New York-style slice joint & bar set in old-fashioned surrounds with late-night hours. Based on 776 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4350 Leary Wy NW, Seattle, WA 98107
Phone: (206) 466-2595
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 12 PM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Monday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 12 PM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
DaysInBlue
This is my first time ordering from here and I just got a plain cheese pizza. Sauce is very spicy for red sauce. Not bad, but if you don’t do well with heat you’re in trouble. Cheese mixture was good, but the crust was very dry and more like a cracker than thin crust pizza. Was fine for what it was but kinda bizarre. Not sure I’d order from here again unless it’s super late and nothing else is open.
… more
Bill P
Great spot to grab a quick slice for a hot Wednesday break. Decent pricing, fabulous quality and great customer service. Free local parking was a real blessing too!!
… more
JKNNKJ Butterfly
I’m originally from NYC and this is not NY pizza. The slices appear huge because the dough is spread very thin. I wish someone who owned a popular, old school pizza shop from NY would actually live here and open a pizza shop in the Seattle proper area Here’s to praying for my dream pizza shop. Good try “Big Mario”.
… more
Eric Hyman
We gave it a four star rating for after drinks, maybe a three before, but generally we loved it, great thin crust, foldable New York style pizza by the slice or a pie! What the hell give it a four-star all around! And open late, a huge plus! Even after breweries in the area, were closing. Forgot to mention, the pizza was great!
… more
Vanno Kouch
The place is amazing. Great atmosphere. It gives off a small town warm and welcoming vibe from the early 2000s. There are tons of cassette tapes, which brings in a lot of nostalgia. The pies were great. Nice and brown on the bottom, but also maluable enough to fold like a tradional NY style za. Flavor was great, especially the cheese, but the pepperoni can be but salty, so I’d recommend if you were to order it to ask to be light on it. Id give this place a solid 85 tomatoes out of 100.
… more
J 2000
Awesome pizza but the service is horrible. Went there and had to walk up to the workers to try to get service. And it was obvious we were inconveniencing them and interrupted their conversation. The pizzas that big Mario’s make are awesome I would highly suggest going to their other locations that have better service.
… more
Saishruti Mutneja
Don’t make the mistake of ordering a full pizza. Customer service is terrible. Full pizzas are made at the end- so if 20 customers walk in AFTER you that want slices, they’re going to make, bake and sell all those slices before they even start making your pizza. Waited almost an hour for our pizza. Rude servers. Such a waste.
… more
Sam Martinez
I would give this place a 0 if I could. We have a practice space right down the way, they never have slices at all. Always some random mix of pizza and last time they had fresh pizza we were told “it wasn’t for us”. So never will step foot in here again until they either get rid of the staff that are terrible to customers or actually have consistent food.
… more
Chris H
Great pizza, great music, friendly staff. The pizza is big!
… more
miniqooper
Yummy-I like it. Great retro feel in side with tight quarters. Talk about elbow room. Has a college and NY city atmosphere. Love the VHS on the shelves throughout the place. Wonder if they rent them out. Just got two slices this time. Good crunch to the crust, NY style thin slices . They also have the square pan thick kind. The sauce is surprisingly spicy and thin with a balance of cheese spread out. You can fold the pie to fit your mouth but the scoop and bite will work.
… more
… View more