Based on 158 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
3176 US-98, Mary Esther, FL 32569
Phone: (850) 374-3054
Website: https://damatteopizzeria.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christina Forrest
Oh my goodness! The food was amazing! I had the homemade spinach ravioli. The sauce was to die for! My husband loved his seafood pasta. Our waitress was amazing, the food was just phenomenal, and excellent beer and wine! On Tuesdays and Thursdays, the chef makes homemade pasta! My teens loved their pizzas!
… more
Debbie Nix
Worlds Best Lasagna
… more
Rod Nichols
I had chicken parm. The sauce was so good. The appetizer was a big cheese ball with some kinda ricotta or cottage cheese all fried together. This was delicious and the texture was unexpectedly great. Wife said pizza was superb to. Limoncello cake was like it had some special ingredient that you could be come addicted to. I will go back soon.
… more
Elizabeth Kim
10 out of 10 Italian spot! This small-business is perfect for a date night, family dinner, and friends celebration! Right when you enter, you are greeted by a chic and classy interior. “This must be the place” and it sure is! You feel a sense of peace and comfort.
… more
Holly Hershberger
All of our food was absolutely fantastic!!! I had the Alfredo. I substituted the Fettuccine noodles for Linguine because I prefer Linguine noodles. My husband had the Lasagna and said it was the BEST Lansagna he has ever had hands down. My mother had the kids meal spaghetti and my cousin had the Rigatoni Alla Bolognese with Red Wine. All of us loooooved our meals. The service was great as well. They were so incredibly sweet. The only only thing I found odd was they served us canned drinks and I actually needed a second one because I finished my drink and they charged me for a second drink. So, $6 for two cans of Sprite? I was not a big fan of that, buuuuuut the food and service definitely outweighed that and I will definitely be going back and supporting this local business and giving them my money. Holy smokes, they truly are amazing!!! I think I’ll try their Pizza next time. Heard someone in the parking lot rave about their pizza. Highly Recommend this place!
… more
Vincenzo Donnarumma
I recently had the pleasure of dining at this restaurant, and I must say that it was a truly wonderful experience. Being Italian, I can say the food was absolutely authentic and delicious, and every dish that I tried was bursting with flavor. I discovered that the cook is from a town close to mine in Italy.
… more
Gayle Ochs
The best New York pizza in our area is here! We asked for additional garlic and got fresh chopped garlic! We had Caprese which was absolutely delicious! The white staff is very accommodating! They have a full bar. The menu is excellent Italian Fare. They have handicap parking, handicap bathrooms as well. They will do take out for you when you come inside and order.
… more
Casey Scheff
My family stopped in after reading great reviews and we are so glad we did! The inside is super cute and well decorated. Our waitress greeted us promptly and was super patient while we decided what to get with our children. We started with a pizza- we did half pepperoni and half Al copone. You could tell all the ingredients were fresh and the crust was fantastic. We have been looking for a decent pizza since we moved to the area and this one definitely did. My husband got the 4 cheese gnocchi and it was so flavorful and delicious. I ordered the lasagna and it was huge. Great flavor but I will probably get something different next time. My son got the kids fettuccine Alfredo and it was great. They give you bread with a garlic olive oil dip and it was fresh and yummy. We ended with the limoncello cake and the cake itself was great but I wasn’t a fan of the sauce that came with it. We will absolutely be back. Great food and great service.
… more
Amanda Martin
This small local Italian restaurant was a delightful surprise. My husband and I shared a piemontese white cheese sausage and mushroom pizza. It reminded us of the Napoli pizza we ate in Italy itself. And we finished with a delicious piece of tiramisu. We will definitely be regulars now.
… more
Tamela Schultz
We visited for lunch, and were the only patrons in the restaurant the entire time. Should have given us a sign of things to come. We ordered lasagna and the mushrooms and pasta with truffle oil. It was average tasting nothing special. I wanted it to be amazing based on all the reviews we’ve read. We also ordered a coke and one beer on tap. Bill was $60, for lunch for two! We don’t mind paying that for an exceptional meal, but this was not, sadly. I don’t think we’ll be back.
… more
… View more