Abby’s Pie Shack Menu – Cloudcroft, NM

Type : Pizza Takeout

Location : Cloudcroft, NM

Based on 24 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price

Abby's Pie Shack 88317

Address:
96 James Canyon Hwy, Cloudcroft, NM 88317

Phone: (575) 682-7492

Website: https://www.facebook.com/abbyspieshack

Menu

Pizzas
7″ Cheese – Thin Crust
Cheese on 7″ thin crust		 $5.00
7″ Cheese – Hand Tossed Crust
Cheese on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $6.00
12″ Cheese – Thin Crust
Cheese on 12″ thin crust		 $10.00
12″ Cheese – Hand Tossed Crust
Cheese on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $12.00
7″ Deluxe – Thin Crust
Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, mushroom, onion, extra cheese on 7″ thin crust		 $8.00
7″ Deluxe – Hand Tossed Crust
Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, mushroom, onion, extra cheese on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $9.00
12″ Deluxe – Thin Crust
Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, mushroom, onion, extra cheese on 12″ thin crust		 $16.00
12″ Deluxe – Hand Tossed Crust
Pepperoni, sausage, bell pepper, mushroom, onion, extra cheese on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $18.00
7″ Meat Lovers – Thin Crust
Pepperoni, beef, ham, Italian sausage, extra cheese on 7″ thin crust		 $8.00
7″ Meat Lovers – Hand Tossed Crust
`Pepperoni, beef, ham, Italian sausage, extra cheese on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $9.00
12″ Meat Lovers – Thin Crust
`Pepperoni, beef, ham, Italian sausage, extra cheese on 12″ thin crust		 $16.00
12″ Meat Lovers – Hand Tossed Crust
`Pepperoni, beef, ham, Italian sausage, extra cheese on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $18.00
7″ Supreme – Hand Tossed Crust
Pepperoni, beef, ham, sausage, bell pepper, mushrooms, olives, onion, extra cheese on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $9.00
7″ Supreme – Thin Crust
Pepperoni, beef, ham, sausage, bell pepper, mushrooms, olives, onion, extra cheese on 7″ thin crust		 $8.00
12″ Supreme – Thin Crust
Pepperoni, beef, ham, sausage, bell pepper, mushrooms, olives, onion, extra cheese on 12″ thin crust		 $16.00
12″ Supreme – Hand Tossed Crust
Pepperoni, beef, ham, sausage, bell pepper, mushrooms, olives, onion, extra cheese on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $18.00
7″ Veggie Supreme – Thin Crust
Bell Pepper, mushrooms, onion, olives, diced tomatoes, extra cheese on 7″ thin crust		 $8.00
7″ Veggie Supreme – Hand Tossed Crust
Bell Pepper, mushrooms, onion, olives, diced tomatoes, extra cheese on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $9.00
12″ Veggie Supreme – Thin Crust
Bell Pepper, mushrooms, onion, olives, diced tomatoes, extra cheese on 12″ thin crust		 $16.00
12″ Veggie Supreme – Hand Tossed Crust
Bell Pepper, mushrooms, onion, olives, tomatoes, extra cheese on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $18.00
7″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 1 Topping
Choice of 1 topping on 7″ thin crust		 $5.50
7″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed Crust – 1 Topping
Choice of 1 topping on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $6.50
12″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 1 Topping
Choice of 1 topping on 12″ thin crust		 $12.00
12″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed – 1 Topping
Choice of 1 topping on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $14.00
7″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 2 Toppings
Choice of 2 toppings on 7″ thin crust		 $6.00
7″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed Crust – 2 Toppings
Choice of 2 toppings on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $7.00
12″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 2 Toppings
Choice of 2 toppings on 12″ thin crust		 $13.00
12″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed – 2 Toppings
Choice of 2 toppings on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $15.00
7″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 3 Toppings
Choice of 3 toppings on 7″ thin crust		 $6.50
7″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed Crust – 3 Toppings
Choice of 3 toppings on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $7.50
12″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 3 Toppings
Choice of 3 toppings on 12″ thin crust		 $14.00
12″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed Crust – 3 Toppings
Choice of 3 toppings on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $16.00
7″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 4 Toppings
Choice of 4 toppings on 7″ thin crust		 $7.00
7″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed – 4 Toppings
Choice of 2 toppings on 7″ hand tossed crust		 $8.00
12″ Make Your Own – Thin Crust – 4 Toppings
Choice of 4 toppings on 12″ thin crust		 $15.00
12″ Make Your Own – Hand Tossed – 4 Toppings
Choice of 4 toppings on 12″ hand tossed crust		 $17.00
Drinks
Canned Soda – 12 fl oz
Coke, Diet Coke, Dr Pepper, Orange Crush, Pepsi, Rootbeer, Sprite		 $2.00
Bottled Water
16.9 fl oz		 $1.00
Appetizers
Cheese Crisps
Large flour tortilla baked with mozzarella to crispy perfection.		 $6.00
Cheese Crisps – With Green Chili or Jalapenos
Large flour tortilla baked with mozzarella – add green chili or jalapenos		 $7.00
7″ Cheese Stix
Hand tossed crust with garlic butter and mozzarella, served with marinara dip – 7″		 $6.00
12″ Cheese Stix
Hand tossed crust with garlic butter and mozzarella, served with marinara dip – 12″		 $10.00
Toppings – Meat
Bacon
Beef
Ham
Pepperoni
Italian Sausage
Sausage
Toppings – Veggies
Bell Peppers
Green Chili
Jalapenos
Mushrooms
Olives
Onions
Pineapple
Diced Tomatoes
Desserts
Pistachio Bread – Slice
Slice of homemade pistachio bread		 $4.00
Key Lime Pie – Slice
A slice of homemade keylime pie served with a lime slice		 $4.00
Hot Dog Meal
Nathan’s Beef Dog
Beef dog on a bun with chips, choice of condiments and a drink		 $7.00
Condiments
Ketchup, mustard, mayo
Relish Cup $0.50
Hot Dog – No Meal
Nathan’s Beef Dog on a bun with choice of condiments		 $3.00
Pizza Deals
Personal Pizza & Drink
One 7″ Pizza on thin crust with 2 toppings and a drink		 $7.00
Two Large for $20
Two 12″ pizzas on thin crust with 1 topping each		 $20.00
Two Large for $22
Two 12″ pizzas on thin crust with 2 toppings each		 $22.00
Dipping Cups
Garlic Butter $0.50
Marinara $0.50
Ranch $0.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Freen Ternet
Best pizza i’ve ever tasted. Quick and fast service. Very clean place and curtious staff

… more

blind cross
The staff is excellent. Time courteous and the customer service is beyond what you would expect. If you ever get a chance to stop by I would highly suggest it. The pizza blows the area of way. What an excellent time I had there good fun good food with good people you can’t beat that.

… more

Yvonne Rangel
Pizza was good and very filling

… more

Baldo Velasquez
I’ve had pizza all over and this little place in the heart of Cloudcroft has to be in my top 3 best pizza joints. The thin crust meat lovers, pepperoni, and deluxe were all very consistent. They had the perfect proportions from the dough to the crust and toppings as well. The customer service was 5 star! I will definitely be returning to Cloudcroft and probably just to come to this pizza joint! If you are passing through or in town definitely come to Abby’s Pie shack! Oh, I almost forgot the dessert! The pistachio bread was AMAZING! It is the perfect moistness and sweetness! Took 2 pieces to go! Abby’s Pie Shack is definitely worth the stop!

… more

Lynn Kimball
Favorite place for pizza in CC. Just sooo good. And service is amazing. Great folks to hang out with and play corn hole.

… more

Joshua watkins
Really good food and great service. Nice outdoors seating. A significantly better alternative to the overcrowded BBQ spots in cloudcroft

… more

D Rey
Great pizza, service and prices.

… more

Joseph Merrell
Amazing. Awesome staff with quick timing. and the hand tossed pizza is to die for. best in Cloudcroft.

… more

Flip Masters “Flip Masters” Productions
Delicious food and A+ atmosphere..

… more

William Shuttles
For ten dollars you can get the best sub chips desert and drink totally awesome!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch