Based on 60 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
112 Main St, Tuckahoe, NY 10707
Phone: (914) 346-5566
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 7 AM–5 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–5 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–5 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–5 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–5 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 7 AM–5 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J Lim
Delicious, authentic Italian sandwiches. Friendly and warm service.
… more
John Galluzzi
Very good Italian food, hot tray & quality imported products – excellent service. Quaint outdoor seating area. Owners & counter staff – very accommodating.
… more
Kelly Foley
Great people and fantastic food. Found them during pandemic and have been going ever since. Highly recommend their ribs, chicken cutlet parm. and eggplant
… more
Jessica Jones
I noticed this place because they often have a sign out front that says they have chopped cheese, which is one of my favorite things. If they keep putting it on a sign, I figured they must have a really good one so I wanted to try it. I was really disappointed. 🙁 the sandwich I got was some kind of sliced beef with cheese — not a chopped up hamburger. It also had no lettuce, tomato, mayo or ketchup, which pretty much always come on a chopped cheese. It was just a dry beef and cheese sandwich. 🙁 I also grabbed a pack of Italian cookies — I ate one and the sprinkles on it tasted like pink food coloring. It left a chemical taste in my mouth for like a half hour. I spent $30 here including a 20% tip, and I threw everything away. So disappointing, because it looks like they have some pretty good food, and they have great reviews. Hopefully it was just a mistake, but the place is too expensive for me to want to try again.
… more
Izzy P
Great food and service. These guys are the neighborhood spot you can depend on!
… more
Nicole Jastillana
Had the Al Pacino hero. Best sandwich. Lovely little place in Tuckahoe.
… more
Barry Sciacca
Fantastic food and service at great prices
… more
Santo Russo
My son and I stumbled upon San Fratello driving through Tuckahoe. We saw menu and when we walked in were incredibly impressed by the warm welcome and great (authentic) Italian treats. The sandwiches – amazing. So many great options to choose too. Try the Al Pacino, you’ll be back for more – just like us. Buon appetito!
… more
Alexandra Monteleone
Absolutely delicious! San Fratello deli catered my sons first birthday and what an impression they made on my friends and family! We had about 110 guests and there was plenty of food, serving trays, sternos etc. They did a fabulous job! We ordered trays of shrimp, salad, pastas, clams, eggplant parm and more. The food tasted homemade, it was so good ! I absolutely recommend this delid will be back for more!
… more
Linda Gambardelli
Small place but packed with Italian goodies. Specialty pastas from Italy Cookies and breadsticks to name a few things. Also a Deli with good Italian bread. If the bread is no good the sandwich is no good.Friendly staff makes it a pleasure to do business there. Would recommend this business if you like Arthur Avenue quality food.
… more
… View more