Fay’s Evelyn Bay Coffee Menu – Charlotte, MI

Type : Coffee shop

Location : Charlotte, MI

Based on 290 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Fay's Evelyn Bay Coffee 48813

Address:
134 S Cochran Ave, Charlotte, MI 48813

Phone: (517) 543-9770

Website:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
7 AM–7 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 7 AM–7 PM
Wednesday 7 AM–7 PM
Thursday 7 AM–7 PM
Friday 7 AM–7 PM
Saturday 8 AM–5 PM
Sunday Closed

Menu

Salads
Turkey Waldorf
romaine blend, turkey, sliced apples, dried cranberries, red onion, chopped pecans & raspberry vineagrette
Chef Salad
iceberg lettuce, ham, turkey, cheddar and swiss cheese, carrots, cucumbers, eggs, tomatoes & choice of dressing
Orange Chicken Salad
romaine blend, seasoned chicken, mandarin oranges, grapes, & poppy seed dressing
Garden Salad
romaine blend, tomatoes, red onion,
Wraps
Turkey Bacon
roasted turkey, bacon, cheddar cheese, red onion, leaf lettuce, tomato, seasoned mayo
Ham
sliced ham, cheddar cheese, red onion, lettuce, honey mustard spread
Veggie Wrap
choice of veggies, lettuce, tomato, onion, cukes, shredded carrot, and choice of dressing
Cafe Sandwiches
Turkey
roast turkey breast, cheddar cheese, lettuce, mayo, tomato
Ham
sliced ham, swiss cheese, lettuce, mayo and tomato
Chicken Salad
(pecans, craisins, celery, grapes, mayo) and lettuce
Tuna Salad
premium albacore tuna
Egg Salad
homemade
Signature Paninis
South West Chicken Panini
southwestern sauce, fajita chicken strips, cheddar cheese and red onion
Chipolte Turkey Panini
sliced turkey, chipolte sauce, cheddar cheese and red onion
Ham Panini
shaved ham, spicy brown mustard and mayo, lettuce, swiss cheese
Grilled Cheese Panini
Corned Beef Reuben
corned beef, swiss cheese, 1000 island drsg.,
Choose Two
Signature Selection
choice of two: bowl of soup, half salad, half signature panini
Cafe Selection
choice of cup of soup & half cafe sandwich
Ice Cream Flavors
Vanilla
Chocolate
Strawberry
Blueberry Pomegranate
Amaretto Truffle
Moose Tracks
Outrageous Oatmeal Cookie
Mint Chocolate Chip
Mocha Madness
Birthday Batter
Hershey’s Ice Cream Cake
delicious vanilla and chocolate ice cream with tasty chocolate crunchies add to the great flavor of hersheys ice cream. (7″ round)
Breakfast/ Muffins/ Desserts
Breakfast Sandwich
choice of ham, bacon or sausage prepared with egg and cheese. served on toast, biscuit, bagel or english muffin
Sausage Gravy & Biscuits
Assorted Muffins
Bagel
with butter or cream cheese
Cookie
daily assortment

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jessica Harmon
Locally owned coffee shop with such a comforting setting. It’s almost impossible to come in here and not feel like your mental state is put at ease. The coffee, desserts, food and ice cream are all delicious! The ice cream is from Moo-Ville which is another local company and is the best around! The coffee flight is so good and allows you to taste several different drinks. To my surprise the one I almost didn’t get was my favorite (viennese mocha). The woman that owns this coffee shop is witty and polite. I love that they also allow local companies to showcase and advertise on the walls or even by just putting their business card up.

… more

Judi Baeli
The coffee was very good. The cinnamon roll was very good after we requested that it be heated in the microwave. The inside of the coffee shop was cute.

… more

Christina P
I love Evelyn Bay! They have a nice, cozy atmosphere and the best coffee in town. My favorite order is an iced mocha.

… more

Rylee K
Just a quick pop-in for much needed coffee! When on the road with children a strong coffee that isn’t burnt helps heaps! I’m glad we drove out of our way for this coffee shop.

… more

Emily Davis
My fiancé and I go here often enough that some of the people there know us. They are all incredibly friendly and fun to talk with! We always order the breakfast croissant sandwich with sausage and let me tell you – AMAZING. We also love love love their Rosemary Potato Soup – which they always have as their standard soup, in addition to their soup of the day. We have tried so many amazing coffee creations here it’s nuts! Our favorites so far have been the Black Velvet, Chai Tea Latte and their Red Hot Mocha. 10/10 would recommend them for their food, drinks, service and chill atmosphere.

… more

Jen McCool
Coffee Flights are fun and delicious-LOTS of sugar free options which is GREAT! Big chains don’t offer as many SF options! The food is good as well!

… more

Katie S
Great locally owned Cafe with very a kind owner and great food and coffee.

… more

Evan Wright
Easy going place to stop in for coffee or a snack. Good atmosphere to hang out.

… more

Michael Miller
It’s a great place to sit and enjoy your coffee, staff are so friendly

… more

Jodabugs Jodabugs
Me and family went here we loved it it had a homie intimate atmosphere to it and the people there were really sweet I had food ice cream and coffee of all kinds I had a rest area and books you could read definitely worth it if you guys are coffeeholics like me and my family

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions