Welcome to By The Fire Pizza, an exceptional pizza destination in Columbia, SC. Inspired by the flavors of Italy, we bring you a taste of culinary tradition. Our pizzas feature house-made slow-cooked sauce and locally sourced ingredients, capturing the authentic essence of Italian cuisine. Indulge in our signature 14 Three Meat pizza, topped with cheese, pepperoni, bacon, and sausage. Step into our inviting restaurant as we redefine the pizza experience, fusing Italian authenticity with bold flavors. Thank you for choosing By The Fire Pizza. Immerse yourself in the vibrant flavors of Italy, right here in Columbia.
Based on 117 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
6169 St Andrews Rd Ste 110, Columbia, SC 29212
Phone: (803) 814-2281
Website:
Hours
| Wednesday |
4–9 PM |
| Thursday |
4–9 PM |
| Friday |
12–9 PM |
| Saturday |
12–9 PM |
| Sunday |
12–9 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Stephen Sark
Our first time to try this restaurant, we were not disappointed. The owners and other staff were very attentive and helpful. The fried ravioli for an appetizer was good. The three pizzas we tried were all great (Margherita, Supreme and BBQ Chicken). Crust is good thickness, not too thin and still has a good chewiness. Marinara is slightly sweet the way I like it. Welcoming atmosphere, large dining area with plenty of seating options. Will definitely go back again.
… more
C S
GREAT food! The employees are so friendly. This place really feels like
… more
Leitner Family
First time. Smoked chicken wings in 2 different sauces. Loaded fries. 4 different pizzas: Gyro, Jamaican Jerk, Margherita and Italian sausage. And cannolis. Handmade and delicious. Our server, Ella gave us great recommendations and the owner came out to meet us and was extremely pleasant to talk to and discuss all the homemade ingredients. We will DEFINITELY be back soon. The food is worth the wait for the fresh ingredients.
… more
Cherri Spaulding
Family of 6 had a great experience here. Service was outstanding. Everyone enjoyed their food. Our server was very attentive. Anything we needed was brought promptly. Salads were fresh, brick oven bread was delicious. Kids had a large cheese pizza that was enough for 3 growing boys. Adults & one child had the personal size which was plenty to bring home leftovers. One of the best dinners out we have had in a long time. Plenty of parking. Highly recommend & will be back.
… more
Kristen Greco
First off I have to shout out the owner. She was fantastic! She played hostess, waitress and chef with a shortage of workers. Short staffed and the food still came out fabulous. The side salad is a generous portion and all the veggies were crisp. My husband and I shared a sausage pizza, it was very good. The crust was crispy, the sausage fresh ground, and the sauce reminded me of home (NJ). If you’re craving some good ole NY/NJ pizza this is a great spot to go to. Highly recommend. Please like and share below.
… more
Shaun Harris
The service and food here is exceptional. It’s always so quiet inside and the atmosphere is relaxing.
… more
Evetta Shivers
By far the best Pizza I ever had as a first time guest, I was pleased with everything. The host with the pretty green locks was amazing and very nice. She greeted me with the biggest smile. The pizza is delicious super satisfied. Will be back soon and bringing friends. Thank You By The Fire Pizza we love you!
… more
angus Godwin
The food was okay, but it wasn’t worth the money we paid. It was really expensive for a few sizes of pizza in 6 wings.. The money we spent, we could have gone and had a nice steak somewhere.
… more
Rylan Cochron
I got the Jamaican Jerk pizza on a whim since it seemed interesting. On the drive home it smelled so good I had to have a slice and, my god, it was incredible.
… more
Donna McCarter
We absolutely love ByThe Fire Pizza!! Thank you for coming to our “neighborhood”! The food is so good and the owners and staff are amazing! It is so good to go to a place that has good food and makes you feel like family!
… more
… View more
