Based on 215 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
15 Main St, Goshen, NY 10924
Phone: (845) 360-5871
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sponge Bob
We ordered a pizza from Sorrento’s during the week in the afternoon, in August 2023. We were told that they were very good by our local relatives. So we ordered a pizza to go.
… more
Jacqueline Hernandez
PIZZA LOVERS MUST VISIT! I am from Brooklyn NY and pizza is EVERYTHING! My husband and I were in Goshen and had a quick pit stop here for a bite. Can I say that I am in love with their pizza! The crust was super crispy on the outside and just the right thickness with super yummy sauce and cheese (that was not oily!). I loved, loved, loved the pizza! Definitely visiting again!
… more
Sabrina Morales
Sorrento’s was absolutely delicious! We got a large pizza and garlic knots. They had friendly customer service. Very easy to talk to. I’m not a local and they made me feel very welcomed. I would definitely come back here often if I didn’t live out of state. I really loved their location as I sat outside, I got to sit in the downtown area that is beautiful and calm.
… more
Rudy Giordano
I always get takeout at the place but it never fails to produce great pizza and Italian dishes. The pizza crust is unique whether thin crust or regular. The owner is welcoming and a pleasure to deal with (Plus is name is Rudy so you can’t go wrong)
… more
Lauren Fagan
We placed a Togo order for an order of chicken fingers, fries , Mac & cheese bites and a chicken parm pizza . To start there was not even a full chicken finger amount on the entire pizza for the topping. The Mac & cheese balls were overly breaded large balls of flavorless Mac & cheese. Fries are shoestring and over cooked no flavor . The chicken fingers are I’m assuming “homemade” so thin and also no flavor . Don’t waste your money .
… more
Mike D
Im a local Goshen resident who actually gave this establishment a 5 star review 4 years ago, but unfortunately deleted it tonight! I ordered a family style 25 inch pie, which i have done many times before with no issues. Well , tonight started off with the woman who answered the phone and understood nothing i was basically saying to her. It helps if the person taking the orders actually speaks English. Then my neice picks up the pizza and walks out with 2 boxes??? So i said whats this, well this was 4 slices in each box because supposedly they didnt have the box to fit the pizza they sell, which ive have got before, available. Well im sure they didnt think when i got home i would put the (cold) $40 dollar pizza together and measure it. Well suprise suprise, 22.5 inches. Maybe 2.5 inches dosent sound big, but lets get serious, its 2.5 inch round , thats adds up! My point is this, dont think your customers are stupid, and remember there is at least 3 other pizzerias in Goshen. So i guess Goshen tomato pie will be the lucky winner of our weekly buisness! I dont give second chances for FRAUD!
… more
Jane C
Stayed at Fairfield Inn and had food delivered through the Slice app. The food is delicious and portions are perfect! I ordered the chicken francese/pasta dinner and asked for extra sauce and for the chicken and pasta to be separate. Everything came perfect! Thank you very much!
… more
J N.
I always get food delivered to my house and they are always friendly and consistent in quality. Same goes for when I go to the restaurant. My favorite place out of all the Goshen pizza options.
… more
Candice osczepinski
Best tasting Pizza around. They got it all taste,size,price,friendly. Nice quiet corner shop.
… more
Bruh Bruh
whenever I drive by, I can see the guy making pizzas from the window. there’s 10 pizzerias in a 3 mile radius, but this is 100% the best one.
… more
… View more