Classic bakery with an attached traditional Italian restaurant for homestyle pastas & meat entrees. Based on 509 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4864 Arthur Kill Rd, Staten Island, NY 10307
Phone: (718) 227-0002
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Jesse Maldonado
Meatball pie was delicious and service was great. Portions were big. The venue is comfortable and spacious… seems like a great place to hold an event. Would definitely head back to this spot.
… more
Joel Agron
We had our son’s wedding rehersal dinner in December 2022. Our party planner Tara was FABULOUS! The dinner party was flawless! So grateful for her hard work. Our guest were delighted. The next day (wedding) the party, complimented the rehersal dinner, yet again. THAT, is what made it even better! Thank you Tara, no amount of words can come close to your diligence!! Agron Family
… more
Steve Calandrino
Went for my sons graduation June 26th 2023 .and if haven’t been here you need to stop in great Italian food own bakery on premises the owner is a a great stand up guy ..the staff amazing and the atmosphere amazing .went with a party of 6 and everyone was wowed .
… more
ayikahS H
I ordered a large chicken and tortellini soup and a loaf of bread. The bread was delicious but the soup was bland. I had to add my trusty Goya Salad and Vegetable Seasoning to jazz it up. It was also a bit greasy and even though I asked for utensils none were given. I wouldn’t buy anything other than a loaf of bread from this place again. Not to mention it’s expensive.
… more
Gary Carpentier
My son and I saw Aunt Butchies on TikTok and stopped by on our way home to Washington, DC. We had a wonderful meal this afternoon. The service was attentive and seamless. Alex had the Sunday Sauce pasta. The meatballs and sausage were delicious as was my eggplant parmigiana. The portions are enormous. Great value!!! We finished with cannolis. Heavenly!! Our gracious host Tara made the meal complete. We unconditionally recommend Aunt Butchies of Brooklyn.
… more
Tom Lucek
This was my second time at this location due to family living on Staten Island. Parking isn’t the best but we got lucky cause we went for lunch. Went with family of 18 and service was spot on. We had two waiters and they were on top of everything from moment we sat down until we left. The chicken parm and chicken marsala were very good. The beef lacked flavor and wasn’t that tender. Both the vodka penne and marina had good flavor. There brick oven pizza is very good. Family style it’s definitely place to go for good food and great service.
… more
Salvatore Brancato
Food was delicious and the restaurant was beautifully designed. The place was busy so that’s a good indicator. This is our first time eating at Aunt Butchies in Staten Island. We usually go to the NJ location. A. Butchies serves authentic Italian cuisine. I highly recommend it.
… more
MariMechi Yrizarry
As always great. However, I think they put too much sauce on the food. Still, we soak it w bread! They serve delicious Italian food. Service is amazing, absolutely great and atmosphere is wonderfully I never get tired of their food!
… more
Christina Avenoso Martucci
Staff is great, excellent service. Food (and sangria) is delicious. Especially loved the salad with strawberries and goat cheese, rigatoni Aunt Butchies, and the vanilla & chocolate tartufo.
… more
Valeriya Osipova
I’ve been here for a weekend brunch. The food was great with generous portions and huge menu selection for every picky eater. The service was good, I felt welcome. It was a bit chilly as our table was by the window and we came on a cold day. There is an extra charge if you pay with the card, as a suggestion, bring cash. Other than that, it is a great family restaurant, I will be coming back.
… more
… View more