Based on 219 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
605 C S 12th St, Murray, KY 42071
Phone: (270) 762-0441
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–1 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kelly Colson
Last 2 weekends I ordered 3 Large pizzas for $8.03 each. Got 5 toppings on each and they are so good! Crust is thin, but I make my own garlic butter and dip my crust. Cheapest pizza in town – carry out or delivered for a fee. Will order again!
… more
Iden Snapp
Just get dominos, food was cold and burnt, my salad was hot? But our sandwich and fries were cold, like sat on a shelf for 45 minutes cold. Was really hoping for a good choice in town but I’ll skip it from now on.
… more
Heidi Baylor
The pizza was great! The salad would have been great – except the Marzetti Blue Cheese Dressing packets were spoiled and once you place it on the salad there is no taking it back off. Patty melt was a burnt burger with raw onions and un-melted cheese. Called to let them know about the dressing and told them it ruined my salad and they offered me nothing. Buyer beware.
… more
Anita Crouch
When I ordered delivery they said it would be 45 minutes. I received it in 23 minutes. Great service and delivery driver
… more
Dominick Justave
First time ordering here, was great the flavor perfect, red sauce perfect. If you live around here or from the Northeast and need some good Italian food this is the spot .
… more
Alex Harriford
I gotta say they one of my favorite places!! I order there quite often!!!!!
… more
amanda Smith
Great prices and it’s fast. They are open late too like 1 am
… more
Amber Eldridge
We order about twice a month from the slice app and usually have great food delivered in a timely manner. Occasionally the wings are over cooked, but they still taste amazing. Their wings are our favorite in town.
… more
Cheyenne Smith
We get Baldy’s quite a bit and never have any issues. This time we could have sworn we ordered a pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese and we definitely ordered a 20 oz soda. The drink was the wrong drink; they said they were out of the one we ordered which is understandable but it was a 16 oz drink when we were charged for a 20 oz. They told me they don’t carry 20 oz drinks when we just had them three days ago and were given 20 oz drinks. With the pizza I guess we didn’t select pepperoni when we thought we did which is fine but it was cold and the woman on the phone was also very condescending. As a customer service worker I know that the customer is not always right but she said to me, “If you want a pepperoni pizza, feel free to order pepperoni next time.” Which felt incredibly rude when I tried to remain kind and understanding the entire time. It was a Saturday night so it may have been an off day but I didn’t enjoy being talked down to.
… more
Billy Pendergrass
Great pizza. I’ve tried pizza from many places all across town and have been primarily disappointed. Then I tried Baldy’s grill. The pizza was absolutely delicious. Great flavor perfect sauce to toppings ratio and light and airy crust. Definitely my go to from now on.
… more
… View more