Based on 183 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
11 Jack and Jill Pl, Eastsound, WA 98245
Phone: (360) 376-2505
Website: http://myislandpie.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 12–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
James Conner
First the pros: The view from the patio is stellar. The roasted beet salad was the best thing we had there.
… more
jamal harris
Totally forgot to leave a review but this place is beyond exceptional, food was amazing, and the people that work here are amazing. I forgot my wallet at the restaurant and the staff was responsive and sent me my wallet in the mail! Thank you island pie! We’ll definitely be back.
… more
Kristen Bohm
We eat here pretty often living on the island. By far the best pizza you will find on and off the island. Being able to slow down, relax and enjoy the views with great drinks and food this is the best place. With food allergies in the family this place definitely has quality ingredients, and great staff. Would absolutely recommend you visit.
… more
Olga Suvorova
This place is fantastic (I honestly don’t understand the unfairly low-ish 3.9 stars rating it currently has). Pizzas are so tasty: we tried “Americas favorite” with pepperoni and cheese and it was delicious. The dough is made in house and is so fresh it melts in your mouth. Garlic knots were delicious as well.
… more
Stephanie Taylor
Absolutely wonderful food. Loved our pizza, the squash special (we added chicken) the sauce was fantastic. Their Island Salad which is their spin on a Caesar salad was also great. Everyone was kind and it is a beautiful patio.
… more
Carlee Hobbs Toth
Great pizza, great service, great location! We were a large group, and we were able to sit on the porch at sunset. Favorite pizzas were the butternut balsamic and the sausage shallot. But classics were good too.
… more
Jolene
We walked in and thebplace looked deserted, empty and old. I was not expecting much for the food, howerver; I was proven wrong. The pizza here was amazing and delicious. I saved golf for the next day and it tasted just as good cold. Great place for pizza.
… more
Jordan Lorell
This is one of my favorite places to eat! The owners are a wonderfully kind couple that provide a beautiful and welcoming dining atmosphere. My husband and I have made multiple day trips from the Seattle area specifically to visit, where we can watch the boats in the marina over a glass of wine and delicious pizza. Highly recommend the seasonal squash offering the fall, that one was gone almost the second it hit the table!
… more
Pablo A
I really don’t like to give small businesses bad reviews, but as other reviewers have said, this place really has some issues they need to fix. The service was non-existent, and the pizza was small and just ok. We were seated without menus for 15 minutes before I went and found some on my own. Then, we had to flag down the only person waiting tables in the entire restaurant who hurriedly took our order for what we thought would be a large pizza (it wasn’t). When the pizza did arrive an hour and 15 minutes later, it was mediocre at best. To top it all off, we had to eat the slices on our napkins since no plates or anything else was provided. No drink orders were taken after the first round and the staff avoided any interaction through the entire experience. Sorry Island Pie, I really did want to enjoy your establishment but you need a lot of improvement. I will say, the views of the harbor are great, so at least there’s that!
… more
Anna Marie
This place is amazing. The pizza was delicious! The lady that brought the pizza was super sweet. I imagine she was the owner as she knew a lot about the pizza, and seemed very passionate about how it was made. We got the seasonal squash pizza. Also the chocolate pis dessert we got was amazing too!
… more
… View more