Based on 253 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
Bizzarro pasta and New York pizza, 1560 Soco Rd, Maggie Valley, NC 28751
Phone: (828) 944-0007
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 1–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Fireman5077
Stopped in this Pizza Shop in Maggie Valley this weekend. Just the wife and I, so we ordered a Medium (16″) Bizzarro pizza which is basically a Supreme.
… more
Dave “Oink” Mason
You wouldn’t expect a classic Italian restaurant in a small town, but here you go!
… more
Todd Wyatt
I am from out of town and thought I would try them because of the great reviews that I saw of the place. I was very disappointed to say the least. The pizza sauce tastes like tomato soup, the crust is like if you bought a frozen pizza from the grocery store, there is no way that their crust is made fresh, no way! The over priced salad that I ordered was very tiny & not worth the price and the service was very dismal as well. They had my pizza ready & given to me and then I had to wait another 5 minutes to get my salad while my pizza got cold. If I go back to Maggie Valley, I will bring a pizza from some other place before I get here. I truly believe the great reviews that you see are just locals who may not have too many other pizza options.
… more
Leonora Reiley
We have tried many of the pizza places in Waynesville and Maggie, and have been mostly underwhemed. We had been looking forward to coming here and were not disappointed. Negotiating on what kind to get is always hard, but we opted for the marinara and mozzarella and added pepperoni. The crust was just right and the toppings had that great fresh taste. We also had a house salad that was fresh and packed with olives and tomatoes. Also each had a glass of chianti. I was happy to see that they have outdoor seating since we might pop in with our dogs. Service was fast and friendly. When we go back, there will be no compromising; I’ll get my own Bizarro special, and my husband can get his own whatever.
… more
Jacqueline Nunes
You know it’s good when you come twice in a week on vacation. Pizzas fresh, just the right amount of sauce, all the right condiments to go on it!! Take it from a Yankee that this is the real deal and best pizza I’ve had in a long time!! Our server Whitney was AWESOME!!
… more
Matthew M. (EvasiveVlogger)
I will drive from states away for this guys pizza!, I’m a bit picky when it comes to the crust and how it’s cooked but whoever the cook is he needs a raise!, I’ve never had such an amazing white pizza the crust was perfect and the cheese and oil were the perfect amount. Give this place a try!.
… more
Lacy Whitten
I usually don’t leave reviews but this experience was particularly awful. We were a party of 2 and arrived at 5:30. Our server was overwhelmed due to staff shortage and my partner and I were completely understanding because we have worked in restaurants and the public and are generally very understanding. However, our server initially took our order, forgot what we ordered and came back and very frustrated shouted “what did you have?” We waited until 6:45 for food. Tables who arrived way after us received their food way before we did.Our food came out wrong. I didn’t receive my salad or garlic bread that was supposed to come with my meal. She didn’t charge us for the incorrect order and brought the pasta I originally ordered and it was not great. While we were trying to get our servers attention the kitchen rang the bell for an order up and she screamed in the middle of the dining room “I’M COMING” and it took us t
… more
Jennifer Hollar
3.5 stars. We ordered a BBQ chicken pizza and garlic cheese bread for carryout. The pizza needed more BBQ sauce to be honest. Some bites you couldn’t even taste it. The toppings were a bit scarce as well (see pic, most toppings concentrated in the middle of the pizza). The medium was enough for 4 people to have 2 pieces each. The garlic cheese bread was excellent. The meal wasn’t bad, but it didn’t live up to the hype.
… more
Austyn Cross
If you’re thinking about going there, do it!! Had dinner there yesterday with some friends and family for my birthday. None of us had ever tried it before but we saw it had really good reviews. It felt very cozy and welcoming. Not only was the waitress super kind, but the food was amazing! The butter was the best butter I have ever had. And the dessert was soooo good. I’m really picky about tiramisu but it was to die for. I will DEFINITELY be back the next time I’m up that way!! 🙂
… more
Shelly Reynolds
My husband and I were in Maggie Valley for vacation from Kentucky and to celebrate me finally being cancer free. We tried your restaurant for the first time, and will definitely be back when we are back in town in a few months. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs, and my husband had a stromboli. The food was spectacular and the portions are huge. I would recommend your restaurant to everyone.
… more
… View more