42nd Street Pizza Menu - New York, NY

No-frills joint serving a broad menu of pizza, burgers, salads, seafood & even breakfast. Based on 414 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

42nd Street Pizza 10036

Address:
647 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (212) 594-4312

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday	11 AM–8 PM
Thursday	11 AM–8 PM
Friday	11 AM–8 PM
Saturday	11 AM–8 PM
Sunday	11 AM–8 PM
Monday	11 AM–8 PM

Most Popular
Pizza Plain Pie Cheese and special sauce.	$0.00
Gyro Pizza Pie Roasted lamb gyro meat, cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Cheese Burger French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$14.95
Famous Burger Deluxe
Hamburger French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$13.95
Cheese Burger French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$14.95
Swiss Burger French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$14.95
Burger Blue French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$14.95
Pizza Burger French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$14.95
Bacon Burger French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$15.75
Bacon Cheese Burger French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$16.50
Burger Special Platter
Burger Mushrooms Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$14.95
Burger Mushrooms And Mozzarella Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$15.50
BBQ Burger And Cheese Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$15.50
Jalapeno Swiss Burger Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$15.50
Popeye Burger With Spinach Choice of cheese, french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$15.75
42nd Street Burger Platter Mushroom, bacon, cheese, french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$17.25
Grilled Chicken Breast Special Platters
Grilled Chicken With Spinach And Mozzarella Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$17.50
Grilled Chicken With Spinach Platter Mushrooms, french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$17.50
Grilled Chicken With Canadian Bacon And Cheese Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$17.50
Grilled Chicken With Mozzarella And Pizza Sauce Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$17.50
Grilled Chicken BBQ Sauce Mozzarella Cheese Platter French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$17.50
GrilledChicken 42nd Street Special MushroomsSpinachandCheese French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$19.25
Sandwich Deluxed
Breast Turkey Sandwich French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$18.50
Virginia Ham Sandwich French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$18.50
Vegan Sandwich Jalapenos, avocado, french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$18.50
Tuna Fish Salad Sandwich French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$18.50
Fresh Chicken Salad Sandwich French fries, lettuce and tomatoes.	$18.50
Meat
Rib-Eye Steak Served with french fries and green salad.	$35.50
Beef And Past Steak Thin slices fresh beef served with past.	$21.50
Pork Grilled Chops Served with french fries or green salad.	$23.50
Steak And Onions Platter Sauteed slice of beef with chopped tomatoes and onions. Brown sauce, french fries and salad.	$22.50
Meatball Parmigiana Over Rice Marinara sauce and melted mozzarella.	$20.95
Chicken Cutlets Parmigiana Over Rice Marinara sauce and melted mozzarella.	$23.50
Chicken Cutlets Spaghetti Parmigiana Marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.	$23.50
Chicken and Pasta Platter
Andreas Marinated Grilled Chicken Platter Over linguini pasta and marinara sauce.	$19.95
Pasta Bolognese Sauteed Fresh Meat Over Pasta Platter	$19.95
Chicken Sorrentino Platter Chicken cutlets sauteed, zucchini, broccoli topped with melted cheese.	$25.75
Mediterranean Chicken Platter Chicken cutlets stuffed with spinach and imported feta cheese, linguini pasta or green salad.	$26.25
Chicken Marsala Platter Sauteed boneless breast of chicken in marsala wine and mushroom and brown sauce with linguini.	$21.95
Chicken Breast Sauteed Platter Over linguini with fresh tomatoes and marinara sauce.	$21.95
Chicken Picata Platter Sauteed boneless breast of chicken in white wine with mushrooms with linguini.	$21.95
Chicken Fradiavolo Platter Sauteed boneless breast of chicken in white and hot marinara sauce over linguini.	$21.95
Chicken Breast Sauteed Platter With fresh broccoli, tomatoes, scallions and salad.	$21.95
Chicken Alfredo Platter Sauteed boneless breast of chicken in white wine, butter, eggs and cream over spaghetti.	$22.50
Linguini Primavera Platter Linguini in sauce primavera, garlic, broccoli, fresh tomatoes, zucchini and scallions.	$20.50
Homemade Meat Balls Platter With linguini pasta marinara sauce.	$19.95
Chicken Wings Platter With french fries lettuce and tomatoes.	$18.25
Chicken Fingers Platter French fries and salad.	$18.25
Linguini With Tomato Sauce Or Butter Platter	$13.50
Tasty Seafood and Pasta Combination Platters
Shrimps And Linguini Platter Fresh tomatoes, scallions and marinara sauce.	$26.50
Calamari And Spaghetti Platter Fresh tomatoes, scallions and marinara sauce.	$26.50
Shrimps, Calamari And Clams Platter Over linguini with marinara sauce.	$26.50
Clams And Linguini Platter White or red sauce.	$26.50
Shrimp And Scampi In Garlic Sauce Platter With linguini or salad.	$26.50
Salmon Steak Broiled Platter Serve with green salad or pasta.	$26.50
Shrimp Alfredo Platter Butter, egg and cream over spaghetti.	$29.50
Fresh Salad Platters
Greek Salad Platter Tomatoes, lettuce, cucumber, dolmades, feta cheese, olives and onions.	$14.25
Cob Salad Platter Grilled chicken breast, avocado, bacon, cucumbers, corn, onions and lettuce.	$19.50
Avocado Suprise Salad Platter Half avocado, a bed of lettuce, tomatoes, carrots and olives.	$16.50
Caesar Salad Platter Romaine lettuce, croutons, anchovies and grated cheese.	$14.75
Caesar Chicken Salad Platter Fresh grilled chicken, lettuce and croutons.	$18.25
42 Salad Platter Chunk chicken breast, tomatoes, bacon, peppers, cucumber, feta cheese and marinated mushrooms.	$19.50
Chef’s Salad Platter Fresh roast beef, turkey, ham and American cheese.	$19.50
Shrimp Salad Platter Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots and onions.	$19.50
Tuna Fish Salad Platter Served on a bed of lettuce, tomatoes and olives.	$16.75
Individual Fish Salad Platter Served on a top of house salad, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers and olives.	$17.25
Chicken Salad Platter Fresh chicken meat, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, onion and celery.	$16.75
Green Salad Platter Lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cucumbers.	$14.50
Athena’s Salad And Chicken Platter Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, feta cheese, olives, onions and dolmades over marinated grilled chicken.	$19.50
Grilled Chicken Primavera Salad Platter Chicken marinated in olive oil, balsamic vinegar, over romaine lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cucumber.	$18.50
Greek Food Platters
Greek Gyro Platter Pita bread, tossed Greek salad and french fries.	$22.75
Greek Veggie Platter Rice, Greek salad, pita bread and tzatziki.	$22.75
Chicken Souyland Platter Pita bread, tossed Greek salad and french fries.	$22.75
Spanakopita Platter (Spinach Pie) Homemade served with Greek salad.	$22.75
Gyro Sandwich On Pita Bread Lettuce, tomato onion and Greek sauce.	$11.50
Appetizers
Fresh Sauteed Mushrooms	$12.50
Fried Zucchini	$12.50
Garlic Bread	$8.50
French Fries	$6.75
Mozarella Sticks	$11.25
Greek Appetizers
Grilled Broccoli, Garlic And Olive Oil	$11.75
Dolmades Grape leaves stuffed with rice and lemon sauce.	$12.25
Greek Tzatziki Sauce Yogurt and pita bread.	$12.25
Feta Cheese With virgin oil and pita bread.	$12.50
Hot and Cold Heroes
Fresh Chicken Cutlets Parmigiana Hero With marinara sauce and cheese.	$15.95
Shrimps (Grilled) Hero With fresh garlic and mozzarella cheese.	$15.95
Steak And Cheese Hero With onion (fresh meat) and cheese.	$15.25
Steak And Mushrooms Hero With onions and cheese (fresh meat).	$15.25
Meatball Parmigiana Hero With marinara sauce and cheese.	$15.25
Italian Sausages Hero With marinara sauce and cheese.	$15.25
Veggan Hero Jalapenos, avocado, lettuce, tomato and onions.	$15.25
Turkey Breast Hero Lettuce, tomatoes, oil and vinegar.	$15.25
Tuna Fish Salad Hero Lettuce and tomatoes.	$15.25
Ham And American Cheese Hero Lettuce, tomatoes, oil and vinegar.	$15.25
Fresh Chicken Salad Hero Lettuce and tomatoes.	$15.25
Grilled Chicken Marinated Hero Lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise.	$15.95
Eggplant Hero With marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.	$14.90
Special Platter
Greek Gyro Platter Served with rice, pita bread and tzatziki sauce.	$21.75
Greek Gyro Platter Served with Greek salad, pita bread and tzatziki sauce.	$21.75
Greek Chicken Souvlaki Platter Served with rice, pita bread and tzatziki sauce.	$21.75
Greek Chicken Souvlaki Platter Served with Greek salad, pita bread and tzatziki sauce.	$21.75
Shrimp And Rice Platter Shrimp sauteed with fresh tomatoes, onions, fresh garlic, parsley, over rice and marinated sauce.	$29.50
Grilled Chicken Breast Marinated Over Rice Platter	$19.50
Fried Fish Fillet Flounder Platter With french fries and salad.	$19.50
Rib-Eye Steak Platter With rice and salad.	$35.00
Grilled Chicken Platter With grilled broccoli.	$21.25
Combination and Salad Sandwiches
Fried Fish Fillet Sandwich Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayonnaise or mustard.	$12.75
Ham And Cheese Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayonnaise or mustard.	$12.75
Ham And Provolone Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayonnaise or mustard.	$12.75
Turkey Deli Breast Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayonnaise or mustard.	$12.75
Tuna Salad Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayonnaise or mustard.	$12.75
Chicken Salad Fresh meat. Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayonnaise or mustard.	$12.75
Tuna Melt With Choice Of Cheese On pita bread or white bread. Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayonnaise or mustard.	$15.50
Grilled Cheese and BLT
American Cheese With Ham Or Bacon	$9.50
Provolone Cheese With Ham Or Bacon	$9.50
Swiis Cheese With Ham Or Bacon	$9.50
BLT (Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato)	$13.95
Breakfast
Greek White Omelette Spinach, onion, feta cheese, home fries and toast.	$16.50
Greek Giro And Eggs Slice of tomatoes, toast, coffee and orange juice.	$17.50
2 Fried Eggs Served with home fries, toast, orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$12.50
2 Scrambled Eggs Served with home fries, toast, orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$13.50
2 Eggs Fried Or Scrambled With Ham, Sausage Or Bacon Served with home fries, toast, orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$15.95
3 Golden Brown Pancakes Served with butter and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$13.50
3 Pancakes And 2 Eggs Combination Served with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$14.75
3 French Toast Served with butte and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$13.50
3 French Toast With Ham, Sausage Or Bacon Served with butte and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$16.25
3 French Toast And 2 Eggs Combination Served with butte and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$16.25
Breakfast
Greek White Omelette Spinach, onion, feta cheese, home fries and toast.	$18.50
Greek Giro And Eggs Slice of tomatoes, toast, coffee and orange juice.	$19.50
2 Fried Eggs Served with home fries, toast, orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$14.50
2 Scrambled Eggs Served with home fries, toast, orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$15.50
2 Eggs Fried Or Scrambled With Ham, Sausage Or Bacon Served with home fries, toast, orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$17.95
3 Golden Brown Pancakes Served with butter and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$15.50
3 Pancakes And 2 Eggs Combination Served with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$16.75
3 French Toast Served with butte and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$15.50
3 French Toast With Ham, Sausage Or Bacon Served with butte and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$18.25
3 French Toast And 2 Eggs Combination Served with butte and syrup with orange juice, coffee or tea or hot chocolate.	$18.25
Three (3) Eggs Omelette
Vegetarian Omelette Tomatoes, onions, peppers and mushrooms. Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$15.95
Santiago Omelette Onions, ham, peppers and tomatoes. Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.50
Grecian Omelette Feta cheese and fresh topped tomatoes. Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.50
Ham And Cheese Omelette Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.50
Spinach Omelette With Mushrooms And Cheese Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.50
Western Omelette Ham, peppers and onions. Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$17.50
Italian Omelette Italian sausages, peppers and onions. Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.50
Bacon And Cheese Omelette Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.50
Egg Whites Omelette Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.50
Spicy Omelette Jalapenos, tomatoes, red crush, peppers and onions. Served with home fires, orange juice, tea or coffee or hot chocolate.	$16.95
Side Order
Bacon	$6.50
Sausages	$6.50
Ham	$6.50
Egg Sandwiches (On Roll)
2 Eggs Fried Sandwich	$5.75
2 Eggs Plus Ham Or Bacon Sausages Sandwich	$6.95
Coffee
Coffee To Go	$2.50
Hot Tea	$3.00
Cafe Latte	$6.25
Cappuccino	$6.25
Espresso	$3.95
Hot Chocolate	$3.50
Milk	$5.50
Chocolate Milk	$5.75
Natural Fruit Shakes
Mango Shake With orange juice or milk.	$50.00
Strawberry Shake With orange juice or milk.	$50.00
Cold Beverages
Milk Shakes	$7.25
Nescafe Frappe	$5.25
Orange Juice	$5.50
Coca Cola	$2.50
Diet Cola	$2.50
Coke	$2.50
Sprite	$2.50
Snapple	$3.25
Gatorade	$3.25
Natural Spring Water	$2.25
Ice Cream and Desserts
Ice Cream 2 scoops.	$7.25
Greek Baklava	$7.60
Vanilla Cheese Cake	$7.25
Carrot Cake	$7.25
Pizza Pies
Pizza Plain Pie Cheese and special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Extra Mozzarella Cheese Pie Special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Sausages Pie Cheese and special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Pepperoni Pie Cheese and special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Mushroom Pie Special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Ham Pie Cheese and special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Homemade Meatballs Pie Special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Anchovies Pie Cheese and special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Onions Pie Cheese and special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza Black Olives Pie Special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza BBQ Chicken Pie Sauteed chunk of chicken in BBQ sauce.	$0.00
Combination Pizza Pies
Greek Pizza Pie Spinach, feta cheese and onions.	$0.00
Supreme Chicken Pizza Pie Cheese, sauce and marinated white chicken meat.	$0.00
Hawaiian Deluxe Pizza Pie Cheese, sauce, pineapple and ham.	$0.00
Vegetarian Pizza Pie Mushroom, onions, peppers, cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Primavera Pizza Pie Zucchini, broccoli and chopped fresh tomatoes.	$0.00
Combination Pizza Pie Cheese, sauce, sausage, pepperoni and mushroom.	$0.00
Spinach And Chopped Fresh Tomatoes Pizza Pie Cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Lasagna Pizza Pie Mozzarella and sauce (feta and meat sauce).	$0.00
Meat Lovers Pizza Pie Cheese, sauce, meatballs, sausage, ham and pepperoni.	$0.00
Narek Hamburger And Onion Pizza Pie Cheese, sauce, beef hamburger meat and onions.	$0.00
Pancho Villa Hot Pizza Pie Jalapenos and tabasco hot sauce, cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Shrimp Pizza Pie Cheese, sauce and grilled shrimp with garlic and cilantro.	$0.00
Paisano Pizza Pie Jalapenos, onions, cilantro, cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Eggplant Pizza Pie Breaded eggplant, cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Pie Grilled chicken in spice sauce, cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Gyro Pizza Pie Roasted lamb gyro meat, cheese and sauce.	$0.00
Vegan Pizza Pie (No cheese) sauce, tomatoes, onions and spinach.	$0.00
Andreas Pizza Pie Green peppers, onions, black slices olives and cheese special sauce.	$0.00
Pizza by the Slice
Plain Pizza Slice	$4.00
Extra Cheese Pizza Slice	$4.80
Onion Pizza Slice	$4.75
Pepperoni Pizza Slice	$4.90
Mushroom Pizza Slice	$4.90
Hawaiian Pizza Slice	$5.90
Sausage Pizza Slice	$4.90
Anchovies Pizza Slice	$4.90
Ham Pizza Slice	$4.90
Vegetarian Pizza Slice	$6.00
Combination Pizza Slice	$5.75
Meatball Pizza Slice	$6.00
Black Olives Pizza Slice	$5.90
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice	$6.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Blaze Nickles 45 Go Pop

I told my girlfriend before we walked in it was a bad idea … The minute you walk in it smells like aspestos… The food was horrible! You look at the pizza and can clearly see it was old. Second some of it looks heated over atleast 4 times..The fish sandwich was terrible it smelled like the sea, and had non melted imitation cheese and was dry like the desert. My chicken parmesan was watered down in sauce, chicken had a weird taste and soon after I had an upset stomach. As we ate one worker stood by and was watching us eat! The other worker stood by the door holding a menu hoping for a costumer to walk in. The bathroom was asbestos smelling as well and ugly looking. A few customers came in but 4/5 walked out and when they came in the workers ran to them hoping for a customer. I would never go there again, it may just be the worst diner- restaurant I ever went in. Stay away from that place it wasnt good at all! It was horrible

… more

liz s

Staff was nice.. Pizza is excellent slice are huge.. I got a Greek salad to ..good size.. I’ll have leftover for later.. yummy.. the building is cute and Quint..

… more

Melvin Coleman

Very nice people. Food is straightforward. Grabbed a couple slices as we walked and explored. Impressed at how long the family has owned the space, since the 60’s! I hope they continue strong!

… more

Biagio Gulino

Just had a slice of pizza as you would imagine it was great the drover’s Christy and the sauce and cheese was excellent

… more

T T

This might have been my top 3 bad experience! The „Gyros“ was far from a real Gyros. And I can tell because I‘m Greek and I go to Greece EVERY year and eat out. Every random Greek grill is 10 times better than this.

… more

Esther Garcia

This restaurant was far more than I expected. The food was amazing. I ate a gyro on pita bread. Never tasted one so delicious as this one. The service is great. I am so glad we found it.

… more

Ben El-Gamal

The pizza was good, but they overcharged us by $8. 2 slices of pizza, a coke and milkshake cost us $25 when it should have been $17. No amount of sales tax or tip should cover that. AVOID AT ALL COSTS

… more

Liz Correa

First place after getting off ferry I should have waited as I walked down 42st so many more places to try out I

… more

Valanta Taveirne

A lucky find after our boat ride on the Hudson and seeing Statue of Liberty. Greek restaurant for nyc pizza….you betchya. It was delicious as was the cheesecake. And family owned and operated made it even better

… more

Ricardo Jorge Ferreira

Fair food but a little expensive for what you get.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

42nd Street Pizza Menu – New York, NY

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions