Holy Cow Menu – Marcellus, NY

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Marcellus, NY

Based on 56 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Holy Cow 13108

Address:
3 North St, Marcellus, NY 13108

Phone: (315) 494-1022

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–7 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–7 PM
Thursday 11 AM–7 PM
Friday 11 AM–8 PM
Saturday 11 AM–8 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed

Menu

Specialty Sandwiches
Classic Philly
Steak or chicken, choice of cheese, on an Amoroso roll.
Philly Hots
Steak or chicken, choice of cheese, raw onion, hot cherry peppers, on an Amoroso roll.
Utica Green
Steak or chicken, choice of cheese, topped with homemade Utica Greens, on an Amoroso roll.
Meat And Potato
Steak or chicken, choice of cheese, fried potatoes, on an Amoroso roll.
Blackened
Steak or chicken, crumbly bleu cheese, blackening seasoning, on an Amoroso roll.
Holy Smoke
Steak or chicken, choice of cheese, hot cherry peppers, banana peppers, jalapeños, on an Amoroso roll.
The Hoagie
Steak or chicken, choice of cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomato, pickle, on an Amoroso roll.
Stacker
Steak and chicken, choice of cheese, mayo, lettuce, tomato, pickle, on an Amoroso roll.
Holy Cow!
Steak or chicken, choice of cheese, mushroom, pepper, onion, on an Amoroso roll.
Chicken Buffalo
Chicken, wing sauce, crumbly bleu cheese, on an Amoroso roll.
Classic BLT
Chicken, choice of cheese, mayo, bacon, lettuce, tomato, on an Amoroso roll.
Half Sandwich
Any half specialty sandwich. Does not come with a side after 2 PM.
Lunch Special *11-2 DAILY
Any half sandwich served with fries. Option to substitute side (upcharge). Add a fountain drink for $1.
Toppings and Cheeses
Toppings
Priced per topping. Sautéed onion, raw onion, mushrooms, peppers, jalapeños, banana peppers, cherry peppers, fried potatoes, lettuce, tomato, pickles, mayo, steak sauce (served on side).
Cheeses / Bacon
Charged per cheese. American, Bleu Cheese, Cheddar, Cheese Wiz, Mozzarella, Provolone. Bacon $1.
Extra Meat
Extra steak, chicken, or Utica Greens.
Kid’s Menu
Grilled Cheese
American cheese, buttered bread. Served with fries.
Chicken Tenders
Restaurant style tenders, served with fries. Sauce choices: BBQ, Honey Mustard, Ranch.
Hot Dog
Hoffman hot dog served with French fries.
Haddock *FRIDAY ONLY*
Haddock Dinner
Fried haddock, French fries, tartar, coleslaw, lemon. Option to substitute a different side (up charge).
Haddock Sandwich
Served with lemon and tartar on an Amoroso roll.
Haddock Sandwich Dinner
Served with French fries, coleslaw, lemon and tartar. Option to substitute a different side (upcharge).
Sides
French Fries
Tater Tots
Onion Rings
Mac Salad
Creamy macaroni salad with celery, carrot, and onion.
Coleslaw
Sweet and tangy dressing.
Utica Greens
Braised escarole, with garlic, cured ham, and cherry peppers. Finished with Parmesan and breadcrumbs. Option to add cherry peppers (upcharge).
Other
Quesadilla
Cheddar filled quesadilla. Served with salsa and sour cream. Option to add steak or chicken for an upcharge. Option to add toppings for an upcharge.
Beverages
Fountain Beverages
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Lemonade, Dr. Pepper, Unsweetened Iced Tea. Free refills for dine-in.
Bottled Beverages
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Starry, Mug Rootbeer, Raspberry Iced Tea, Unsweetened Iced Tea.

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jeff Bachstein
One of the best steak sandwiches I have ever had. Great and friendly service. Fast service. Reasonably priced.

… more

Victor Shakhov
Astonishing first impression. I’m not a fan of Philly cheese steaks and neither is my reviewing colleague, so when I say the classic Philly cheese steak is unimaginable, it really says something. The softness in the bun is other-worldly, the warm and tender meat and gooey cheese was delicious. Truly a masterpiece for the very minimal wait. The only reason the food didn’t get 5 stars is because there was an uninvited pickle which jumpscared my unexpecting colleague. Also there was a very tough part of steak in the sandwich, although it wasn’t terrible as this was only a small part of the steak. All in all, I was very satisfied with my food. I will be coming here again without a doubt.

… more

Amanda S
Everything we had was delicious! Love that they offer chicken in addition to steak so there are choices that work for our whole family. We called in our ordered ahead and were told it would be ready in 10 minutes. Their estimate was perfect, food was just getting wrapped up when we arrived which means it was still super hot and fresh when we got home. Staff was very friendly too. The only thing I’ll do differently is order a half a sandwich next time instead of a whole, because they are MASSIVE.

… more

Lisa Twombly
This was probably our 4th or 5th experience here and all have been great! We came here when they first opened and completely understood the wait times back then as they were just starting out at this location and they had an overwhelming response! Overwhelming is actually an understatement! Food we’ve gotten has always been great and tonight was no exception. Got the haddock sandwich dinner expecting a small sandwich and fries and what I got was a fish fry on a hoagie roll! Wow! Anyway, very glad to support this awesome eatery in our small town. Happy we have them here!

… more

Brett Chilcoat
Honestly was a little disappointed with my classic cheesesteak. It was pretty big, and overall not bad, just felt like it should not have been so dry. Needed more cheese in my opinion anyway. Look forward to going back and trying a different sandwich though, they all sound so good.

… more

Mark Moriarty
Solid food, reasonable price, friendly staff, clean.

… more

Makenzie McEathron
We got the cow but not the holy… We asked for onions , peppers , mushrooms and cheddar with mayo on our roll. We literally received steak and cheddar on a very tasty roll. The quality of the meat was great, and the roll was awesome!! But the sub was tasteless . We were so excited for this to be our go to here in our village !

… more

Christine Austin
Live near by and I can tell you from the smells alone, the food is much higher quality than anything previously offered in that location. The owner is pleasant, smart and this isn’t his first rodeo. It will take time for any business to settle in and I for one, am happy to see someone who knows what they’re doing, bringing Marcellus some really good food!

… more

John Duckett
We just picked up lunch to go for the first time and the experience was great. The food and service were excellent and the order was ready right when I arrived. Not sure why someone would give the place 1 star for not serving breakfast when they don’t open til 11am and clearly don’t have breakfast as part of the menu. Also, they just opened and time and understandIng should be given to work everything out. As far as the prices, they are reasonable considering the portion size. We will definitely be regular customers!

… more

Sean Donnelly
Wanted to try out this new place. Stopped in on my lunch break around 1:30pm to grab a simple lunch special. Easy you would think, There was about three other people in line including me. The lady at the register is training and is either hard hearing or doesn’t understand English well she wasn’t understanding the other customers request for there sandwich and had to repeat several times and also had to repeat my simple order of a lunch special after repeating my request a few times I was cashed out service was fast indeed I did not think to check and make sure it was right with only a few people ordering but the sandwich I got was not the one I ordered. Unfortunately I wasn’t able to turn around and wait any longer to be fixed. So I called and asked for a manager and told them, My order was made wrong they simply said okay and that was it hung up on me this was my first time there and I will must likely not be returning due to the service they provided I was not pleased this could have been handled in a more professional manner and was not best of luck if that is how you treat your customers

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions