Based on 49 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
247 Genesee St, Auburn, NY 13021
Phone: (315) 253-5371
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 3:30–8 PM |
| Friday | 3:30–8 PM |
| Saturday | 3:30–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Reviews
R M
Best pizza in NewYork!!. The burnt cheesy crust meat loves pizza is AAA+++++
… more
Blue SouthPaw
Best pizza in Auburn! Very hearty pizza. More like gourmet!!! Worth every penny worth the wait! I used to have a favorite pizza that I thought was the best, but now after experiencing this pizza, I’ve changed my mind. I also never in my life have eaten the crust on any pizza. But this pizza I gladly eat the crust as it is delicious!!! If you’re looking for a gourmet style pizza with very fresh ingredients bursting with flavor, give this pizza a try!!!
… more
Jeremy Smelski
This pizza is unique and amazing. The crust is like no other you’ll find anywhere in Auburn. And the crust is literally the best part of the pizza. Be ready to wait, these pizzas take 45 minutes in the oven, that’s what it takes to get the amazing crust and boy is it worth the wait. If you haven’t tried this pizza, do it! It also isn’t cheap, but remember it takes 45 minutes just to cook. As the sayings go. “Good food isn’t cheap and cheap food isn’t good!” -and- “Good food isn’t fast and fast food isn’t good!” Enjoy this rare delicious delicacy of a pizza and be thankful you can get something so unique and flavorful right here in Auburn New York.
… more
Diana Stevens
First ever trying a new place for pizza near me. Was excellent! They have all the toppings I like. The pizza had a burnt crust on the edges, but not on the bottom, was excellent
… more
trish watkins
If there is a heaven I hope it smells like Papa Paulies!!!
… more
Eddie
Ok to start we ordered a pizza and were told 1 hour….after an hour and a half we tried to call but they turn the phones off apparently when it gets busy. When I picked up the phone again to order a pizza from Angelos a car stopped in front of my house. 1 hour and 40 minutes my pizza arrives. It was a poor pizza at best. The crust was the only redeeming quality. The bought the recipes but this did not equal the old man. I will not be ordering again from Papa Paulie’s.
… more
Denise Dixon
If you like a thick crust pizza ,delicious taste ,perfect pizza Papa Paulies is the place to go
… more
Doug Warter
Its totally worth the wait! Lot’s of love goes into those pizzas 90min wait for delivery but Oooo..so delish!
… more
Ben T
Amazing Pizza!! I will dial and call 100 times if I have to get a pizza from Papa Paulies!!! Great crust hot or cold!
… more
Richard Honchar
Great service, excellent pizza. Friendly people.
… more
… View more