Relaxed, family-friendly chain serving up pizza & sandwiches, plus salads & desserts. Based on 913 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
33 E Broadway St, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Phone: (317) 392-4677
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tracy Smith
Cagney’s has always been my favorite place to go to for pizza! I will drive from out of town to get it. The service is always outstanding, and I love the atmosphere. My issue with going there is just how dirty the bathrooms are. There isn’t a surface in it that I would touch. The kitchen floor that is visible from the front desk is dirty, but the bathrooms are disgusting. Please tell me that someone can spend some time cleaning and disinfecting the place each night. It needs some serious elbow grease! I want to continue going to this establishment. But I cannot keep overlooking the filth that includes mice running around the bar.
… more
Steven Diamante
Loved there shrimp cocktail specially for just $3.75 | also there Taco Pizza was Amazing
… more
Molly Wheeler
New to the area & my family decided on Cagney’s Saturday night,thanks to google search. Our server Danielle was awesome, she gave my family the best customer service we have ever had. We will be requesting her from this day forward. The BBQ Chicken pizza is my family’s new go to! The kids loved the breadsticks and cheese the most. It was an all around awesome experience and we will be back however the dinning room could use a makeover. Brighten it up some, up to date decor. Thank you cagneys for not disappointing my family see you again soon.
… more
VALERIE KEHRT
Hate to do this for many reasons but last few times pizza so disappointing. Hardly any toppings,dry,what little bit of cheese was dissentegrated due to over cooked. Crust so hard & rim black. For the money(I did use coupon) terrible value. I expect to pay but don’t want to pay this amount for dry,tasteless pizza. Didn’t used to be this way. Pictures you show don’t resemble at all what I’ve been getting. I’ve always loved Cagney’s & love spending local but too much money for this. Sorry. I understand costs going up etc but the last few times pizza lacking toppings & terrible.
… more
Julie Tinsley
If I could give this no stars I would. I swelled up to the point I thought I might have to go to hospital. I ate 2 pieces and threw the rest out. Why. It tasted like a salt shaker was dumped on it. I buy my food with no salt added. Didn’t know they add that much salt to their pizzas. Shame on you for not telling me. You could of killed me.
… more
Amanda S
If you like a traditional Pizza King location with either a train delivering your drinks or their famous dill butter brushed breadsticks..this is NOT the pizza king for you. Unfortunately, both the kitchen service and dining room service was very slow, food took a long time to come out, couldn’t get our drinks refilled. Server wasn’t attentive and didn’t do any table touches. She was there to take the order and drop off a check. They seemed to be properly staffed and there was just two of us. I can’t imagine dining in during lunch or dinner rush. There was a lounge entrance in the back of the dining room and at one point, we considered relocating back there.
… more
Jimmy Giordano
Sat in the bar area for lunch and tried the tenderloin. It was okay, but I will stick to their pizza or hot sandwiches. The beer was cold and the waitress was awesome! She was the Bar Tender/Waitress and she was killn it!
… more
Tyler Duncan
Good tavern style pizza. Their shredded/diced pepperoni is a little salty for my tastes, next time I’ll ask for only half. The strombolis, regular and BBQ, were very good. Give them a try if you’re in the area.
… more
Alexis Mann
The pizza was amazing! So full of toppings of every part of our large pizza, absolutely worth the money! Also with us being signed up with cagneys coupons, we got a free breadstick with our order!
… more
Amanda Woods
It was Pizza King food without the trains. I would not have know it was there without Google maps.
… more
… View more