Classic American steaks, chops & seafood pair with craft beer & whiskey in unpretentious digs. Based on 401 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5006 E Jelinek Ave, Weston, WI 54476
Phone: (715) 298-2903
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Josie Smith
It’s hard to even know where to start. The whole evening was amazing. We were early for our reservation and to our surprise they seated us immediately. Every course came out quickly and perfectly timed. We never waited which was awesome. The pork belly is divine. The best pork belly I think I’ve ever had. The pickles with it were okay,but I would have been just happy with the plain pork belly. It was so good. Every course was more perfect than the last. My only complaint of the whole evening in fact was that my steak was extremely salty. I couldn’t finish an otherwise absolutely perfect steak,but the rest of the food was perfectly seasoned. Maybe the chef dropped the salt shaker or something because they sure knocked everything else out of the park. They must have a very talented pastry chef because the deserts were just amazing. The key lime pie is sweet and tangy and the chocolate cake is absolute perfection. It was better than my grandma made(sorry grandma)and that’s a difficult achievement. Service was excellent and our waitress knew just when to pop in. The restaurant was nice and clean and the ambiance was great. Overall it was a wonderful experience. We will definitely be back for more date nights in the future! 10 out of 10.
… more
Rob Indrebo
I wore a T-shirt and shorts and the staff still treated us as royalty. The food is phenomenal and the steak was cooked to perfection. It’s the place for a Wisconsin old fashion and a great meal.
… more
Jennifer Stegall
Most amazing food ever! Little pricey but so worth it. I will definitely go back! My waiter/bartender was the best. You know he enjoys his job. He just bragged constantly about the owner the other staff etc…. He made the experience even better.
… more
Mai Lee Yang
Great service and delicious steaks done right We’ve gone here to celebrate birthdays and anniversaries. Our service is always superb! Shout out to Becca our waitress the other day.
… more
David Olson
Delightful evening at Wish celebrating a friends anniversary. Three out of four had wonderful food, two fillets, one shrimp scampi and one $42 ribeye steak. All were exceptional ( and less expensive ) except the ribeye steak which was tough, stringy, and dry. Unfortunately colored all of our meals. Took most of it home for the dog. Special evening is not so special with one bad meal. Waitress asked how our meal was.. her response was, I’m sorry. …we were too!! Don’t order the ribeye..
… more
Pete Fuller
We were so pleased to have dined at this fin establishment. Our server was delightful which usually is an indication of the food quality. The salads were remarkable with an explosion of flavor and we all just continuously shared. The apps were scrumptious and the cheese chiefs had such an authentic texture and flavor.
… more
Beth Damp
Excellent food and wonderful service from Cindy. House made pickles were great. The only thing we had problems with was with the online reservation system and phoning the restaurant. Eventually got through to them via FB messenger.
… more
Marge Keller
We went there to celebrate our birthdays and anniversary, Kyle our server was absolutely awesome. Can’t really decide if the service was better than the food or the food was better than the service the steak was to die for you could cut it with your fork and the crème brûlée was out of this world kudos to all of you you do an excellent job.
… more
Amber Lambrecht
Our dinner last night was exceptional! Flatbread and steaks were perfect. Our waitress, Cindy, was funny and very sweet. Highly recommend the key lime pie! Overall a wonderful experience.
… more
Pam Jirschele
The food, atmosphere and staff were fabulous! Steaks cooked perfectly and wonderful sides …. loved the cucumbers! Will definitely be back and highly recommend!
… more
… View more