Sheboygan Pasty Company Menu – Sheboygan, WI

Type : Restaurant

Location : Sheboygan, WI

Based on 59 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Sheboygan Pasty Company 53081

Address:
811 A Indiana Ave, Sheboygan, WI 53081

Phone: (920) 395-2132

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Thursday 11 AM–7 PM
Friday 11 AM–7 PM
Saturday 11 AM–7 PM
Sunday 11 AM–6 PM
Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11 AM–7 PM

Menu

Hot & Ready Pasties
Breakfast Pasty $8.28
Sheboygan Pasty $7.76
Traditional Pasty $7.24
Veggie Pasty $6.73
Italian Pasty $7.76
Gluten Free Italian Pasty $10.87
Gluten Free Traditional Pasty $9.83
Gluten Free Sheboygan Pasty $10.87
Oktoberfest Pasty $8.80
April – Mushroom Swiss Pasty $8.80
March – Reuben Pasty $8.28
June – Buffalo Chicken Pasty $8.28
South African Peri Peri Pasty $8.80
April – Chicken Cordon Bleu Pasty $8.28
All-American Cheeseburger Pasty $8.28
BBQ Pasty $8.28
DECEMBER – Sheep & Steer Pasty $8.28
Green & Gold Pasty $8.80
February – Cajun Pasty $9.06
Southwest Chorizo Pasty $8.28
November Thanksgiving Pasty $8.80
August – Thai Chicken Pasty $9.32
Pizza Pasty $8.80
May – Philly Cheesesteak Pasty $8.80
Spicy Sheboygan Pasty $8.28
January – Hawaiian Pasty $8.80
December Spicy Traditional Pasty $7.76
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pasty $8.28
Frozen Pasties
FROZEN Traditional Pasty $7.24
FROZEN Italian Pasty $7.76
FROZEN Sheboygan Pasty $7.76
FROZEN Veggie Pasty $6.73
FROZEN GF Traditional Pasty $10.35
FROZEN GF Italian Pasty $10.87
FROZEN GF June – Buffalo Chicken Pasty $8.28
FROZEN Reuben $8.28
FROZEN GF Sheboygan Pasty $10.87
FROZEN Southwest Chorizo Pasty $8.28
FROZEN Breakfast Pasty $8.28
Par Baked Pasties
PAR BAKED August Thai Chicken Pasty $9.32
PAR BAKED Southwest Chorizo Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED Traditional Pasty $7.24
PAR BAKED Italian Pasty $7.76
PAR BAKED Sheboygan Pasty $7.76
PAR BAKED Veggie Pasty $6.73
PAR BAKED GF Traditional Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED Breakfast Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED BBQ Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED January – Hawaiian Pasty $8.80
PAR BAKED December Pasty $7.76
PAR BAKED February Cajun Pasty $9.06
PAR BAKED Reuben Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED April – Chicken Cordon Bleu Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED – Chicken Bacon Ranch Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED May – Philly Cheesesteak Pasty $8.80
PAR BAKED – Greek Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED Spicy Sheboygan Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED All-American Cheeseburger Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED – Green & Gold Pasty $8.80
PAR BAKED DECEMBER – Sheep & Steer Pasty $8.28
PAR BAKED South African Peri Peri Pasty $8.80
PAR BAKED Pizza Pasty $8.80
Sides
Deep Fried Mini Pasties $10.35
French Fries $4.14
Onion Rings $5.18
Sweet Potato Fries $4.92
Homemade Chili $3.11
Kettle Chips – Sea Salt $1.55
Kettle Chips – BBQ $1.55
Kettle Chips – Cheddar $1.55
Kettle Chips – Jalapeno $1.55
Desserts
Cheesecake $5.18
Sayklly’s Fudgie Pasty $2.07
Apple Dessert Pasty $3.62
Sayklly’s Yooper Bar (Milk Chocolate) $1.55
Sayklly’s Caramel Bar $1.29
Sayklly’s Maple Walnut Fudge $7.25
Cherry Mini Pie $3.25
Dark Chocolate Trenary Toast $3.11
Sayklly’s Yooper Bar (Dark Chocolate) $1.55
Pumpkin Mini Pie $4.14
Apple Mini Pie $4.14
Sayklly’s Salt Water Taffy (16oz) $3.11
Sayklly’s Salt Water Taffy (8oz) $3.11
Milk Chocolate Trenary Toast $3.11
Sayklly’s Cholate Peanut Butter Fudge $7.25
Sayklly’s Trail Mix $3.11
Sayklly’s Peanut Brittle $5.95
Raspberry Nutella Dessert Pasty $3.62
Trenary Tart Cherry Toast $8.80
Trenary Cinnamon Toast $7.76
Trenary Cinnamon Raisin Toast $8.80
Trenary Cardamom Toast $8.80
Trenary Cinnamon Chocolate Chip Toast $8.80
U.P. Gift Basket $25.88
Keweenaw Kitchen’s Blueberry Jam $7.25
Keweenaw Kitchen’s Seedless Blackberry Jam $7.25
Keweenaw Kitchen’s Peach-Apricot Jam $7.25
Keweenaw Kitchen’s Raspberry Jam $7.25
Keweenaw Kitchens Sweet-Hot Pepper Jam $7.25
Keweenaw Kitchens Strawberry Rhubarb Jam $7.25
Kissinger’s Maple Syrup $13.46
Keweenaw Kitchen’s Trippleberry Jam $7.25
Keweenaw Kitchen’s Thimbleberry Jam $17.59
Jumbo Date Bar $4.14
Chocolate & Peanut Butter Bar $4.14
Strawberry Rhubarb Bar $4.14
Beverages
Sprite $1.55
Coke $1.55
Diet Coke $1.55
Bottle Water $1.55

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Bridget H
I found this on google maps when searching for some interesting local food. I got the traditional u.p. pasty with beef, rutabaga, carrots and onions. It was exceptional and cooked to perfection. The crust is perfect, it’s flavorful and tender without being doughy. With or without gravy, it’s delectable. You can also get frozen ones to bake at home. I haven’t tried the breakfast pasty yet but, I feel certain that I won’t be disappointed. The chocolate “pasty” they sell is made elsewhere but, yummy. The employees offer service with a smile. I only gave it 4 stars because there is no atmosphere. I recommend ordering ahead and getting curbside delivery.

… more

thisis hybrid
Great flavour and generous sizes. A very hearty meal that reminds me of home.

… more

Jessi F
These pasties are delicious! I always loved Rainier’s 4 of a kind, so they continued their good food with the pasties! I will be back! Photos are of the Traditional with gravy.

… more

John Michaels
I had the Sheboygan. Great job! Really, REALLY GOOD! I loved the gravy as well!

… more

Josh Bailie
Very tasty pasty! If only they had steak!

… more

T J
The traditional was not as good as the one I got when I was in the UP, what was still pretty good

… more

Erick Kivi
Great pasty, almost as good as back home in the UP I come up from Milwaukee for these and it’s definitely worth the trip

… more

Arlen Brunsvold
Pretty local good pasties. Located inside Ranieris Four if a Kind bar.

… more

Jenny Floria
Some of the best authentic U.P. pasties you can get south of Marinette, MI. The Sheboygan pasty made w brats and cheddar is also a special treat. I ordered online and they were still warm when I picked them up. Yum!!!

… more

Jack Kosmoski
OMG – really good pastys. The best I’ve had. We’re going to go back and buy a bunch to bring home too.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch