supreme was fine. The sauce it came with was delicious! I used it on my 3 toppings pizza and that gave it flavor it was lacking. Nevertheless, the pizzas were good and satisfied my cravings!
… more
brenden coviello
Def has a great slice, that’s fosho! I’ve spent a lot of time in NYC. I’m also an avid pizza maker (at home) and a pizza connoisseur. Prices are excellent. I’ll def be back but for 2 pies next time. Only thing I observed is they’re open till 8 and it didn’t seem like they were willing to make additional pies for people coming in for their 2 slice deal. I could be wrong but that’s the impression I got when there were only 2 slices left at 4:30pm. Try to go before, during, or after lunch but not early evening if that’s what you want.
… more
Chris G
This place does not honor there stamp card. Went in today to try and get food this would of been my 5th purchase and on your 5th purchase you get a 3 topping pizza for free. Instead of honoring it they told me would have to be on my next visit, No were on the card does it say this. What would be the difference with just giving it to me today and making me wait 2 days from know. That’s right Nothing!. Just lazy workers not wanting to do there job. Poor Customer Service will not be going back anytime soon.
… more
Dorothy Poor
Overall it was an interesting dining experience. The staff was friendly..The restaurant seemed dirty, I noticed the man making the pizzas wasn’t wearing gloves when handling food. The bathroom was really gross… the food was too salty, and they don’t have many GF options. I had a Greek salad, my son had ravioli. It was interesting, but I’m not sure I will be back. Possibly a good cheap option for slices.
… more
A B
I’ve got pizza from this place
… more
Dixie Lee Hodges
Absolutely the most horrible Calzone that I eaten in my entire Life.
… more
Kyle F
Love your supreme Stromboli with extra sauce but last night no one told me you were out of sausage. I would’ve waited and ordered the next day or after. I can see you guys read, respond and address your reviews, which you guys did offer to fix my order when I called to check what happened, and I can respect that. I also appreciate when you guys stay open a little later for pick up. Also, your owner responses are hilarious!!! We don’t sell cookies!!! Lol!!
… more
… View more