Barrila’s Pastaria is the creative kitchen of master chef Marco Barrila voted best Italian food on the North Fork. Enjoy fresh handmade pastas with signature Sicilian sauces, pizza alla pala, local seafood and lobster, Mediterranean meats and steak specialty desserts. Eat inside Il Giardino, the Italian inspired light filled and spacious dining room or alfresco on La Terrazza. There are many private dining and an event space to accommodate groups for celebratory and special occasions. Also, order platters and trays for easy entertaining or book your full-service catering off-site at location of your choice. Located close to the aquarium, theatre and vineyards, we offer a variety of gourmet foods to go. Ask about our food truck too!
Based on 212 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
300 E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901
Phone: (631) 726-4444
Website:
Hours
| Tuesday |
12–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday |
Closed |
| Thursday |
12–8:30 PM |
| Friday |
12–9:30 PM |
| Saturday |
12–9:30 PM |
| Sunday |
12–8:30 PM |
| Monday |
12–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Reviews
Robert Laurie
Fantastic and authentic Italian food. The wait staff is so kind and helpful from top to bottom. All the pasta is fresh homemade and so is their delicious bread. Their isn’t anything on menu that hasn’t been great. Since my first visit with my wife we have since gone back twice (for my dad’s birthday and my in laws anniversary). We are all Italian and everyone loved the food! Can’t wait to go back!
… more
Kenneth Harkin
We were looking for a new place to try and were pleasantly surprised to find this restaurant. The atmosphere is excellent and the food incredible. Our pasta dishes were the best we have had since returning from Italy four months ago. I had the open lasagna, half of which will be lunch tomorrow, and my wife hs the spinach ravioli. We look forward to returning and trying more dishes.
… more
Marcia Wallace
I recently had a fantastic lobster, shrimp, and mussels dinner with black ink linguine created by Chef Marco– it was absolutely delicious and I could not have been more satisfied! My guests were equally thrilled with the meal!
… more
Mary (UniqueFiveX)
My family went for a meal, everyone loved what they ordered. I had the pesto penne with chicken and it was delicious, the lasagna was a big portion and also great. The Caesar salad was fresh and delicious. They even accommodated my father who has dietary restrictions. Clean place, friendly staff, I would love to go back for another meal!
… more
Jonathan
The food was very mid compared to other Italian restaurants. 20+ dollars for a pie that was completely wrong. The staff was slow and got the orders wrong twice. What’s the point of having a menu if you can’t follow it? The ONLY good part of the food was the bread they served at the beginning and the calamari. We asked for more bread which we were willing to pay for but they just gave us what looked like stale breadsticks. The personal pies are hella expensive for what tasted like processed cheese on a flatbread. This place is just an expensive bougie restaurant with nothing uniquely Italian about it other than the music they play.
… more
Ronald Lane
Had a Barrila Burger at the bar today satisfied more than satisfied my craving it was juicy and great flavor next to hand cut Fries overall nice atmosphere with very good vibes!!
… more
Jermine Konan
Absolutely delicious! We’re here now and every dinner is amazing! The waitress is the sweetest! We are regulars!
… more
Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
Wow, an amazing place. Tell ’em Barsnobs sent ya! Food was top notch. Gourmet and delicious. I have eaten at many Italian restaurants but this one takes the cake! The pasta is out of this world. The salad, out of this world. Tiramisu and Cappuccino….you got it, out of this world. What wasn’t? The atmosphere needs to be a bit darker. It was too bright and it was very cold with the ceiling to floor windows now that it’s getting colder. The drinks were just good, not amazing. Overall, this place is worth the night out. Go!
… more
Morgan Paige
Great food. Nice big parking lot that’s hidden in the back. When I came out from having dinner, there were young adults still sitting in their car that we saw on our way in for dinner so it seems like it has its own nightlife the parking lot, lots of activity back there! Amazing homemade pasta
… more
Rowena Arrieta
Fast and friendly service. (I don’t understand the other negative reviews.)
… more
… View more
